Kardashev scale Quantum Computing for Bitcoin Mining

Pierre-Luc Dallaire-Demers, BTQ Technologies Team · 2026

Read Kardashev scale Quantum Computing for Bitcoin Mining by Pierre-Luc Dallaire-Demers, BTQ Technologies Team (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-25519.txt.

Introduction

Dallaire-Demers and the BTQ team price a quantum attack on Bitcoin mining in real hardware, not query counts. Grover's search halves the brute-force exponent, but fault-tolerant machines pay huge overhead. Their open estimator sweeps oracles, error-correction factories, and fleet timing against energy use. Even at the kindest setting, a fleet needs about a hundred million physical qubits and ten thousand megawatts. At today's full difficulty, the bill nears a star's worth of power. Practical quantum mining collapses under the costs.

Catalog record

CREATORPierre-Luc Dallaire-Demers, BTQ Technologies Team
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE81924
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.25519

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Kardashev scale Quantum Computing for Bitcoin Mining Pierre-Luc Dallaire-Demers, BTQ Technologies Team Abstract Bitcoin already faces a quantum threat through Shor attacks on elliptic-curve signatures. This paper isolates the other component that public discussion often conflates with it: mining. Grover’s algorithm halves the exponent of brute-force search, promising a quadratic edge to any quantum miner of Bitcoin. Exactly how large that edge grows depends on fault-tolerant hardware. No prior study has costed that hardware end to end. We build an open-source estimator that sweeps the full attack surface: reversible oracles for double- SHA-256 mining and RIPEMD-160 -based address preimages, surface-code factory sizing, fleet logistics under Nakamoto-consensus timing, and Kardashev-scale energy accounting. A parametric sweep over difficulty bits b b , runtime caps, and target success probabilities reveals a sharp transition. At the most favourable partial-preimage setting ( b = 32 b=32 , 2 224 2^{224} marked states), a superconducting surface-code fleet still requires ∼ 10 8 \sim\!10^{8} physical qubits and ∼ 10 4 \sim\!10^{4}\, MW. That load is comparable to a large national grid. Tightening to Bitcoin’s January 2025 mainnet difficulty ( b ≈ 79 b\approx 79 ) explodes the bill to ∼ 10 23 \sim\!10^{23} qubits and ∼ 10 25 \sim\!10^{25}\, W, approaching the Kardashev Type II threshold. These numbers settle a narrower question than “Is Bitcoin quantum-secure?” Once Grover mining is lifted from asymptotic query counts to fault-tolerant physical cost, practical quantum mining collapses under oracle, distillation, and fleet overhead. To push mining into non-trivial consensus effects, one must invoke astronomical quantum fleets operating at energy scales that lie far above present-day civilization. 1 Introduction Fifteen gigawatts power the Bitcoin network. That exceeds the electricity use of many nation-states. All of it buys one guarantee: no adversary finds a valid block header faster than brute force permits [ 1 , 2 ] . Grover’s algorithm threatens that guarantee. A quadratic speedup halves the exponent of proof-of-work search; a quantum miner armed with error-corrected Grover oracles could, in principle, locate a winning nonce with the square root of the classical work [ 3 ] . “Can quantum computers break Bitcoin mining?” The question echoes across the blockchain community, yet the literature offers no definitive answer. Prior analyses do one of two things. They either halt at asymptotics, where “Grover gives O(\sqrt{N}) ,” or they bury the verdict inside surface-code ledgers that practitioners cannot extract [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] . That ambiguity matters because Bitcoin’s quantum story already splits in two. Shor’s algorithm threatens the signature layer on a nearer-term front [ 7 ] , while public discussion often treats the mining layer as vulnerable for the wrong reason: it imports Grover’s asymptotics and skips the physical bill. This paper addresses that second question. Three compounding overheads hide behind that clean asymptotic promise. A reversible double-SHA-256 oracle demands {\sim}\,3\times 10^{5} non-Clifford ( T ) gates per Grover iteration, inflating the naïve query count by a factor of {\sim}\,2^{38} [ 4 ] . Each T gate in turn requires a magic-state distillation factory that occupies thousands of physical qubits on the surface code [ 8 ] . Nakamoto’s ten-minute block window then caps the depth of any single search and forces the adversary to field exponentially many independent machines. Each machine is too slow on its own to reach the target success probability [ 9 ] . Oracle cost, distillation tax, fleet multiplication: together these three factors transform a quadratic speedup into a resource bill that no single study has totalled. This paper closes the loop. We trace the full path: reversible oracle design, surface-code factory sizing, fleet logistics, and wall-plug power. We then sweep difficulty bits, runtime caps, and success thresholds across three hardware architectures: superconducting, trapped-ion, and neutral-atom. The estimator converts fleet qubit counts into watts and maps each result onto Kardashev’s civilization ladder, where Type I marks planetary power ( {\sim}\,10^{16}\, W), Type II stellar ( {\sim}\,10^{26}\, W), and Type III galactic ( {\sim}\,10^{36}\, W) [ 10 ] . The verdict falls hard against the quantum miner. At the most favourable partial-preimage setting, namely difficulty b=32 with 2^{224} marked states, a superconducting fleet still consumes {\sim}\,10^{4}\, MW across {\sim}\,10^{8} physical qubits, a load that rivals a large national grid. Tighten to Bitcoin’s January 2025 mainnet difficulty ( b\approx 79 ) and the bill explodes: {\sim}\,10^{23} qubits drawing {\sim}\,10^{25}\, W, which approaches the Kardashev Type II threshold. Grover’s quadratic speedup does not survive the multiplicative overhead of fault tolerance at Bitcoin-relevant scales. The moral is narrow and sharp. This paper does not revisit the signature-layer Shor threat [ 11 ] . It shows that the mining component fails for the opposite reason. That is the part often cited in public discussions of “quantum Bitcoin mining.” To produce non-trivial effects on Nakamoto consensus, a Grover miner must command astronomical fleets operating at energy scales that only much higher Kardashev civilizations could plausibly support. Figures 2 and 3 show the baseline machine in fleet units: the favourable partial-preimage corner already demands industrial-scale hardware, and tighter runtime caps force explosive growth in machine count. Figure 6 turns that fleet into a power budget and pushes the mainnet point toward Type II. Figures 8 – 11 then test the science-fiction escape hatch. The ladder buys speed, but the high-energy heatmaps and trade-off curves still demand objects that read less like computers than like engineered astrophysical bodies. The remainder of the paper assembles this verdict piece by piece: background on Grover search and surface-code accounting (Sec. 2 ), the reversible oracle ledgers that price each hash call (Sec. 3 ), the surface-code fleet mapping that converts logical gates into physical qubits (Sec. 4 ), the Kardashev-scale energy analysis (Sec. 5 ), and the implications for Nakamoto consensus (Sec. 6 ). The route follows the debunking trail in order: oracle cost, distillation tax, fleet multiplication, then power. All estimator code, test suites, and sweep data that reproduce every table and figure appear in a public repository. 1 1 1 https://github.com/Pauli-Group/kardashev 2 Background and related work 2.1 Grover’s Algorithm and Cryptographic Search Grover’s algorithm [ 3 ] locates a marked item in an unstructured set of size N with O(\sqrt{N}) queries. That is a quadratic cut against brute force. In cryptography, n -bit preimage resistance drops to roughly n/2 bits under quantum queries. For Bitcoin’s proof-of-work, the predicate reads “ \mathrm{SHA}\text{-}256(\cdot) falls below target,” so the oracle implements the SHA-256 compression function [ 12 , 1 ] . The asymptotics look simple; the physical bill on a fault-tolerant device does not: error-correction overhead, clock rate, and oracle cost drive the total. For collision resistance, quantum algorithms achieve O(N^{1/3}) complexity [ 13 ] , but a collision search does not help Bitcoin’s thresholded proof-of-work predicate or single-target preimage on P2PKH , so we focus on preimage oracles. 2.2 Fault-Tolerance, Surface Code, and Space–Time Overheads Large Grover searches demand full fault tolerance. The surface code leads on threshold and locality, yet it exacts heavy qubit and time costs, with a premium on non-Clifford ( T ) gates that require magic-state distillation. Litinski’s framework [ 8 ] exposes a space–time tradeoff: slow runs with few qubits; fast runs with many. At a physical error rate 10^{-4}

Read the complete text