Decoder Dependence in Surface-Code Threshold Estimation with Native Gottesman-Kitaev-Preskill Digitization and Parallelized Sampling
Dennis Delali Kwesi Wayo, Chinonso Onah, Leonardo Goliatt,, Sven Groppe, · 2026
Read Decoder Dependence in Surface-Code Threshold Estimation with Native Gottesman-Kitaev-Preskill Digitization and Parallelized Sampling by Dennis Delali Kwesi Wayo, Chinonso Onah, Leonardo Goliatt,, Sven Groppe, (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-25757.txt.
Introduction
Wayo and co-authors show that surface-code threshold estimates depend strongly on the decoder used. They compare four decoders under Pauli noise and under native GKP-style digitization. The tools are MWPM, Union-Find, belief propagation, and a neural-guided MWPM. At distance five, MWPM and Union-Find form the accuracy and speed frontier. The neural-guided version is slower and less accurate, and belief propagation trails far behind. Only MWPM gives stable threshold crossings. Threaded runs speed things up while keeping statistics sound.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dennis Delali Kwesi Wayo, Chinonso Onah, Leonardo Goliatt,, Sven Groppe, |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37098 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.25757
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Decoder Dependence in Surface-Code Threshold Estimation with Native Gottesman-Kitaev-Preskill Digitization and Parallelized Sampling Dennis Delali Kwesi Wayo, Chinonso Onah, Leonardo Goliatt,, Sven Groppe, Abstract We quantify decoder dependence in surface-code threshold studies under two matched regimes: Pauli noise and native GKP-style Gaussian displacement digitization. Using LiDMaS+ v1.1.0, we benchmark MWPM, Union-Find (UF), Belief Propagation (BP), and neural-guided MWPM with fixed seeds, identical sweep grids, and unified reporting across runs 06–14. At d = 5 d=5 and σ = 0.20 \sigma=0.20 , MWPM and UF define the Pareto frontier, with (runtime, LER) = (1.341 s, 0.2273) and (1.332 s, 0.2303); neural-guided MWPM is slower and less accurate (1.396 s, 0.3730), and BP is dominated (7.640 s, 0.6107). Crossing-bootstrap diagnostics are stable only for MWPM, with median σ 3 , 5 ⋆ = 0.10 \sigma^{\star}_{3,5}=0.10 (1911/2000 valid) and σ 5 , 7 ⋆ = 0.1375 \sigma^{\star}_{5,7}=0.1375 (1941/2000 valid), while other decoders show no valid crossing samples. Dense-window scanning over σ ∈ [ 0.08 , 0.24 ] \sigma\in[0.08,0.24] returns NaN crossings for all decoders, confirming estimator- and window-sensitive threshold localization. Rank-stability and effect-size bootstrap analyses reinforce ordering robustness: BP remains rank 4, neural-guided MWPM rank 3, and MWPM-UF differences are small ( Δ MWPM − UF = − 0.00383 \Delta_{\mathrm{MWPM-UF}}=-0.00383 , 95% interval [ − 0.0104 , 0.00329 ] [-0.0104,0.00329] ) across σ ∈ [ 0.05 , 0.35 ] \sigma\in[0.05,0.35] . Threaded execution preserves statistical fidelity while improving throughput: 1.34 × 1.34\times speedup in Pauli mode and 1.94 × 1.94\times in native GKP mode, with mean | Δ LER | |\Delta\mathrm{LER}| 6.07 × 10 − 3 6.07\times 10^{-3} and 5.20 × 10 − 3 5.20\times 10^{-3} , respectively. We therefore recommend estimator-conditional threshold reporting coupled to runtime-fidelity checks for reproducible hardware-facing practical future decoder benchmarking workflows. I Introduction Fault-tolerant quantum computing depends on reliable quantum error correction (QEC), and practical QEC depends on two coupled layers: a physical noise process and a classical decoder that interprets syndrome information. In idealized discussions, one often treats “the threshold” as a code property. In practice, threshold estimation is a joint property of code geometry, noise assumptions, syndrome extraction details, decoder objective, and statistical estimator. For this reason, two studies using the same code family can report materially different threshold values when they change decoder policy, fitting procedure, or sampling protocol. This dependence has been visible from foundational topological-code analyses through modern surface-code decoder studies 15 ; 7 ; 27 ; 8 ; 6 ; 14 . This work focuses on the surface code, which remains a dominant reference architecture because of its local stabilizer structure, compatibility with planar layouts, and well-developed decoder ecosystem 8 . The decoder landscape now spans exact and near-exact matching methods, near-linear-time alternatives, and tailored-noise variants whose ranking can change with channel assumptions 6 ; 14 ; 3 ; 25 ; 24 ; 1 ; 13 ; 29 . In parallel, experimental progress has moved from repeated distance-three operation toward stronger logical suppression and below-threshold demonstrations, increasing the need for reproducible software-side comparison protocols 31 ; 17 ; 22 ; 10 ; 18 ; 9 . At the same time, emerging hardware programs increasingly motivate hybrid continuous-variable/discrete modeling choices, including GKP-inspired digitization paths and device-specific loss heterogeneity. These choices can alter both syndrome statistics and decoder behavior in ways that are not well captured by purely discrete baselines. The broader bosonic-QEC literature motivates this direction, from the original GKP encoding proposal to recent fault-tolerant and oscillator-control results in photonic and cat-qubit platforms 11 ; 26 ; 30 ; 19 ; 4 . LiDMaS+ was designed precisely to evaluate these interactions under one reproducible interface 28 . The stack exposes a unified threshold harness, multiple decoders, native GKP-inspired digitization, optional per-qubit loss maps, and consistent outputs. This makes it possible to ask a stricter question than “what is the threshold of this code”: under matched experimental controls, how much of a threshold claim is explained by decoder and estimator choices, and how much is explained by the underlying noise process. Most decoder-comparison papers face a comparability problem: implementations are benchmarked under partially mismatched sweep grids, trial counts, fit procedures, or reporting conventions. Even when each individual experiment is technically valid, cross-decoder conclusions can be difficult to interpret because differences in setup are entangled with differences in algorithmic performance. The same issue appears when transitioning from Pauli-style noise to continuous-variable-informed models: if the sampling or reporting pipeline changes at the same time as the noise model, attribution becomes ambiguous. This comparability gap is visible when juxtaposing tailored-noise studies, architecture-constrained analyses, and hardware demonstrations that necessarily use different assumptions and reporting conventions 1 ; 13 ; 2 ; 12 ; 10 ; 9 . A second problem is estimator overconfidence. Scalar threshold numbers are frequently presented without explicit crossing-validity diagnostics, bootstrap spread, or sweep-window dependence. In regimes where curves are shallow, non-monotonic, or distance-reversed over the sampled window, a single crossing estimate may be unstable or undefined. Without explicit diagnostics, these cases can be misread as robust threshold evidence. Recent studies that emphasize circuit-level effects and tailored boundary/noise structure reinforce the need to present threshold statements with explicit uncertainty and model conditions 13 ; 29 . A third problem is operational reproducibility. Large trial budgets are necessary for stable comparisons, but runtime constraints often push studies toward reduced sampling. Parallelized simulation can help, but only if serial-vs-parallel statistical agreement is checked directly. Otherwise, throughput gains may come at the cost of subtle estimator drift. This is consistent with the broader parallel-decoding literature, which treats scalability and correctness as co-requirements 21 ; 23 . The motivation for this paper is therefore methodological and practical. Methodologically, we want a decoder-comparison workflow where every major degree of freedom is explicit: noise mode, sweep design, trial budget, estimator, and post-processing logic. Practically, we want a workflow that can scale to paper-grade trial counts and still preserve reproducibility across reruns, systems, and collaborators. This follows the broader direction in decoder engineering where algorithmic speedups are meaningful only under controlled, comparable evaluation pipelines 6 ; 14 ; 3 ; 13 . The immediate application context is native GKP-informed surface-code simulation with additional gate/measurement/idle/loss controls, where decoder behavior can differ substantially from discrete Pauli expectations. In such settings, it is not enough to rank decoders by one curve snapshot. We need to evaluate runtime–accuracy trade-offs, stability across distances, sensitivity to channel components, effect sizes between decoders, and estimator robustness near candidate crossings. We also need to quantify whether parallelized sampling changes scientific conclusions or only reduces wall-clock time. This is aligned with ongoing work that connects bosonic and hybrid-encoding noise models to practical fault-tolerance analysis 11 ; 26 ; 30 ; 20 . This is especially relevant for hardware-facing decision making. A useful decoder benchmark for device teams must answer three questions simultaneously: (i) which decoder is best in the operating regime, (ii) how reliable is that conclusion under finite sampling and estimator uncertainty, and (iii) what is the computational cost of producing the evidence. Our motivation is to provide this combined view in a form that can be regenerated from scripts and raw outputs. The primary objective is to produce a reproducible and internally consistent decoder-comparison study for surface-code threshold