Networks of quantum reference frames and the nature of conserved quantities
Daniel Collins, Carolina Moreira Ferrera, Ismael L. Paiva, Sandu Popescu · 2026
Read Networks of quantum reference frames and the nature of conserved quantities by Daniel Collins, Carolina Moreira Ferrera, Ismael L. Paiva, Sandu Popescu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-25485.txt.
Introduction
Collins and co-authors show that webs of quantum reference frames can scramble the bookkeeping of conserved quantities. One frame can mint several others, and those can ready systems that later meet. Following a conserved charge through such a web turns subtle fast. Odd features emerge that clash with naive counting. The team also offers a fresh way to analyze quantum frames. They expect it to help future debates about what frames really are.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daniel Collins, Carolina Moreira Ferrera, Ismael L. Paiva, Sandu Popescu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69336 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.25485
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Networks of quantum reference frames and the nature of conserved quantities Daniel Collins, Carolina Moreira Ferrera, Ismael L. Paiva, Sandu Popescu Abstract We show that networks of quantum frames of reference, in which one frame may be used to produce multiple other frames that in their turn prepare systems which may interact with one another, have counterintuitive properties that make following the exchange of conserved quantities very subtle, and raise questions about the very nature of conserved quantities. In addition, we present an alternative approach to analysing quantum reference frames that we believe will be useful in discussions related to quantum frames of reference. I Introduction In this paper we focus on the interplay between two important concepts in physics: conservation laws and reference frames. Specifically, we consider the recently discovered deeper relation that exists between these two concepts Aharonov et al. 2021 ; Aharonov et al. 2023 ; Collins and Popescu 2025 , and we present qualitatively new and subtle effects that appear in networks of quantum frames of reference, that bring into question the very nature of what conserved quantities are. In quantum mechanics, frames of reference, whilst long ignored, are now viewed as essential in our understanding of quantum physics Aharonov et al. 2021 ; Aharonov et al. 2023 ; Collins and Popescu 2025 ; Aharonov and Susskind 1967a ; Aharonov and Susskind 1967b ; Aharonov and Kaufherr 1984 ; Angelo et al. 2010 ; Krumm et al. 2021 ; Rovelli 1991 ; Bartlett et al. 2007 ; Popescu et al. 2018 ; Popescu et al. 2020 ; Suleymanov et al. 2024 , with implications across quantum foundations, quantum information, and even approaches to quantum gravity. However, in virtually all discussions of quantum frames of reference the set-up has been that of a single quantum frame, to which various quantum systems have been referred. On the other hand, in Nature, and very much in practice, the situation is far more complicated, with frames of reference preparing other frames of reference and so on. For example, a table is prepared relative to the wall and a laser is prepared relative to the table. This is a simple chain of reference systems, see Fig. 1 (a). A more complex network is that of two tables, each prepared relative to the same wall, and having one system prepared relative to one table, and another system prepared relative to the other table, as in Fig. 1 (b). We will call such scenarios “networks of quantum reference frames”. In the present paper we introduce this general idea in the context of fundamental quantum mechanics. Figure 1: Chains of system preparations. (a) A grand-frame G prepares a frame F , which then prepares a system S . (b) A grand-frame G prepares two frames, F and F^{\prime} , which in turn prepare systems S and S^{\prime} , respectively. The second ingredient in our paper concerns conservation laws, where recently a breakthrough was made showing that conservation laws hold not only in the usual statistical sense, in terms of distributions of measurement outcomes generated over many repeated experiments, but also for individual measurement outcomes Aharonov et al. 2021 ; Aharonov et al. 2023 ; Collins and Popescu 2025 . For example, for a particle on a circle in a superposition of angular momentum eigenstates, a measurement of angular momentum gives a particular value, and whilst the usual law refers to the distribution over all possible values from many repeated experiments, Ref. Collins and Popescu 2025 showed that conservation still holds for a single experimental outcome, as the angular momentum of the frame of reference used to prepare the state will decrease by precisely that outcome. While it was long known that there is an exchange of conserved quantities between a system and the frame of reference relative to which it has been prepared Aharonov and Kaufherr 1984 , from the point of view of conservation laws there was never a great need to explicitly consider this. Indeed, consider, say, a system of particles evolving under a translation-invariant Hamiltonian. Then their total momentum is conserved, and there is no need to refer to any frame of reference, let alone consider exchanging momentum with it. On the contrary, for conservation in individual cases, which gives a far more detailed view on how conservation works, the frame plays an active role in the conservation, making a much deeper connection between the two. Coming to the specific subject of our paper, the main phenomenon is the transfer of momentum between a system and the frame used to prepare it. In a previous work Collins and Popescu 2025 the exchange of the conserved quantity has been studied in the simple case of a chain of frames of reference, as in Fig. 1 (a), but as we shall show here, the way conserved quantities flow in networks of quantum frames of reference such as that in Fig. 1 (b) is qualitatively different, and raises fundamental conceptual questions about the nature of conserved quantities. The key feature, whose unusual properties only become apparent when analysing networks of quantum frames, is related to the flow of information that accompanies the flow of conserved quantities, which exhibits a subtle quantum structure. We also introduce the notion of the first common frame of reference of two frames, which will play an important role in our results. In addition to the main result, we also present a change of variables that we believe will be particularly suitable to discussions related to frames of reference, not only those in this paper but also in many other scenarios, and which, as far as we know, has not yet appeared in the literature. The remainder of this article is organised as follows. Section II describes a paradox that illustrates the qualitatively different behaviour of networks of quantum frames. Section III recalls the main elements of a single system and frame, as hitherto known. Section IV discusses the special properties of the interaction used to prepare a system relative to a frame. Section V gives the details of the paradox. Section VI introduces our alternative approach to analysing quantum reference frames in terms of “frame of reference coordinates”, and Section VII uses it to derive the results of a linear chain from Ref. Collins and Popescu 2025 in a simpler fashion. Section VIII solves part of the paradox. Section IX presents a second paradox, highlighting what is unresolved from the first. Section X resolves the second paradox and discusses the flow of information. Finally, Section XI summarises our results. II The Paradox We will now present the basic paradox of the paper in qualitative terms. To start, consider a particle on a circle in a state of zero angular momentum, i.e. a state with no spatial features. Suppose that the particle is now prepared by a frame of reference in a state \chi(\theta) , with \theta relative to the frame. There must be angular momentum transfer from the frame to the particle, unless \chi(\theta) is the zero angular momentum state, as the interaction is momentum conserving. However, this “frame of reference interaction” is special; it is not a generic total angular momentum preserving interaction. Indeed, the main result of