Energy Transport and Heating by Non-Thermal Electrons in a Turbulent Solar Flare Environment
A. Gordon Emslie, Eduard P. Kontar · 2026
Read Energy Transport and Heating by Non-Thermal Electrons in a Turbulent Solar Flare Environment by A. Gordon Emslie, Eduard P. Kontar (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-26276.txt.
Introduction
Emslie and Kontar model how fast electrons deposit heat in a turbulent solar flare. Past models stressed scattering from Coulomb collisions inside the plasma. The authors add strong angular scattering from turbulent centres and solve for the electron flux in both regimes. They find turbulent scattering can raise coronal heating by about tenfold. It also cuts chromospheric heating and weakens the return current, making its heating effect minor next to direct collisional heating.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | A. Gordon Emslie, Eduard P. Kontar |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38303 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.26276
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Energy Transport and Heating by Non-Thermal Electrons in a Turbulent Solar Flare Environment A. Gordon Emslie, Eduard P. Kontar Abstract The impulsive phase of a solar flare is known to generate strong turbulence and to transfer magnetic energy into accelerated electrons. Recognizing the importance of angular diffusion on the dynamics of the accelerated electrons, we extend previous treatments by deriving analytic solutions for the electron flux and associated energy deposition in two regimes: scattering dominated by inelastic Coulomb collisions and scattering dominated by elastic interactions with turbulent scattering centers. We show that the turbulence-dominated scattering term strongly reshapes the spatial distribution of the plasma heating: compared to the traditional collisional thick-target approach, turbulent scattering could lead to an order-of-magnitude increase in coronal heating and an even greater suppression of chromospheric heating. Scattering also acts to reduce the anisotropy of the electron distribution and so reduces the net current associated with the nonthermal electrons. The return-current Ohmic heating is accordingly reduced to a level that renders it negligible compared to direct collisional heating. The results have significant implications for models of atmospheric response to impulsive phase energy release, in particular chromospheric evaporation, flare-driven coronal heating, the formation of loop-top hard X-ray sources, and the longstanding discrepancy between modeled and observed soft X-ray line profiles. show][email protected] show][email protected] I Introduction There is growing evidence that a high level of plasma turbulence is created during the impulsive-phase energy release of a solar flare. Turbulent flows are a natural consequence of the high Reynolds number in the solar corona ( 67 , e.g.,) , and turbulence is often invoked as a means to enhance the plasma resistivity to the extent necessary to drive magnetic reconnection on timescales compatible with those of the impulsive phase of a flare ( 20 , see, e.g.,) . As the plasma turbulence is spatially and temporally well‑correlated with the power in accelerated electrons, it suggests that turbulence itself plays an active role in the flare energy‑transfer process ( 46 ; 72 ) . 14 have shown that suppression of heat conduction by turbulence can help explain the relatively long cooling times that are ubiquitously observed in post-flare loops ( 61 ; 70 ; 38 ) , thus reducing the level of heating previously thought to be required in the post-impulsive phase of a flare. 31 ( 21 , see also) showed that a turbulence-dominated mean free path in the corona leads to a weaker temperature dependence of the thermal conduction coefficient ( 71 , from its T^{5/2} behavior for collisional transport;) and so to shallower temperature gradients in the relatively cool lower corona and hence a greater amount of material at temperatures \,\lower 3.0pt\hbox{$\sim$}\hbox to0.0pt{\hss\raise 2.0pt\hbox{$<$}}\,10^{6} K. The correspondingly enhanced differential emission measure at such levels in the atmosphere offers a possible resolution to a long-standing enigma (see, e.g., 36 , and references therein) regarding the discrepancy between modeling results and the observationally-inferred behavior of the differential emission measure at low coronal temperatures. EUV and soft X ray spectral lines observed during flares frequently exhibit widths that are significantly in excess of the thermal Doppler width ( 8 ; 3 ; 57 ; 37 ; 66 ; 22 , e.g.,) , strongly indicating the presence of some form of turbulence. Indeed, 46 have shown that high levels of turbulence, as evidenced by excess broadening of soft X-ray spectral lines, are present in coronal regions where flare energy release occurs, and they further showed that the energy content in the turbulence, coupled with the relatively short timescales over which turbulence is created and dissipated, makes turbulent motions a very effective conduit of energy from the chaotic dissipation of magnetic field in the region of primary energy release to other forms of energy ( 24 , e.g., non-thermal electrons, heating, mass motions;) that drive the flare. 72 showed that turbulence can be distributed throughout the flaring region, and is often greatest in the coronal loop tops, where higher energy electrons suffer stronger scattering ( 62 ) . Several studies ( 44 ; 13 ; 14 ; 29 ; 6 ) have considered the effects of turbulent scattering on energy transport by thermal conduction, and recently ( 27 ; 28 ) the effects of turbulent scattering on the electrical resistivity of the ambient medium, and so on the Ohmic heating effected by beam-neutralizing return currents ( 43 ; 26 ; 16 ; 51 ; 74 ; 76 ; 77 ; 2 ) has also been considered. It is widely accepted ( 24 ; 9 ; 10 , e.g.,) that a very significant component of the energy released during a solar flare appears in the form of a beam of nonthermal electrons, accelerated in the primary energy release site. Complete consistency of any treatment of impulsive-phase energy transport in a turbulent environment must, therefore, also consider the effects of turbulent scattering on the energy deposition rate effected by the passage of such a beam of nonthermal electrons through the ambient solar atmosphere. The transfer of energy from the non-thermal electrons to the ambient atmosphere proceeds through two main processes: direct collisions of beam electrons on ambient electrons and Ohmic heating associated with driving the beam-neutralizing return current through the finite resistivity of the ambient plasma. In a turbulent medium, the electron trajectories are also affected by scattering off turbulent inhomogeneities. Although such (elastic) collisions do not constitute an additional energy transfer mechanism per se between the nonthermal electrons and the ambient solar atmosphere, they do alter the trajectories of the electrons, resulting in a modification of the spatio-spectral distribution of the electron spectrum and hence the associated heating rate ( 44 ) . The present work explores an electron transport model in which the energy loss still takes place through Coulomb collisions on ambient electrons and/or Ohmic heating associated with the driving of the beam-neutralizing return current, but in which the electron trajectories include the effects of scattering, either through inelastic Coulomb collisions or through elastic scattering off turbulent scattering centers. If the turbulence scattering length \lambda_{T} is large compared to the collisional mean free path for an electron of a specified energy E , then turbulent scattering can be neglected; the scattering is then dominated by Coulomb collisions. In such a situation the collisional mean free path is somewhat less than the total travel distance and so the electrons propagate diffusively. This results ( 30 ) in an energy deposition vs. depth profile that is rather similar to that in traditional non-diffusive treatments in which the electron transport is modeled by computing the dynamics of scatter-free particles ( 63 ; 55 ; 4 ; 54 ; 6 ) . For field-aligned injection ( 30 , Figure 1 of) the heating profiles in a collisional diffusive model are similar in magnitude to those calculated using a non-diffusive model, but in general vary more smoothly with distance from the injection site; the local heating rate differs from that of the non-diffusive model by at most a factor \sim 2 . For isotropic injection, the differences between the diffusive and non-diffusive treatments are even smaller; the diffusive heating profiles are very similar to the non-diffusive results ( 30 , Figure 1 of) . More significant differences