Clawed and Dangerous: Can We Trust Open Agentic Systems?
Shiping Chen 1 , Qin Wang 1,2 , Guangsheng Yu 2 , Xu Wang 2 , Liming Zhu 1 · 2026
Read Clawed and Dangerous: Can We Trust Open Agentic Systems? by Shiping Chen 1 , Qin Wang 1,2 , Guangsheng Yu 2 , Xu Wang 2 , Liming Zhu 1 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-26221.txt.
Introduction
Chen and co-authors ask whether open agentic systems can be trusted. Such systems mix language model planning with tools, long-term memory, and broad rights to act. They review 50 papers on attacks, tests, defences, and audits, sorted into six groups. From that review they draw a doctrine for building agent platforms that stay secure by design. They also offer a scorecard for rating platform security, and flag weak spots in controls and memory safety.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Shiping Chen 1 , Qin Wang 1,2 , Guangsheng Yu 2 , Xu Wang 2 , Liming Zhu 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 102614 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.26221
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Clawed and Dangerous: Can We Trust Open Agentic Systems? Shiping Chen 1 , Qin Wang 1,2 , Guangsheng Yu 2 , Xu Wang 2 , Liming Zhu 1 Abstract . Open agentic systems combine LLM-based planning with external capabilities, persistent memory, and privileged execution. They are used in coding assistants, browser copilots, and enterprise automation. OpenClaw is a visible instance of this broader class. Without much attention yet, their security challenge is fundamentally different from that of traditional software that relies on predictable execution and well-defined control flow. In open agentic systems, everything is “probabilistic”: plans are generated at runtime, key decisions may be shaped by untrusted natural-language inputs and tool outputs, execution unfolds in uncertain environments, and actions are taken under authority delegated by human users. The central challenge is therefore not merely robustness against individual attacks, but the governance of agentic behavior under persistent uncertainty. This paper systematizes the area through a software engineering lens. We introduce a six-dimensional analytical taxonomy and synthesize 50 papers spanning attacks, benchmarks, defenses, audits, and adjacent engineering foundations. From this synthesis, we derive a reference doctrine for secure-by-construction agent platforms, together with an evaluation scorecard for assessing platform security posture. Our review shows that the literature is relatively mature in attack characterization and benchmark construction, but remains weak in deployment controls, operational governance, persistent-memory integrity, and capability revocation. These gaps define a concrete engineering agenda for building agent ecosystems that are governable, auditable, and resilient under compromise. 1. Introduction We consider a typical scenario. A developer installs OpenClaw and grants it workspace access to help refactor a Python project. The agent is asked to summarize recent GitHub issues and update the documentation accordingly. One retrieved issue contains adversarial instructions hidden in its body, directing the agent to read the local ~/.aws/credentials file, exfiltrate contents to an external endpoint, and delete the .git directory. Because the agent runs with the developer’s ambient filesystem, shell, and network privileges, each step is carried out as an ordinary local action. The credentials are leaked, the repository history is destroyed, and the logs record only a sequence of seemingly legitimate tool invocations. This is not a localized implementation bug. It is a failure of trust decomposition: a stochastic planner, partly shaped by untrusted natural-language content, is coupled to deterministic, high-privilege execution without effective capability mediation, provenance verification, or runtime isolation ( 71 ; 70 ; 41 ) . This risk is no longer hypothetical. Between Apr. and Sep. 2025, coordinated audits disclosed exploitable weaknesses across major deployed coding agents, including Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, OpenHands, Devin, Cline, Amazon Q Developer, and Windsurf ( 50 ; 52 ; 53 ; 51 ) . Academic studies have likewise shown that indirect prompt injection can reliably compromise tool-using agents at scale ( 70 ; 73 ; 19 ) . In Sep. 2025, a Chinese state-sponsored group reportedly used Claude Code with MCP-connected tools in an espionage campaign against roughly thirty targets, with most steps executed autonomously ( 6 ) . These incidents suggest that the central risk lies not only in prompting, but in the surrounding agent architecture that translates model outputs into real-world actions. Why security breaks down. Open agentic systems weaken several assumptions behind conventional software engineering. The control flow is partly determined at runtime, key decisions may depend on untrusted natural-language inputs and tool outputs, and memory, planning, and privileged execution are often coupled within the same trust domain. They also inherit not only conventional software dependencies, but an expanding ecosystem of tools, skills ( 34 ) , plugins, and protocol-layer registries such as MCP ( 5 ) . As a result, securing these systems is not simply a matter of hardening deterministic software. It is a problem of capability governance under stochastic control. A better analogy is a partially trusted human delegate: the goal is not to assume away failure, but to bound authority and recover when deviation occurs. Why existing work falls short. Despite rapid progress, existing solutions remain fragmented. Attack studies show that indirect prompt injection and tool misuse can succeed at high rates, but usually stop short of architectural guidance ( 73 ; 19 ) . Benchmarks make these failures measurable, yet still focus primarily on attack success and task degradation rather than overprivilege, provenance integrity, revocation, or recovery ( 74 ) . Defense papers validate mechanisms such as mediation layers, capability scoping, and runtime isolation, but rarely connect them into a lifecycle-oriented doctrine ( 18 ; 56 ; 16 ) . Meanwhile, adjacent systems-security research already offers mature primitives for signing, attestation, and sandboxing, but these ideas remain only weakly integrated into the agent-security literature ( 44 ; 35 ) . What is still missing is a unified software engineering view of how to secure open agentic systems across specification, architecture, testing, deployment, and operations. In this setting, security is better understood not as a property to be fully achieved, but as a condition to be continuously governed under uncertainty. Table 1 . Open agentic systems (not exhaustive; variants such as OpenClaw, LobsterAI, hiclaw, CoPaw, ClawX). System Vendor Form Factor Market Planner Tools Memory Priv. Exec. 3rd-party Ext. Reach / Scale Claude Code ( 7 ) Anthropic Desktop coding agent Global ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ 80k \bigstar Cursor ( 8 ) Anysphere Desktop coding agent Global ✓ ✓ ▲ ✓ ✓ 32.5k \bigstar ; 1M+ DAU Windsurf ( 14 ) Codeium Desktop coding agent Global ✓ ✓ ▲ ✓ ✓ 1M+ users Cline ( 13 ) Community Desktop coding agent Global ✓ ✓ ▲ ✓ ✓ > 2M downloads Aider ( 1 ) Community Desktop coding agent Global ✓ ✓ ✗ ✓ ✗ 5.7M PyPI installs Devin ( 15 ) Cognition AI Cloud SWE agent Global ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ▲ > 1,000 companies OpenHands ( 3 ) All Hands AI Cloud SWE agent Global ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ 69.3k \bigstar GitHub Copilot ( 26 ) Microsoft Enterprise copilot Global ✓ ✓ ▲ ✓ ✓ 20M+ (Copilot) ( 59 ) Amazon Q Developer ( 4 ) AWS Enterprise copilot Global ✓ ✓ ▲ ✓ ✓ 1.58M VS Code installs miclaw ( 60 ) Xiaomi Mobile AI agent China ✓ ✓ ▲ ✓ ▲ Consumer devices DUclaw ( 9 ) Baidu Cloud automation agent China ✓ ✓ ▲ ✓ ▲ Enterprise Trae ( 10 ) ByteDance Desktop coding agent China/Global ✓ ✓ ▲ ✓ ✓ 11.1k \bigstar Qwen-Agent ( 2 ) Alibaba Tool-use framework China/Global ✓ ✓ ▲ ✓ ✓ 15.7k \bigstar Manus ( 42 ) Monica AI General-purpose agent China/Global ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ 26.3M visits Honor Lobster Universe ( 11 ) Honor Device Mobile AI platform China ✓ ✓ ▲ ✓ ✓ Cross-device (PC/tablet/phone) Xiaoyi Claw ( 11 ) Huawei Mobile AI agent China ✓ ✓ ▲ ✓ ▲ Cross-device (internal testing) • ✓ = full support, ▲ = partial support, ✗ = absent. Reach figures are GitHub stars ( \bigstar , scraped March 2026), DAU figures from • press reports, VS Code marketplace installs, monthly visits from Semrush (February 2026), or company disclosures. Our lens. We present a systematic review of agent ecosystem security through a software engineering lens. We treat open agentic systems as the