Improving metadata flows - The simultaneous use of multiple metadata schemas at disciplinary research data repositories
2026
Read Improving metadata flows - The simultaneous use of multiple metadata schemas at disciplinary research data repositories (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-25468.txt.
Introduction
Strecker studies how clashing metadata rules leave gaps in DataCite records. Eight field repositories in geoscience and social science supply the cases. Some clashes come from two readings of one standard. Others pit one standard against another. Both kinds feed missing fields, as record checks and schema maps show. Workflows and deliberate choices add their own share. Crosswalk updates, shared enrichment, and profile tools could heal some gaps. Others tie too tightly to a repository's mission to heal at all.
Catalog record
| YEAR | 2026 |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 48398 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.25468
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Improving metadata flows - The simultaneous use of multiple metadata schemas at disciplinary research data repositories Abstract Improving metadata flows \authorsnames [1]Dorothea Strecker \authorsaffiliations Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, Berlin School of Library and Information Science, \authornote Dorothea Strecker https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9754-3807 Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to: [email protected] Abstract This study investigates the simultaneous use of multiple metadata schemas at research data repositories. The analysis covers how eight disciplinary research data repositories from the geosciences and social sciences use disciplinary metadata schemas and the DataCite Metadata Schema, and how two metadata records describing the same dataset compare. The results show that DataCite metadata records could be improved considerably by optimizing schema crosswalks. However, the parallel use of disciplinary and multidisciplinary metadata records is complex. For example, discpline has a significant effect on the completeness of DataCite metadata. A temporal analysis also highlights that metadata workflows are diverse, and in some cases, suboptimal crosswalks are likely not the sole cause of incomplete DataCite metadata. Comparing the disciplinary metadata schemas and the DataCite Metadata Schema on a structural level reveals that most differences between schemas are the result of different approaches to modelling statements about datasets, not the lack of opportunity to express them. The element sets of both disciplinary metadata schemas and the DataCite Metadata Schema could be extended to describe datasets in more detail. These observations demonstrate that disciplinary and multidisciplinary metadata schemas serve distinct purposes. Disciplinary repositories should take full advantage of the opportunities both options provide. Keywords: research data repository, metadata schema, metadata crosswalk 1 Introduction In order to realize the vision of research data as separate and valuable research outputs, datasets must be able to be moved effectively from data creator to data reuser. This process requires metadata, structured descriptions of datasets, which allow potential data reusers to find and make sense of datasets. Structured metadata are especially important for research data, because in contrast to text-based research outputs, datasets are not self-explanatory. Data movements are facilitated by a complex web of information infrastructures that use different schemas for creating metadata records. There are many metadata schemas available for describing research data, each representing a specific point of view. Some standards have strong connections to the research community they emerge from, but they can also create friction: "Metadata […] facilitate the exchange of data within communities. They also can be sources of friction with collaborators and markers of the boundaries between communities." ( 9 , 80) Metadata based on these disciplinary schemas that are specific to a discipline are necessary to make informed decisions about data reuse, but they also need to be integrated in the wider metadata ecosystem to facilitate data movement across institutional, disciplinary and temporal boundaries. Therefore, alongside disciplinary metadata schemas, more integrative, multidisciplinary schemas are necessary to support data movements. The most widely used multidisciplinary metadata schema for research data is the DataCite Metadata Schema, which is maintained by the DOI registration agency DataCite ( 13 ) . DataCite maintains the largest collection of metadata about research data and is uniquely positioned to facilitate activities like data discovery and scientometric research. However, previous research has highlighted that DataCite metadata is often incomplete, which might be caused by suboptimal crosswalks from disciplinary metadata schemas to the DataCite Metadata Schema. Currently, there is little research on how research data repositories navigate the use of multiple metadata schemas. 41 stresses the necessity to study standards implementation: “More research is needed to characterize both inter-standard conflicts and conflicts in implementations of the same standards, as well as to understand why these issues occur, and how implementers navigate and resolve these conflicts.” ( 41 , 125) This study addresses this gap by investigating the simultaneous use of multiple metadata schemas at research data repositories. The analysis covers how disciplinary research data repositories use metadata schemas and how metadata records describing the same dataset compare - metadata records that are based on a metadata schema that is catering to (1) a specific discipline and (2) to a global audience and general purposes such as DOI registration. The study addresses the following research questions: RQ 1: How do repositories use the metadata schemas? RQ 2: Where do the metadata schemas overlap, where do they differ? RQ 3: How effective is metadata transfer from local to global contexts? 2 Background 2.1 Research data infrastructures and standardization Research data repositories are a form of information infrastructure, one that is specialized on storing and disseminating research data ( 10 ) . Like other infrastructures, their operation is closely connected to standardization - they are “[…] basic systems and services that are reliable, standardized, and widely accessible […]” ( 16 , 8) . Infrastructures are, among other properties, characterized by "embodiments of standards" ( 53 , 113) . They implement standards in order to connect to other infrastructures, tools and services; to make things work together, even across distances. This allows networks to form between individual, heterogenous infrastructures ( 16 ) . Facilitated by standardization, information infrastructures supporting research data form a network that comprises diverse components, for example research data repositories with different scopes and missions ( 5 ; 9 ) . Other components are DOI registration agencies that assign persistent identifiers, receive and store metadata from registrants, and provide output metadata for service users ( 11 ; 15 ; 20 ) . Based on an ISO/IEC standard ( 30 ) , Pomerantz and Griffey define a standard as “[…] a document, established by consensus and approved by a recognized body, that provides, for common and repeated use, rules, guidelines, or characteristics for activities or their results, aimed at the achievement of the optimum degree of order in a given context.” ( 47 , 26) An important area of application for standards in the context of research data are metadata - creating metadata is an example for embodiment of standards ( 10 ; 60 ) . 2.2 Metadata for research data Metadata are "structured, encoded data that describe the characteristics of information-bearing entities." ( 62 , 12) Compared to other forms of research data descriptions, metadata are more standardized; their goal is to "provide context and consistency" ( 36 , 77) . The resulting product, a metadata record, serves as a stand-in for the described object and allows users to interact with it in information systems ( 1 ; 18 ) . Creating and maintaining metadata records is an important aspect of data curation, “the encompassing work and actions taken by curators of a data repository in order to provide meaningful and enduring access to data” ( 32 , 5) . A survey on curation activities research data repositories in the US showed that reviewing metadata and minting persistent identifiers are the most common curation actions ( 32 ) . Researchers also expressed the opinion that “documentation” is the curation action undertaken by repositories that adds most value to their data ( 39 ) . This notion is mirrored by data curators - in their opinion, support from metadata experts can considerably improve the findability and usability of data ( 25 ) . In general, the process of creating and maintaining metadata records is fluid and can include a variety of actions ( 19