Universal transport laws in buoyancy-driven porous mixing

Marco De Paoli, Xiaojue Zhu · 2026

Read Universal transport laws in buoyancy-driven porous mixing by Marco De Paoli, Xiaojue Zhu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-25457.txt.

Introduction

De Paoli and Zhu find exact transport laws for buoyant mixing inside porous rock. Rising warm fluid fingers through pores, and that brief fingering stage boosts transport in aquifers and carbon stores. Old rules for it were mere fits. Their balances tie transport, flow strength, and scalar decay together at each moment, with no slack. The action stays inside the mixing layer, which yields a one-knob model for the mean field. It predicts self-similar profiles and a linear transport law. Giant simulations confirm the claims.

Catalog record

CREATORMarco De Paoli, Xiaojue Zhu
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31237
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.25457

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Universal transport laws in buoyancy-driven porous mixing Marco De Paoli, Xiaojue Zhu Abstract Buoyancy-driven convection in porous media governs heat and mass transport in a wide range of natural and engineered systems, from groundwater aquifers and geothermal reservoirs to carbon storage in geological formations and flows through planetary interiors. Yet the transient regime, in which fingering flows emerge and transport is strongly enhanced, is still described largely through empirical scaling laws, limiting predictive capability across conditions. Here we show that transient porous buoyancy-driven mixing obeys exact time-dependent balances that couple transport, flow intensity, and scalar dissipation. These balances remain accurate when restricted to the actively mixing layer, revealing that the essential dynamics are localized within a finite region. Leveraging these results, we derive a minimal one-parameter closure for the mean scalar field. The theory we propose predicts self-similar mean profiles, universal second-order statistics, and a linear transport law without case-by-case tuning. Direct numerical simulations up to spatial resolution of 2048 × 2048 × 16384 2048\times 2048\times 16384 points validate these predictions. Our results place transient porous mixing on a predictive footing, showing how macroscopic transport laws emerge from exact balances and self-similar dynamics, and provide a general framework for buoyancy-driven transport in porous media. keywords convection | heat and mass transport | geological systems Transport in porous media shapes the evolution of many natural and engineered systems, from groundwater aquifers and geothermal reservoirs to geological carbon storage and hydrothermal activity in planetary interiors ( cheng1979heat ; jolie2021geological ; heinze2023velocity ; ulloa2025convection ; goodman2004hydrothermal ; lowell2005hydrothermal ; le2020internally ; schrag2007preparing ; orr2009onshore ; szulczewski2012lifetime ) . In these settings, buoyancy can destabilize an initially stratified fluid and drive vigorous convective mixing, greatly accelerating the transport of heat and dissolved species. In contrast, diffusive spreading reduces local density differences, and thus the strength of this driving mechanism. This competition between convection and diffusion also underlies solute mixing in geological formations ( narayan1995simulation ; depaoli2025simulation ) and salt seepage from saline lakes narayan1995simulation ; depaoli2025dispersion . An example of the latter is reported in Fig. 1 (a), where the hydrogeology of the Murray River basin is schematically illustrated. The high-salinity water channeled to the Lake Ranfurly West seeps through the low-permeability lake bottom lake into the underneath Channel Sands Aquifer, connected to the Murray River. In these permeable sands, a high-salinity fluid layer builds up, resulting in an unstable configuration with a heavy fluid that sits above the lighter low-salinity groundwater. Eventually, when the density contrast between the two fluid layers is large enough, convection sets in. Predicting the dynamics of this convective mixing is key to evaluate the influx on salt into the adjacent Murray River. Yet, despite the key importance of this process, its transient dynamics remain poorly understood at a predictive level. A central difficulty is that transient buoyancy-driven mixing is usually described through empirical scaling laws. These are useful within the range of conditions for which they were obtained, but they offer limited confidence when extrapolated across the broad parameter regimes relevant to geophysics and engineering. What is still missing is a framework in which transport laws emerge from the dynamics themselves, rather than being inferred case by case from simulation or experiment. In porous materials, this problem arises naturally in the Rayleigh-Taylor-Darcy configuration, where a denser fluid overlies a lighter one in a permeable matrix ( rayleigh1883investigation ; taylor1950instability ) . In subsurface settings, the motion is controlled by Darcy’s law, and the resulting instability generates descending and rising fingers, an expanding mixing layer, and transport rates far larger than diffusion alone. Previous studies have established a robust phenomenology, including approximately linear growth of the mixing region ( DeWit2004 ; gopalakrishnan2017relative ; Boffetta2020 ) , finite-size corrections ( depaoli2019universal ; depaoli2019prf ; depaoli2022experimental ) , and strongly enhanced transport at large driving ( hew12 ; hew14 ; wen2013computational ; wen2015structure ; pir21 ; Boffetta2020 ) . But these observations do not yet amount to a predictive theory: the dominant transport laws and leading statistics of the mixing process are still not derived from exact time-dependent constraints. This gap is especially striking when compared with statistically steady porous convection, for which exact relations have recently clarified how global transport is linked to flow intensity and dissipation ( zhu2024transport ) . In that setting, the heat-transfer rate is known to increase linearly with the strength of buoyancy forcing in the strongly convective regime, and this result can be derived from exact balances rather than inferred empirically, in the spirit of Grossmann-Lohse theory ( grossmann2000scaling ; gro01 ; lohse2024ultimate ) . No comparable theoretical structure has yet been established for transient porous Rayleigh-Taylor mixing. Existing descriptions typically treat the mixing-layer thickness as an external ingredient or rely on empirical closures ( Boffetta2020 ; borgnino2021dimensional ; boffetta2022dimensional ) , leaving open the deeper question of whether transient porous mixing also obeys universal balances that can predict both structure and transport. Here we show that it does. We derive exact time-dependent budget identities for transient porous Rayleigh-Taylor mixing and demonstrate that, during the convection-dominated regime, these balances remain accurate when restricted to the actively mixing layer. Leveraging these results, we develop a minimal one-parameter closure for the horizontally averaged scalar field, building on the nonlinear eddy-diffusivity framework of Boffetta et al. boffetta2010prl and adapting it to Darcy dynamics. The resulting theory predicts self-similar mean profiles, universal second-order statistics, and the associated transport law, all of which are validated by three-dimensional direct numerical simulations over a broad range of Rayleigh-Darcy numbers. Figure 1: (a) Conceptualized hydrogeology of the River Murray basin area (New South Wales, Australia), adapted from Narayan et al. narayan1995simulation . Inset: modelling of the saline seepage through the bottom of Lake Ranfurly West. The high-permeability sands aquifer is confined by two low-permeability layers. Lake Ranfurly West supplies high-salt-concentration (high-density) water from the top, while low-salinity (low-density) groundwater is present in the aquifer. (b) Evolution of the density distribution in time ( t ) for simulation S1 ( \ra=3.2\times 10^{4} , quantities shown in dimensionless units). (b-i) Initial flow configuration with indication of gravity ( \mathbf{g} ), of the reference frame ( x,y,z ) and of the domain extension ( L_{x},L_{y},L_{z} ). (b-ii) A developed field during the convective phase, with indication of the extension of the mixing region, h . (b-iii) Field after the fingers reached the boundaries. Results We consider a homogeneous and isotropic porous medium having height L_{z}^{*} and permeability K , which is initially saturated with a light fluid at bottom (temperature T^{*}=T^{*}_{\text{max}} , density \rho^{*}=\rho^{*}_{\text{min}} ) and a cold, heavy fluid at top ( T^{*}=T^{*}_{\text{min}} , \rho^{*}=\rho^{*}_{\text{max}} ). The initial temperature-induced density difference defines an unstable configuration, due to the presence of gravity g acting in vertical direction. A sketch of the flow configuration is provided in Fig. 1 (b). To quantify the efficiency of convective transport, we measure the Nusselt number \nus , defined as the total vertical heat flux normalized by its purely diffusive value. Note that the problem formulation is independent of the transported scalar considered, i.e., whether heat or mass fluxes are considered. We derive the results in the frame of thermal convection in analogy with previous works ( boffetta2010prl ) . However,

Read the complete text