Identifying Surface Degeneracies in Single-Visit Reflected Light Observations of Modern Earth using the Habitable Worlds Observatory
Aiden S. Zelakiewicz, Elijah Mullens, Lisa Kaltenegger, Dmitry Savransky · 2026
Read Identifying Surface Degeneracies in Single-Visit Reflected Light Observations of Modern Earth using the Habitable Worlds Observatory by Aiden S. Zelakiewicz, Elijah Mullens, Lisa Kaltenegger, Dmitry Savransky (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-25694.txt.
Introduction
Zelakiewicz and co-authors ask what one visit by the Habitable Worlds Observatory could reveal about an Earth-like planet. They model photon-counting noise for a design with a charge-6 vector-vortex coronagraph. They pair that noise model with five modern Earth models seen at quadrature. Spectral retrievals with the POSEIDON code then try to recover surface and air makeup. The authors find strong ties among radius, surface pressure, surface type, and cloud cover. These ties can hide signs of life, such as the red edge from chlorophyll.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Aiden S. Zelakiewicz, Elijah Mullens, Lisa Kaltenegger, Dmitry Savransky |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 81589 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.25694
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Identifying Surface Degeneracies in Single-Visit Reflected Light Observations of Modern Earth using the Habitable Worlds Observatory Aiden S. Zelakiewicz, Elijah Mullens, Lisa Kaltenegger, Dmitry Savransky Abstract Characterizing the surface and atmosphere of Earth-like planets in reflected light is a key goal for upcoming direct imaging surveys. NASA’s next flagship-class astrophysics mission concept, the Habitable Worlds Observatory (HWO), is a space-based Ultraviolet/Optical/Near-Infrared observatory with a mission design requirement to reach the 10 − 10 10^{-10} contrast necessary to characterize Earth-like planets around Sun-like stars. While reflected light from planetary surfaces provides a unique opportunity to constrain the coverage of surface materials and biopigments, detailed predictions of HWO’s ability to retrieve surface fractions are necessary but have not been conducted. Here, we model photon-counting noise from astrophysical, instrumental, and post-processing sources for the HWO Exploratory Analytic Case 5 design equipped with a charge-6 vector-vortex coronagraph. By combining our photon-counting noise with five distinct modern Earth models at quadrature, we simulate single-visit HWO observations and perform spectral retrievals using the open-source code POSEIDON to assess our ability to constrain both the surface and atmospheric composition. We find that degeneracies between planetary radius, surface pressure, surface material, and cloud coverage in reflected-light retrievals can significantly complicate the classification of surface features. These degeneracies can complicate the detection of surface biopigments, such as the chlorophyll-induced red edge on modern Earth. Our work shows that developing concrete strategies for detecting surface features and breaking degeneracies in reflected-light observations of Earth-like planets is a critical priority for mission design and data analysis. I Introduction With over 6,000 exoplanets confirmed to date ( J. L. Christiansen et al. 2025 ) , and tens of thousands more predicted to be found with upcoming observatories like the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope ( R. F. Wilson et al. 2023 ) and PLATO ( H. Rauer et al. 2025 ) , the field of exoplanet science has entered an era of characterization and demographic studies. Atmospheric characterization using the James Webb Space Telescope ( JWST ) is unveiling features such as molecular abundances ( T. J. Bell et al. 2023 ; B. Benneke et al. 2024 ; T. G. Beatty et al. 2024 ; S. P. Schmidt et al. 2025 ) , aerosols ( D. Grant et al. 2023 ; A. Dyrek et al. 2024 ; J. Inglis et al. 2024 ) , and photochemistry ( S.-M. Tsai et al. 2023 ; Z. Rustamkulov et al. 2023 ) in transiting hot Jupiters and sub-Neptunes. Transmission and emission spectroscopy of Earth-like planets, however, is significantly more difficult due to factors such as the shallower transit depth ( L. Kaltenegger & W. A. Traub 2009 ) . Despite the challenges, JWST observations of rocky exoplanets orbiting M-dwarfs have begun to place upper limits on secondary atmospheres ( Q. Xue et al. 2024 ; M. Radica et al. 2025 ; M. Fortune et al. 2025 ; K. A. Bennett et al. 2025 ; N. Espinoza et al. 2025 ; A. Glidden et al. 2025 ) . While M-dwarfs improve the observability of rocky exoplanets compared to Sun-like stars, their increased activity, especially young M-dwarfs, may expose close-in planets to atmospheric stripping due to high-energy irradiation. Stellar activity may also present signals larger than attenuation from the planet itself, which require an in-depth understanding of the star to address ( J. Scalo et al. 2007 ; H. Lammer et al. 2007 ; P. J. Wheatley et al. 2017 ; L. Kaltenegger 2017 ; K. J. Zahnle & D. C. Catling 2017 ) . The 2020 Decadal Survey on Astronomy and Astrophysics by the National Academies of Science, Engineering, and Medicine identified imaging Earth-like planets around Sun-like stars as a top priority for the field ( E. National Academies of Sciences 2021 ) . Following the recommendations of the 2020 Decadal Survey, NASA announced the Habitable Worlds Observatory (HWO) as the next flagship-class astrophysics mission design concept, taking inspiration from the LUVOIR ( The LUVOIR Team 2019 ) and HabEx ( B. S. Gaudi et al. 2020 ) concepts. The HWO design is a \geq 6 meter space-based observatory with a dedicated survey for the detection and characterization of Earth-like exoplanets around FGK stars ( N. W. Tuchow et al. 2025 ; S. Peacock et al. 2025 ) . A driving science goal of HWO is to characterize exoplanets around FGK stars, with particular emphasis on Earth-like planets around Sun-like stars. To observe an Earth-twin orbiting a Sun-analog, HWO will need to reach a planet-star flux ratio ( F_{p}/F_{s} ) below 10^{-10} through high-contrast imaging. As part of the Great Observatory Maturation Program (GOMAP), the Technology Assessment Group (TAG) has been leading the design of Exploratory Analytic Cases (EACs) for HWO ( E. National Academies of Sciences 2021 ; L. Feinberg et al. 2024 ) . The EACs were created to model and inform key mission design choices as the Concept Maturity Level timeline for HWO progresses. The first three EAC design efforts, which ranged from 6 to 8 meters, were completed in 2025, with EACs 4 and 5 currently being assessed by the TAG. The EAC 4 and 5 primary mirrors have an inscribed diameter of >6.5 and >8 meters, respectively ( L. D. Feinberg et al. 2026 ) . Both observatory designs feature hexagonal segmented primary mirrors and an off-axis secondary. The EACs are compatible with a coronagraph instrument (CI), which will enable visible (VIS) and near-infrared (NIR) spectroscopy using an integral field spectrograph (IFS) to capture reflected light from an Earth-sized exoplanet. In the wavelength regime of HWO, reflected light from the host star is expected to be the primary component of emergent flux from the planet. Reflection spectroscopy of Earth-like exoplanets has the potential to uncover biosignatures unique to surface features, such as biopigments, including the chlorophyll-induced photosynthetic red edge at \sim 750 nm ( C. Sagan et al. 1993 ; S. Seager et al. 2005 ; L. Kaltenegger 2017 ) . Ongoing research on identifying potential atmospheric biosignatures on other worlds (see L. Kaltenegger 2017 ; E. W. Schwieterman et al. 2018 ; E. W. Schwieterman & M. Leung 2024 , for reviews) , and biopigments on Earth ( S. Hegde & L. Kaltenegger 2013 ; S. Hegde et al. 2015 ; J. T. O’Malley-James & L. Kaltenegger 2018a ; J. T. O’Malley-James & L. Kaltenegger 2019 ; L. F. Coelho et al. 2022 ; L. F. Coelho et al. 2024 ; L. F. Coelho et al. 2025 ) have shown the incredible spectral diversity of life. Detecting surface biopigments on terrestrial exoplanets will require rigorous protocols for signal detection and vetting ( V. Meadows et al. 2022 ) . Here, we examine whether current state-of-the-art methods for analyzing exoplanet atmospheres via Bayesian atmospheric retrievals (see N. Madhusudhan 2018 ; J. K. Barstow & K. Heng 2020 ; R. J. MacDonald & N. E. Batalha 2023 , for reviews) can identify surface features in addition to atmospheric features. Retrieval codes are the standard for analyzing JWST transmission and emission spectra, and many of these algorithms are now being developed to handle higher-resolution reflection spectra for next-generation observatories. These codes must account for the unique spectral signatures of surface pigmentation from both