The muon charge asymmetry and the directional distribution of thunderstorm events observed by the GRAPES-3 muon telescope
S. Shibata · 2026
Read The muon charge asymmetry and the directional distribution of thunderstorm events observed by the GRAPES-3 muon telescope by S. Shibata (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-26112.txt.
Introduction
Hariharan and co-authors link a lopsided pattern in thunderstorm muon data to the muon charge ratio. Thunderstorm fields change the flow of cosmic ray muons at the ground. The GRAPES-3 telescope logged such events for a decade. Nearly six times more events came from the east than the west. Simulations show the cause is the muon charge imbalance across the sky. The geomagnetic field filters mostly positive primaries in a slanted way. With a fixed charge ratio, the lopsided pattern vanishes in the models.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | S. Shibata |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40463 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.26112
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The muon charge asymmetry and the directional distribution of thunderstorm events observed by the GRAPES-3 muon telescope S. Shibata Abstract The electric fields inside thunderstorms can significantly modify the intensity of secondary cosmic ray muons at the ground level, producing measurable variations in their intensity ( Δ \Delta I μ ). By utilizing the decade-long observations of thunderstorms (April 2011–December 2020) by the GRAPES-3 muon telescope (G3MT), a directional asymmetry in Δ \Delta I μ is observed, with nearly six times more events being detected from the east than the west directions. Using detailed CORSIKA Monte Carlo simulations, it is shown that this asymmetry is caused by the variations of the muon charge ratio R μ (N μ + {}_{\mu^{+}} /N μ − {}_{\mu^{-}} ). The anisotropic R μ in turn, is caused by the systematic changes in geomagnetic cutoff rigidities, and subsequent selective filtering of predominantly positively charged primary cosmic rays. As a consequence, the R μ increases systematically from west to east across the G3MT field of view, enhancing the sensitivity of east directions to positively charged thunderstorm top. Monte Carlo simulations with constant R μ show that the directional asymmetry disappears, demonstrating the muon charge imbalance to be the dominant driver of the observed asymmetry. The dependence of R μ on the hadronic interaction is also studied by comparing seven combinations high-, and low-energy hadronic interaction generators, which show a ≲ \lesssim 7% spread in R μ , and ≲ \lesssim 14% variation in the derived thunderstorm potentials. These results provide the first quantitative link between the muon charge asymmetry caused by the geomagnetic field, and the directional distribution of thunderstorms, reinforcing the role of muon observations as a probe of gigavolt potentials in atmospheric electrical structures. 1 Introduction The study of primary cosmic ray (PCR) interactions in the atmosphere has long provided a window into both the high-energy interactions, as well as the atmospheric electrodynamics. The PCRs undergo interactions after entering the atmosphere, producing cascades of secondary mesons that eventually decay into muons, and neutrinos [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . Because the muons are highly penetrating particles and largely retain the directional memory of their parent mesons, their intensity and charge composition at the surface carries signatures of PCR composition, and that of the environmental influences [ 4 , 5 ] . The muon charge ratio R μ , defined as the ratio of numbers of the positive (N {}_{\mu^{+}} ), and negative muons (N {}_{\mu^{-}} ) is a sensitive observable encapsulating the production, and propagation of the charged secondaries. Early ground-based measurements reported R μ = 1.26 in the multi-GeV range, while the later precision measurements by MUTRON [ 6 , 7 ] , CMS [ 8 ] , and MINOS [ 9 , 10 ] experiments confirmed this ratio, and its mild energy dependence up to the TeV scale. The underground, and mountain based experiments have also shown that R μ depends on the zenith angle, and the geomagnetic latitude [ 11 , 12 ] . The directional dependence of muon intensity, commonly known as the “east–west” effect, was first discovered in the 1930s [ 11 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 12 , 13 , 19 , 14 ] . This asymmetry originates from the geomagnetic field, which differentially filters PCRs according to their charge sign, and rigidity. Predominantly, positively charged PCRs from the east experience stronger magnetic deflection than those from the west, resulting in a lower flux from the east due to higher cutoff rigidities [ 20 ] . Subsequent studies demonstrated that this geomagnetic filtering translates into measurable asymmetries in the muon intensity, and their charge ratio at the ground level [ 21 ] . At the geomagnetic latitude of Ooty (11.4 ∘ N), where the cutoff rigidity ranges from \sim 15 GV in the west to \sim 24 GV in the east [ 22 ] – such directional effects cause significant variations in R μ . In addition to the geomagnetic effects, the atmospheric electric fields produced inside major thunderstorms also influence the muon intensity. Early balloon, and aircraft experiments detected vertical electric fields of several hundred kV/m, and potentials of \sim 100 million volts [ 23 , 24 ] . More recently, the GRAPES-3 experiment provided the first direct evidence for gigavolt potential in a thunderstorm by correlating short-term variations in muon intensity with simultaneous measurements of electric field on the ground [ 25 , 26 ] . The underlying physics involves either acceleration or deceleration of the charged muons traversing the thunderstorm region, which depends on the polarity of the muon, and the orientation of electric field inside the thunderstorm, leading to either excess or deficit in the ground-level muon intensity [ 27 , 28 , 29 , 30 ] . This mechanism forms the basis of interpretation of thunderstorm induced muon intensity variations ( \Delta I μ ) observed by the GRAPES-3 muon telescope (G3MT) [ 25 , 26 ] , Mt. Norikura [ 31 ] , Telescope Array [ 32 ] , HAWC [ 33 , 34 ] , LHASSO [ 35 ] , etc. However, a highly directional asymmetry in the frequency of thunderstorms is observed in the G3MT data, wherein number of events recorded in the east are six times larger than in the west directions. Explanation of this directional asymmetry is obtained with the aid of CORSIKA Monte Carlo simulations [ 36 ] . In the CORSIKA package different combinations of high-, and low-energy hadronic interaction generators are used to simulate the muon intensity throughout the atmosphere. These simulations show that the value of R μ in the G3MT field of view (FOV) varies, systematically increasing from the west ( \approx 1.14) to the east ( \approx 1.37) direction. The regions with a higher R μ display larger variations in the muon intensity for the same thunderstorm potential resulting in a larger number of events from the east than the west directions. The interplay of hadronic physics, geomagnetic effects, and thunderstorm electric fields has been explored in several previous theoretical work [ 37 , 38 , 39 ] , but the explicit link between the muon charge asymmetry and the directional dependence of detected thunderstorms has not been quantitatively investigated. Recent GRAPES-3 analyses demonstrated that the inferred thunderstorm potential depends weakly ( \lesssim 14%) on the choice of hadronic interaction generators [ 26 ] . This highlights the need for improved modeling of muon production, which influences the detection of thunderstorm by G3MT. Results from other major experiments provide evidence that the thunderstorm electric fields significantly impact the intensity of charged secondaries including muons [ 31 , 32 , 33 , 34 , 35 ] . The present work builds on the body of existing work by investigating the factors affecting R μ , which in turn influences the directional distribution of thunderstorm events. In the present study, 487 events recorded by the G3MT between April 2011 and December 2020 are analyzed. As mentioned above, these data show a strong directional asymmetry, with about six times more events being observed from the east than the west directions. By using CORSIKA Monte Carlo simulations, the directional dependence