Revisiting the Evidence for Double Sequences of Blue Straggler Stars in Globular Clusters Facilities: HST(ACS), HST(WFPC2), HST(WFC3) Aladin sky atlas ( 8 ) , TOPCAT ( 67 ) , SAOImageDS9 ( 33 )
Gourav Kumawat, Craig O. Heinke, Alison Sills, Haldan N. Cohn, Phyllis M. Lugger, Christian Knigge, Andrea Dieball, Tyler Heise · 2026
Read Revisiting the Evidence for Double Sequences of Blue Straggler Stars in Globular Clusters Facilities: HST(ACS), HST(WFPC2), HST(WFC3) Aladin sky atlas ( 8 ) , TOPCAT ( 67 ) , SAOImageDS9 ( 33 ) by Gourav Kumawat, Craig O. Heinke, Alison Sills, Haldan N. Cohn, Phyllis M. Lugger, Christian Knigge, Andrea Dieball, Tyler Heise (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-25987.txt.
Introduction
Kumawat and co-authors retest claims of double blue straggler sequences in globular clusters. Blue stragglers are thought to form by mass transfer or by collisions. Two sequences in a cluster would hint that both channels leave separate tracks. The team uses survey photometry for 56 Galactic clusters. Dip tests find no case with strong signs of two modes. Model comparison favors one skewed group in 94 of 112 cases. For M30, the classic case, the famous dip looks like a chance feature. Later claims may just reflect skew in the color spread.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gourav Kumawat, Craig O. Heinke, Alison Sills, Haldan N. Cohn, Phyllis M. Lugger, Christian Knigge, Andrea Dieball, Tyler Heise |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 60302 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.25987
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Revisiting the Evidence for Double Sequences of Blue Straggler Stars in Globular Clusters Facilities: HST(ACS), HST(WFPC2), HST(WFC3) Aladin sky atlas ( 8 ) , TOPCAT ( 67 ) , SAOImageDS9 ( 33 ) Gourav Kumawat, Craig O. Heinke, Alison Sills, Haldan N. Cohn, Phyllis M. Lugger, Christian Knigge, Andrea Dieball, Tyler Heise Abstract Blue straggler stars (BSSs) are believed to form through mass transfer in binary systems or stellar collisions. The reported presence of double BSS sequences in some globular clusters (GCs) has been interpreted as evidence that these two formation channels produce distinct sequences in color–magnitude diagram (CMD). We reassess this claim using HST UV Globular Cluster Survey (HUGS) photometry of 56 Galactic GCs. We used the Hartigan Dip Test to test bimodality, and Akaike model comparison to test whether BSS distance distributions are better described by a mixture of two unskewed Gaussians or a skewed unimodal Gaussian model. We find no strong statistical evidence for bimodality; no cluster yields a dip test p p -value below 0.15, and Akaike model comparison favors the skewed unimodal model in 94 out of 112 cases. We re-examine NGC 7099 (M30), the prototypical case of a double BSS sequence, using three reductions of HST data. We find bimodality is detected at p = 4 × 10 − 3 4\times 10^{-3} , vs. the originally reported p ∼ 10 − 5 \sim 10^{-5} , in the original photometry. The observed uncertainties derived from the subgiant branch widths are comparable to the suggested separation between the proposed BSS sequences, making the detection of statistically significant bimodality challenging. Our results suggest that the dip between two BSS sequences in M30 photometry is a coincidence, and that later bifurcation claims can be explained as skew in the BSS color distribution, rather than two separate distributions. show][email protected] I INTRODUCTION Blue straggler stars (BSSs) were first identified by 58 in the globular cluster M3, where he noticed a distinct sequence of stars lying above and to the left of the main-sequence turnoff (MSTO) in the optical color–magnitude diagram (CMD). Their position in the CMD indicates that they are both bluer and more luminous than normal cluster main-sequence stars, implying higher masses ( 60 ; 25 ; 21 ) . However, in stellar systems as old as globular clusters (GCs), stars of such masses should have already evolved off the main sequence, suggesting that BSSs have undergone a rejuvenation process that increases their mass ( 3 ) . Because of their higher masses relative to the average cluster stars, BSS progenitors are subject to mass segregation and dynamical friction, leading to their preferential concentration toward the dense cluster core ( 42 ; 18 ) . Consequently, the distribution and physical characteristics of BSSs provide valuable insights into both the stellar and dynamical evolution of their host clusters ( 18 ) . The origin of BSSs has been a subject of extensive study since their discovery. Two main formation pathways are generally accepted ( 43 , see) : (1) mass transfer (MT) from a binary companion, ; and (2) direct stellar collisions, likely during a binary encounter. In the MT scenario, originally proposed by 44 , a (typically evolved) primary star fills its Roche lobe and transfers mass to a less massive secondary, rejuvenating it into a hotter, more massive main-sequence star. For an evolved companion, MT results in a binary of a BSS and a white dwarf, while a main-sequence companion leads to a (slow) stellar merger. The slow merger phase goes through a long-lived contact binary (or W UMa, a peanut-shaped star; 57 ) phase before final merger ( 48 , e.g.) . Both the W UMa binary itself, and the final merger product, can appear as a BSS. The second formation channel involves direct collisions between stars ( 30 ) . Although direct collisions of single non-giant stars are rare even in globular clusters, the presence of binary stars increases the likelihood of collisions, with numerical simulations demonstrating that such interactions are likely during binary–single or binary–binary encounters ( 38 ; 22 ) . In the cores of the densest GCs, where stellar interactions are frequent, both the collisional and MT mechanisms may operate simultaneously, contributing to the observed BSS population ( 23 ; 2 ; 17 ) . During the 1990s, stellar collisions were widely regarded as the dominant BSS formation channel in high-density environments, while MT in binary systems was considered more relevant in the low-density outskirts of clusters. However, 54 showed an anti-correlation between the BSS relative frequency and the total luminosity of the host cluster, with no statistically significant correlation between BSS frequency and the predicted collision rate. Instead, the BSS relative frequency seemed to clearly anti-correlate with cluster mass. This result suggested that BSS formation is not dominated by collisional processes, even in the densest clusters. By the late 2000s, accurate measurements of binary fractions and new theoretical work indicated that MT is likely to dominate the production of BSSs even within dense cluster cores ( 64 ; 34 ; 45 ) . 20 reported that the number of BSSs, when normalized to the sampled luminosity, correlates inversely with the central density of the parent cluster and positively with the binary fraction, implying that BSSs are largely produced by binaries in globular clusters. 16 , (hereafter 16 ) identified a double BSS sequence in the HST/WFPC2 F555W-F814W CMD of the post-core-collapse (PCC) cluster NGC 7099 (M30). The two sequences are separated in color, with the blue BSS sequence suggested to match collisional models ( 62 ) and the red sequence suggested to match models of mass-transfer (MT) binaries ( 68 ) . This discovery suggested that both formation channels can operate simultaneously within dense cluster cores. The coexistence of the two populations was interpreted as a possible outcome of the core-collapse (CC) process, which enhances the stellar collision rate and may drive binaries toward the mass-transfer regime through dynamical interactions in the collapsing core. Given the evolutionary timescales of BSSs, the observation of two distinct sequences suggests that a CC event in NGC 7099 occurred within the last 1–2 Gyr (F09). Following this finding, bifurcations in the BSS population have been reported in several other clusters, including NGC 362 ( 14 ) , NGC 1261 ( 63 ) , NGC 7078 (M15) ( 5 ) , NGC 6752 ( 12 ) , and NGC 6256 ( 10 ) . A bifurcation has also been reported in the young Large Magellanic Cloud cluster NGC 2173 ( 36 ) , though its reality has been questioned ( 13 ; 15 ) . If NGC 2173 indeed has a BSS bifurcation, both BSS sequences would have to be produced by primordial binaries, since it is too young and low-density to have experienced substantial collisions. Several theoretical works have attempted to explain one or both BSS sequences. 71 computed mass-transfer BSS products that matched only the red BSS sequence in M30. However, merging contact binaries (W UMa stars) were calculated to populate both sequences ( 65 ) , consistent with the presence of known W UMa stars on both sequences ( 52 ) , as noted by 16 . 31 showed that mass-transfer BSS products can