A Human-Centered Approach to Ethical AI Education in Underresourced Secondary Schools
Valentina Kuskova, Sonia Howell, Brianna Stines, Brianna Conaghan · 2026
Read A Human-Centered Approach to Ethical AI Education in Underresourced Secondary Schools by Valentina Kuskova, Sonia Howell, Brianna Stines, Brianna Conaghan (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-26004.txt.
Introduction
Kuskova and co-authors describe a college-level course on ethical AI built for under-resourced high schools. Policy pushes AI literacy, but access alone does not build sound judgment, they argue. Their course runs with a national education network and grants college credit. It mixes self-paced lessons, near-peer mentors, and live discussion classes. Nearly 180 students at 12 Title I schools finished the first run. The completion rate was 97.8 percent. Surveys show students reasoned hard about ethical trade-offs. Teachers rated the course as rigorous and meaningful.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Valentina Kuskova, Sonia Howell, Brianna Stines, Brianna Conaghan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30965 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.26004
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Human-Centered Approach to Ethical AI Education in Underresourced Secondary Schools Valentina Kuskova, Sonia Howell, Brianna Stines, Brianna Conaghan Abstract National and international policy efforts increasingly promote AI literacy in K–12 education, yet access to AI tools alone is insufficient to ensure equitable and responsible participation, particularly in under-resourced contexts. Without designs that integrate ethical reasoning, human support, and opportunities for judgment, AI initiatives risk reinforcing inequities and preparing students to use powerful technologies without critically evaluating their societal consequences. To address this gap, we developed a human-centered, college credit–bearing course on Responsible and Ethical AI for students attending Title I and Title I–eligible high schools, implemented in partnership with the National Education Opportunity Network (NEON). The bichronous course integrates foundational AI concepts with ethical and socio-technical reasoning through asynchronous instruction, near-peer mentorship, and synchronous, discussion-based instruction. In its inaugural year, nearly 180 students from 12 U.S. schools completed the course, with a 97.8% completion rate. Using end-of-course survey data from students, co-teachers, and teaching fellows, this study examines academic agency, confidence with college-level expectations, critical engagement with responsible AI, and perceived post-secondary trajectory expansion. Results indicate that students were challenged to apply learning and reason about ethical tradeoffs, while educators reported high engagement, rigor, and meaningfulness relative to typical high school coursework. Overall, findings highlight the importance of human connections in advancing equitable Artificial Intelligence in Education and support ethical judgment as a core learning outcome alongside AI literacy. 1 Introduction: AI Literacy, Equity, and the Limits of Access National and international policy efforts increasingly emphasize expanding artificial intelligence (AI) literacy in K–12 education, framing it as a necessary response to AI’s growing role in everyday life, work, and civic decision-making [ 22 ] , [ 33 ] , [ 32 ] . In the United States, this emphasis has been formalized through executive action: an Executive Order dated April 23, 2025, in which President Trump [ 45 ] directed a federal push to expand K–12 AI education through early exposure to AI concepts and strengthened educator training. Many initiatives prioritize student exposure to AI tools and applications [ 18 ] , [ 26 ] , reflecting the assumption that familiarity will prepare learners for future academic and workforce demands. At the same time, this policy momentum has raised critical questions about how AI education can support meaningful and responsible participation in an AI-mediated society, beyond technical awareness alone [ 2 ] . Within AIED research, a central concern is that access to AI tools and curricular content alone does not produce equitable outcomes, particularly in under-resourced educational contexts [ 41 ] . Schools serving students from low-income backgrounds often face constraints in instructional capacity, infrastructure, and sustained academic support [ 42 ] , shaping how AI initiatives are implemented and experienced. This challenge is frequently described as the Artificial Intelligence in Education divide [ 1 ] : a socio-technical gap that extends beyond disparities in technology or curriculum to include differences in instructional design, pedagogical support, and opportunities for guided reflection [ 34 ] . From this perspective, equity in AI education depends not only on access, but on how learning experiences are structured and embedded within students’ educational trajectories [ 31 ] , including the social dimensions of learning such as mentorship, dialogue, and the cultivation of judgment in complex, real-world contexts. Accordingly, scholars argue for AIED approaches that move beyond technical proficiency toward ethical judgment [ 7 ] . In under-resourced contexts, developing such judgment is closely tied to human support structures [ 24 ] , including instructors, mentors, and peers who create space for discussion and sense-making. Dialogic, socio-technical, and scaffolded learning design can therefore function as equity mechanisms in Artificial Intelligence in Education [ 9 ] . Building on these insights, we developed a college credit-bearing course, Responsible & Ethical AI ( R&E AI course ), for students in Title I and Title I-eligible schools, offered in partnership with the National Education Opportunity Network (NEON) [ 38 ] . The course operationalizes ethical judgment through human-centered learning in underresourced secondary school contexts. This paper reports findings from the first implementation, using end-of-course survey data from students, co-teachers (CTs), and teaching fellows (TFs) to examine academic agency, critical engagement with responsible AI, and preparation for postsecondary pathways. By centering ethical judgment, human connections, and learning design, this study demonstrates how equity-oriented AIED approaches can be operationalized and empirically examined beyond access-focused models. 2 Related Work This study contributes to intersecting research streams in AIED, including AI literacy and critical AI education [ 46 ] , equity and access in under-resourced contexts [ 40 ] , and human-centered pedagogical approaches [ 11 ] . Rather than offering an exhaustive review, this section highlights key themes and gaps that motivate the design of the R&E AI Course . 2.1 AI Literacy and Critical AI Education AI literacy [ 37 ] has become a central focus of educational initiatives, commonly defined as understanding core AI concepts and systems [ 29 ] and interacting effectively with AI-enabled tools [ 39 ] . In K–12 contexts, AI literacy efforts typically emphasize exposure and foundational skills [ 12 ] , aiming to prepare students for AI-infused academic and workforce environments [ 6 ] . These approaches have been important in establishing AI as a topic of general education [ 27 ] . More recently, scholars have called for a shift toward critical AI literacy [ 8 ] , which foregrounds ethical reasoning, power, and social impact [ 5 ] . Critical AI education encourages learners to examine how AI systems are designed, deployed, and governed, and whose interests they serve [ 3 ] , emphasizing AI’s role in reinforcing or challenging inequality [ 13 ] . Despite strong conceptual development, such approaches have been less frequently implemented in sustained K–12 settings [ 48 ] , particularly outside well-resourced schools [ 21 ] . Across both AI literacy and critical AI education, a persistent limitation is the emphasis on skills, exposure, or attitudinal change [ 47 ] . Many programs assess conceptual understanding or tool familiarity [ 4 ] while giving limited attention to learners’ capacity for ethical judgment in realistic socio-technical contexts [ 48 ] . Consequently, ethical reasoning and decision-making under uncertainty remain under-assessed and under-supported in AI education [ 30 ] , with responsible action often assumed rather than empirically examined. 2.2 Equity, Access, and the Artificial Intelligence in Education Divide Equity is a central concern in AIED research [ 20 ] , particularly as AI learning opportunities expand unevenly across educational systems. Under-resourced and low-resource school contexts—often serving students from low-income or historically marginalized communities—face persistent challenges in adopting and sustaining AI education, including limited infrastructure, instructional capacity, and access to specialized expertise [ 1 ] , [ 9 ] . Research emphasizes that inequity in AI education extends beyond access to tools or curricula to include differences in instructional support, contextualization, and integration into educational pathways [ 23 ] , [ 36 ] . From this perspective, the Artificial Intelligence in Education divide reflects disparities in the quality and depth of engagement rather than the mere availability of AI-related content. Accordingly, scholars caution that access-oriented approaches, particularly