I Want to Believe (but the Vocabulary Changed): Measuring the Semantic Structure and Evolution of Conspiracy Theories

Manisha Keim, Sarmad Chandio, Osama Khalid, Rishab Nithyanand · 2026

Read I Want to Believe (but the Vocabulary Changed): Measuring the Semantic Structure and Evolution of Conspiracy Theories by Manisha Keim, Sarmad Chandio, Osama Khalid, Rishab Nithyanand (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-26062.txt.

Introduction

Keim and co-authors track how the meanings of conspiracy theories shift over a decade of online talk. They study 169.9 million comments from Reddit's politics forum, from 2012 to 2022. Conspiracy language forms clear, distinct regions in word space, they show. That lets each theory be treated as a semantic object. Aligned embeddings then follow those objects across time. Theories grow, shrink, hold steady, or get replaced in uneven ways. Keyword counts alone miss these moves, the authors argue.

Catalog record

CREATORManisha Keim, Sarmad Chandio, Osama Khalid, Rishab Nithyanand
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE62512
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.26062

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

I Want to Believe (but the Vocabulary Changed): Measuring the Semantic Structure and Evolution of Conspiracy Theories Manisha Keim, Sarmad Chandio, Osama Khalid, Rishab Nithyanand Abstract Research on conspiracy theories largely focusses on belief formation, exposure, and diffusion, while paying less attention to how their meanings change over time. This gap persists partly because conspiracy-related terms are often treated as stable lexical markers, making it difficult to separate genuine semantic changes from surface-level vocabulary changes. In this paper, we measure the semantic structure and evolution of conspiracy theories in online political discourse. Using 169.9M comments from Reddit’s r/politics subreddit spanning 2012-2022, we first demonstrate that conspiracy-related language forms coherent and semantically distinguishable regions of language space, allowing conspiracy theories to be treated as semantic objects . We then track how these objects evolved over time using aligned word embeddings, enabling comparisons of semantic neighborhoods across time. Our analysis reveals that conspiracy theories evolve non-uniformly, exhibiting patterns of semantic stability, expansion, contraction, and replacement that are not captured by keyword-based approaches alone. 1 Introduction In November 2016, a gunman enters Comet Ping Pong pizzeria in Washington, D.C USA, firing an AR-15 rifle to “self-investigate” claims that the restaurant harbors a child trafficking ring run by Democratic Party officials. The conspiracy theory that motivates this attack, “Pizzagate”, begins as specific accusations about a single pizza restaurant connected to Hillary Clinton’s campaign chairman. By 2020, however, “Pizzagate” becomes absorbed into the QAnon conspiracy theory, linking not just to child trafficking but to claims about a global cabal of elites, deep state actors, and institutional control. While the term “Pizzagate” remains constant across these years, its meaning, the concepts, actors, and narratives it encompasses, fundamentally transforms and fragments. This illustrates a fundamental challenge: disambiguating semantic evolution (changes in what a conspiracy theory means) from lexical churn (changes in the vocabulary used to express it). While existing research predominantly focuses on who believes conspiracy theories, how they spread, and what psychological factors drive belief formation ( 6 ; 5 ; 26 ) , understanding how conspiracy theories change in meaning over time remains critically understudied. Traditional keyword-based approaches ( 10 ) track specific terms like “pizzagate” or “deep state”, but cannot distinguish between three fundamentally different processes: (i) the term itself persists while its underlying meaning transforms, (ii) the meaning remains stable while the vocabulary changes entirely, and (iii) a single theory fragments into multiple interpretations referenced by the same term. By drawing on distributional semantics, we move beyond isolated keywords to use semantic neighborhoods , the collections of terms that consistently co-occur with conspiracy theories and define what they actually mean in discourse. This approach allows us to define semantic objects : coherent regions bounded by semantic neighborhoods . We use these as stable units of analysis that represent a conspiracy theory’s meaning at a given point in space and time. This allows us to track how these objects evolve, whether they remain stable, relocate in semantic space, expand or contract, or fragment into multiple meanings — while separately measuring vocabulary turnover, revealing evolutionary patterns that prior methods fundamentally cannot capture. We develop and apply a semantic object framework to study conspiracy theory evolution in online political discourse. Using 169.9M comments from Reddit’s r/politics spanning 2012-2022, we address two research questions: • RQ1. Is language associated with conspiratorial discourse semantically distinguishable from language used in non-conspiratorial discourse? ( Section 3 ) Specifically, we ask whether conspiracy-related discourse occupies a coherent and distinguishable region of linguistic expression that is meaningfully separable from non-conspiratorial discourse. We focus on establishing this property because semantic evolution can only be meaningfully studied if conspiratorial language forms a coherent and distinguishable semantic region within the discourse under study; without such structure, neither individual conspiracy theories nor their interactions over time can be well defined as they would be diffused over the entire language. We address this question by constructing semantic neighborhoods anchored on 19 distinct conspiracy theories and evaluating their coherence and boundaries using embedding-based cluster analysis and human expert annotations. This step establishes whether the semantic neighborhoods associated with conspiracy theories can be treated as semantic objects . • RQ2. How do the semantics and lexica associated with conspiracy theories evolve over time? ( Section 4 ) Based on the findings of RQ1, we address this question by building on prior research on diachronic word embeddings ( 13 ; 18 ) to create an analysis framework that allows comparisons of semantic objects , each object representing the semantic neighborhood of an individual conspiracy theory, across time periods. These comparisons allows us to reason directly about semantic changes over time without relying on vocabulary shifts alone, thus enabling accurate tracking and characterization of the evolutionary patterns associated with individual conspiracy theories. Alongside semantic shifts, we also track changes in the lexica to capture how the language used around these theories changes even when the underlying meaning remains stable. Broadly, our findings shows that conspiracy-related discourse forms coherent and semantically distinguishable clusters, validating the use of conspiracy-related semantic objects as units in our analysis framework. We also find that conspiracy theories evolves non-uniformly, with some retaining their semantic core over long periods, others either narrowing their semantics to reflect more specific theories or broadening their semantics by absorbing concepts from other theories, and a few undergoing drastic shifts which retain little of their past meanings. We find that many of these patterns are largely invisible to approaches that are focused on lexicon or keywords alone. We also observe that political scandal conspiracies underwent semantic replacement, whereas elite control conspiracies developed multiple, diverging narratives. 2 Data and Preprocessing In this section, we describe our dataset, methods for the construction of temporal embeddings, and approach for identifying conspiracy theories and their themes. Identifying conspiracy theories and thematic concept labels. We focus on a fixed set of 19 conspiracy theories that were prominent during the period between 2012-2017 (cf. Table 1 ) 1 1 1 While this is not an exhaustive set, it serves as a proof of concept. The ideas presented here can be extended to any arbitrary conspiracy . This choice allows us to focus on examining how these theories evolve throughout the three time periods in our study, as social and political dynamics change. These conspiracy theories were curated based on prior academic literature ( 20 ; 14 ; 27 ; 26 ; 2 ; 28 ) and media reporting ( 32 ; 33 ) . These theories include well-established U.S.-centric conspiracy theories (e.g., illuminati and chemtrails), event-driven conspiracies (e.g., related to the Sandy Hook shooting and Boston bombing), and squarely political conspiracies (e.g., Emailgate and Russiagate). For each of these, we defined a concept label : a term that encapsulates the core theme of the theory and anchors it in discourse. These labels reflect how the specific theory is commonly referenced in online discussions. For example, the concept label ‘deep state’ refers to conspiracies alleging that a hidden network of government actors secretly controls U.S. policy. Each concept label serves as an entry point for identifying the surrounding discourse related to a conspiracy theory. This was inspired by prior work ( 26 ; 27 ) which described similar “overarching themes”

Read the complete text