Parameterizing Dark Energy at the density level: A two-parameter alternative to CPL Preprint: UTWI-10-2026
Gabriele Montefalcone, Richard Stiskalek · 2026
Read Parameterizing Dark Energy at the density level: A two-parameter alternative to CPL Preprint: UTWI-10-2026 by Gabriele Montefalcone, Richard Stiskalek (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-25735.txt.
Introduction
Montefalcone and Stiskalek propose a new two-parameter way to describe dark energy. Standard practice uses the CPL form, which tracks the equation of state. Their form instead tracks the dark energy density itself, scaled to its value today. The two parameters are the density and the equation of state at one pivot redshift. They test it with DESI data, Planck priors, and supernova samples. Both parameters are tightly bounded, they report. The values sit close to the cosmological constant case. Evidence for evolving dark energy stays below three sigma.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gabriele Montefalcone, Richard Stiskalek |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 85926 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.25735
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Parameterizing Dark Energy at the density level: A two-parameter alternative to CPL Preprint: UTWI-10-2026 Gabriele Montefalcone, Richard Stiskalek Abstract We introduce a minimal two-parameter formulation of the dark energy (DE) density evolution normalized to its present-day value, f DE ( z ) ≡ ρ DE ( z ) / ρ DE , 0 f_{\rm DE}(z)\equiv\rho_{\rm DE}(z)/\rho_{\rm DE,0} , in terms of f p ≡ f DE ( z p ) f_{p}\equiv f_{\rm DE}(z_{p}) and the DE equation of state w p ≡ w ( z p ) w_{p}\equiv w(z_{p}) , at a pivot redshift z p z_{p} . This provides an alternative framework for assessing the evidence for evolving DE, complementary to the established Chevallier-Polarski-Linder (CPL) parameterization of the DE equation of state in terms of w 0 w_{0} and w a w_{a} . By parameterizing the DE density directly, the ( w p , f p ) (w_{p},\,f_{p}) formulation avoids the approximate degeneracies intrinsic to the ( w 0 , w a ) (w_{0},\,w_{a}) basis—in particular the weak sensitivity of the expansion history to w a w_{a} —while reproducing the background evolution of representative quintessence models with equivalent accuracy. Confronting it with the latest baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) measurements from DESI, a prior on early-universe parameters from Planck cosmic microwave background (CMB) observations, and Type Ia supernovae (SNe) data, we find that the w p w_{p} and f p f_{p} parameters are both tightly constrained and sensitive to distinct subsets of the data. Specifically, w p w_{p} is measured to percent-level precision by BAO and CMB alone, while f p f_{p} is pinned down by the independent matter density constraint that only SNe provide. Including the Pantheon + SNe sample, we obtain w p = − 1.04 ± 0.04 w_{p}=-1.04\pm 0.04 and f p = 1.07 ± 0.04 f_{p}=1.07\pm 0.04 , with similar results when using the DESY5 SNe sample. The preference for evolving DE over Λ \Lambda CDM remains below 3 σ 3\sigma across all dataset combinations, comparable to that obtained with CPL. Notably, the proximity of both w p w_{p} and f p f_{p} to their cosmological constant values of ( − 1 , 1 ) (-1,1) —precisely at the epoch where the data are most sensitive—deepens the coincidence previously identified in the CPL framework, reinforcing the case for caution in interpreting the current evidence for dynamical DE. I Introduction Recent measurements from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) 4 ; 2 have reignited the possibility that cosmic acceleration is driven by a dynamical dark energy (DE) component rather than a cosmological constant. When combined with cosmic microwave background (CMB) and Type Ia supernovae (SNe) observations, the DESI DR2 baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) data yield a {\sim}\,3\sigma preference for evolving DE 2 ; 121 ; 46 , assuming spatial flatness and the Chevallier–Polarski–Linder (CPL) parameterization of the DE equation of state 24 ; 67 , w_{\rm CPL}(z)=w_{0}+w_{a}\frac{z}{1+z}\,. (1) The inferred evolution favors a phantom crossing, with the effective equation of state transitioning from w<-1 at earlier times to w>-1 before the present epoch 71 . These findings have prompted extensive investigation into the nature and robustness of the apparent preference for dynamical DE, employing alternative DE parameterizations 113 ; 74 ; 28 ; 19 ; 123 ; 132 ; 88 ; 107 ; 29 ; 70 ; 12 ; 93 ; 97 ; 36 ; 75 ; 78 ; 133 ; 38 ; 51 ; 94 ; 95 ; 39 ; 89 ; 63 ; 130 ; 105 ; 37 ; 84 ; 71 ; 106 ; 32 ; 53 ; 81 ; 85 ; 87 ; 20 ; 52 ; 101 ; 42 ; 129 ; 59 ; 114 ; 83 ; 96 ; 111 ; 102 ; 69 ; 125 ; 21 ; 22 ; 99 ; 17 ; 65 ; 82 ; 60 ; 64 ; 55 ; 109 ; 49 ; 131 ; 135 ; 33 ; 110 ; 61 ; 134 ; 23 ; 40 ; 54 ; 73 ; 86 ; 62 ; 41 ; 77 , varying the choice of priors on the DE parameters 112 ; 10 ; 116 ; 115 ; 108 or the statistical framework under which the evidence is assessed 45 ; 79 ; 80 , and using full-shape galaxy clustering data in place of BAO alone 5 ; 26 ; 25 ; 50 ; 27 . While the reconstructed evolution of w(z) remains qualitatively stable across these approaches, the statistical significance of the departure from \Lambda can differ considerably (see e.g. 125 ; 79 ; 116 ; 27 ; 126 ). Moreover, as noted in Refs. 28 ; 32 , reparameterizing CPL in terms of the equation of state w_{p} evaluated at the pivot redshift—the epoch where a given dataset combination most tightly constrains DE—reveals that w_{p} is consistent with -1 to percent-level precision, with the entire preference for evolving DE driven by the weakly constrained slope w_{a} . That these models require a substantially varying w(z) to reproduce the data yet return a cosmological constant value at the redshift where the data are most constraining constitutes a new cosmic coincidence, warranting caution in interpreting the current evidence for evolving DE. Indeed, this preference for evolving DE is partly shaped by the choice of parameterizing at the level of the DE equation of state, which enters the cosmological distances measured by BAO, CMB, and SNe only through a nonlinear integral mapping to the DE density. This mapping can amplify parameter uncertainties, introduce approximate degeneracies, and smear out features in the underlying evolution 76 ; 9 ; 124 ; 107 . The recent analysis of Ref. 125 corroborates this concern: bypassing the equation-of-state parameterization entirely and reconstructing the DE density evolution directly from DESI and CMB data, they find consistency with \Lambda CDM at the {\sim}\,1\sigma level. While such model-independent approaches that reconstruct the DE density in redshift bins 124 ; 125 ; 71 offer maximal flexibility, they come at the cost of additional free parameters. Moreover, the information content of geometric probes is largely concentrated in two effective DE degrees of freedom 66 ; 71 . This motivates the approach pursued in this work: a minimal two-parameter polynomial expansion of the normalized DE density f_{\rm DE}(z)\equiv\rho_{\rm DE}(z)/\rho_{\rm DE,0} that, like CPL, requires only two free parameters. Its smooth analytical form also lends itself naturally to the inclusion of DE perturbations, unlike the discontinuous bin structure of model-independent reconstructions. A related approach was pursued in Ref. 104 through a polynomial parameterization of the DE pressure, recently constrained using current data in 21 . As we discuss in Sec. II.2 , the density parameterization introduced here spans an equivalent functional space but differs crucially in the choice of parameters. Specifically, our polynomial density expansion is parameterized in terms of the DE density fraction f_{p}\equiv f_{\rm DE}(z_{p}) and equation of state w_{p}\equiv w(z_{p}) at the pivot redshift. Here f_{p} directly quantifies how much the DE density differs from its present-day value, while w_{p} captures its rate of evolution. Together, they provide an immediate physical characterization of DE at the epoch where current observations are most sensitive. Moreover, as we show in this work,