Reinforcing Prestige: Journal Citation Biases in Astronomy

Vardan Adibekyan, Olivier Demangeon, Tiago Campante, Nuno Santos, Susana Barros, Artur Hakobyan · 2026

Read Reinforcing Prestige: Journal Citation Biases in Astronomy by Vardan Adibekyan, Olivier Demangeon, Tiago Campante, Nuno Santos, Susana Barros, Artur Hakobyan (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-25349.txt.

Introduction

Adibekyan and co-authors audit a quarter million astronomy papers for journal citation bias. Big cross-field journals draw up to nine times more citations than their article share earns. Field journals get cited less than their output would suggest. Authors also cite a journal more once they publish in it, most strongly for the big titles. That habit has eased over the past decade but still shows. Topic clusters, habits, and editor-pleasing likely drive the skew. The team urges care with citation-based scores.

Catalog record

CREATORVardan Adibekyan, Olivier Demangeon, Tiago Campante, Nuno Santos, Susana Barros, Artur Hakobyan
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33273
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.25349

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Reinforcing Prestige: Journal Citation Biases in Astronomy Vardan Adibekyan, Olivier Demangeon, Tiago Campante, Nuno Santos, Susana Barros, Artur Hakobyan Abstract Citations are essential for recognizing scientific contributions, yet citation behavior is shaped by more than just relevance or quality. We analyzed approximately 255,000 refereed astronomy articles published between 2000 and 2025 to investigate how journals are cited relative to their publication volume and authorship context. We find that multidisciplinary journals receive disproportionately more citations, up to nine times higher than their share of articles, while field-specific journals are cited less frequently in proportion to their output. Citations to a journal also increase significantly when authors publish within it, a bias particularly pronounced in multidisciplinary journals. Although this effect has declined over the past decade, it remains notable. These patterns likely arise from a combination of topical clustering, institutional/individual publishing habits, and strategic referencing to align with editorial expectations. Our findings reveal persistent structural biases in scientific visibility and suggest that citation-based metrics should be used with greater awareness of the publishing context they reflect. We encourage authors, reviewers, and editors to remain mindful of these dynamics and strive for fairness and inclusivity when selecting references. This manuscript presents the full version of a shorter Research Note submitted to RNAAS. Citations are the primary means by which scientific work acknowledges and builds upon previous research. Ideally, references should be selected with fairness and objectivity, giving proper credit to all relevant contributions. In practice, however, unconscious biases often shape citation choices. Citation bias is not merely an analytical concern but an ethical one, with implications for the equitable dissemination of knowledge and the marginalization of underrepresented voices in science [ 1 ] . While bibliometric indicators can support research evaluation, their misuse as simplistic proxies for scientific excellence or career merit can be misleading and even harmful [ 4 ] . Many researchers have experienced the frustration of seeing their own work or that of colleagues overlooked in articles addressing topics directly related to their expertise. The authors of this manuscript are no exception. Whether such omissions stem from a lack of awareness or from conscious decisions, the result can be perceived as ignorance of the field or even deliberate exclusion. But how widespread are these citation biases? Are they isolated incidents involving individual researchers or research groups, or do they reflect systematic tendencies within the publishing ecosystem? In this study, we investigate patterns of citation behavior in astronomy to assess the presence and extent of such biases. To explore these dynamics, we assembled a large bibliographic dataset of refereed astronomy publications spanning the years 2000 to 2025. We retrieved records from the SAO/NASA Astrophysics Data System (ADS) using a set of thematic keywords representative of diverse subfields in astronomy: Exoplanet, Star, Galaxy, and AGN . Our final dataset consists of 255,008 refereed articles. These articles were published across 769 unique journals. However, approximately 62% of them appear in just three major astronomy journals: The Astrophysical Journal (ApJ), Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society (MNRAS), and Astronomy & Astrophysics (A&A). Note that The Astrophysical Journal (ApJ) and ApJ Letters are treated as a single journal in our analysis, as both are indexed under the unified journal name "ApJ" in the ADS Bibcode records. The Astronomical Journal (AJ) and The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series (ApJS) are listed separately and are not merged. The fourth most frequent journal in our dataset is Physical Review D (PhRvD), which contains approximately 3.3 times fewer articles than A&A. Unlike the top three journals, PhRvD is primarily focused on theoretical astrophysics and cosmology and does not cover the full breadth of astronomical research. This thematic specialization may influence citation dynamics, as niche journals are less likely to be broadly cited by more generalist publications. In this study, we concentrated on analyzing citation trends and potential biases in the three dominant astronomy journals: The Astrophysical Journal (ApJ), Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society (MNRAS), and Astronomy & Astrophysics (A&A). We also included the relatively recent, high-impact journal Nature Astronomy (NatAs), along with two broad-scope multidisciplinary journals, Nature (Natur) and Science (Sci). While our primary focus is on articles published in these six journals, all citations and references are analyzed using the full dataset of 255 thousand articles, allowing us to capture how each journal is cited across the broader astronomy literature. The share of articles published in the selected journals is illustrated in Figure 1 . ApJ has the largest share, accounting for approximately 26% of all articles, while NatAs and Sci have the smallest shares, each contributing around 0.25%. Figure 1 : Relative contribution of each journal to the total number of articles in the field (bar chart, left axis), compared with the mean fraction of references to that journal across all articles in the dataset (black circles, right axis). The numbers above the markers indicate the ratio between the mean reference fraction and the journal’s share of publications. This ratio highlights how frequently journals are cited relative to their publication volume. These publication shares have shifted over time (see Methods). In the last 5 years, MNRAS has overtaken ApJ, contributing roughly 23% of all articles, slightly more than ApJ. Meanwhile, Science continues to have the smallest share of publications in our astronomy dataset (about 0.15%), which is approximately three times fewer than Nature and four times fewer than Nature Astronomy . To better understand the role and perceived impact of these journals within the field, we compared their share of publications with the average fraction of references they receive across all articles. This comparison is shown in Figure 1 . A citation ratio greater than 1 indicates that a journal is referenced more frequently than would be proportional to its publication share, suggesting a relatively higher visibility or broader relevance. Conversely, a ratio below 1 suggests that a journal is cited less often relative to how much it contributes in terms of article volume. For example, although ApJ accounts for approximately 26% of all articles, it is referenced slightly more often than its publication share (citation ratio \sim 1.08). As noted earlier, we treat ApJ and ApJ Letters as a single journal in this analysis, although the latter has a substantially higher impact factor [ 7 ] . In contrast, MNRAS , despite being the second most prolific journal, shows a noticeably lower citation ratio (around 0.68), indicating that it is cited less frequently relative to its publication volume. A&A shows a moderate citation deficit with a ratio of about 0.82. On the other end of the spectrum, multidisciplinary journals such as Science and Nature receive citation fractions far exceeding their publication shares, with citation ratios of 3.86 and 3.50, respectively. This aligns with their longstanding reputation for high-impact publications and their broader readership across disciplines, despite the relatively small number of astronomy-related articles they publish. These journals, while classified as multidisciplinary, have been shown to consistently overrepresent certain high-visibility fields [ 5 ] , which may further inflate their citation ratios within specific topics. Moreover, journal venue itself exerts a causal influence on citation counts, independent of article quality [ 6 ] , reinforcing the role of journal prestige in amplifying scientific visibility. This

Read the complete text