Secant-quandle: an invariant of braids and knots
Yangzhou Liu, Seongjeong Kim, Vassily Olegovich Manturov · 2026
Read Secant-quandle: an invariant of braids and knots by Yangzhou Liu, Seongjeong Kim, Vassily Olegovich Manturov (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-25256.txt.
Introduction
Kim, Liu, and Manturov build a new invariant for braids and knots called the secant-quandle. Quandles already serve as knot invariants that count how arcs can be labeled. This version grows from secants, lines that cut a knot in set ways. Homotopy classes of plain secants and flat trisecants supply the raw material. The result widens the usual knot quandle. It aims to hold richer shape data than the classic tool. The construction gives knot theory a fresh algebraic lens.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yangzhou Liu, Seongjeong Kim, Vassily Olegovich Manturov |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 28764 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.25256
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Secant-quandle: an invariant of braids and knots Yangzhou Liu, Seongjeong Kim, Vassily Olegovich Manturov Abstract We construct a novel invariant of braids and knots, secant-quandle ( SQ ), with generic secants serving as generators and generic horizontal trisecants serving as relations, i.e., SQ(M)=\Gamma\langle\mathcal{S}_{M}\mid\mathcal{T}_{M},\mathcal{E}_{M}\rangle , where M is a braid or link. Let \beta:=\beta(t):=\{A_{k}(t)\}_{k=1}^{n} , A_{k}:[0,1]\rightarrow\mathbb{C} , be a braid, where the initial points \{A_{k}(0)\}_{k=1}^{n} are arranged in sequence on the semicircle. Each braid exactly corresponds to \binom{n}{2} ruled surfaces R_{jk}:=\{p\mid p\in\overline{A_{j}A_{k}}(t),t\in[0,1]\}. \beta(t) is generic if each intersection point between the interior of any R_{jl} and A_{k}(t) is transverse at A_{k}(t_{0}) . Then these intersection points are finite and 1-1 corresponding to generic horizontal trisecants jkl:=A_{j}A_{k}A_{l}(t_{0}) . Definition 1 . A film-frame is open disk D on a ruled surface divided by two adjacent trisecants A_{j}B_{j}C_{j} ( j=0,1 ), where D\cap A_{j}B_{j}C_{j}\in\{AB,BC,AC\} , as shown in Figure 1 . Figure 1: Trisecants divide R_{ij} into several film-frame . Definition 2 . Two horizontal secants AB and A^{\prime}B^{\prime} of a braid \beta or knot K are local secant homotopic , denoted by AB\overset{loc}{\sim}A^{\prime}B^{\prime} , if there exist two adjacent film-frames D_{j}\subset R_{AB} ( j=0,1 ) and a continuous family of horizontal secant h_{t}\left(AB\right)\subset\overline{D_{0}\cup D_{1}} , t\in[0,1] such that h_{0}(AB)=AB,\quad h_{1}(AB)=A^{\prime}B^{\prime}, and for any t , h_{t}(AB)\cap M=\varnothing,h_{t}(A)\neq h_{t}(B). the interior of h_{t}(AB) is disjoint from M=\beta,K . AB\sim A^{\prime}B^{\prime} means that AB=A_{0}B_{0}\overset{loc}{\sim}A_{1}B_{1}\overset{loc}{\sim}\cdots\overset{loc}{\sim}A_{m}B_{m}=A^{\prime}B^{\prime}. Remark 1 . The definition can be slightly relaxed by permitting secants to degenerate to critical points at the endpoints ( t=0,1 ). How does secant homotopy differ from the usual homotopy of secants? Consider a 1-punctured disc with two secants e^{\pm} , each homotopic to a top or bottom critical point of this disc, respectively. Under usual homotopy e^{+} is equivalent to e^{-} , whereas secant homotopy e^{+}\nsim e^{-} . Definition 3 . Let \beta:=\{A_{j}(t):[0,1]\rightarrow\mathbb{C}\}_{j=1}^{n} be a braid, then SQ(\beta):=\Gamma\langle\mathcal{S}_{\beta}\mid\mathcal{T}_{\beta}\rangle where \mathcal{S}_{\beta} is the set of horizontal secant homotopy classes, \mathcal{T}_{\beta} is the set of generic horizontal trisecants, and each trisecant ABC:=A_{j}A_{k}A_{l}(t_{0}) as a relation among nearby secants: AB^{+}\sim AB^{-} , BA^{+}\sim BA^{-} , BC^{+}\sim BC^{-} , CB^{+}\sim CB- , AC^{\pm} , CA^{\pm} , where AB^{\pm}:=A_{j}A_{k}(t_{0}\pm\epsilon) . If \mathrm{sign}(ABC):=\det(AC,Oz,T_{B}\beta)>0 then we have ABC:{AC^{-}}\mapsto AC^{+}={AC^{-}}\circ{AB} {CBA}:{CA^{-}}\mapsto CA^{+}={CA^{-}}\mathbin{/}{CB}. (1) If \mathrm{sign}(ABC)<0 then interchange \circ and / in the above two equations. We will show that SQ is a braid invariant in Theorem 1 . The definition of SQ for knots is more involved: we focus on plat closure knots (termed Birman knots). Unlike braids with rich secant local homotopy classes as generators, Birman knots require that identify secant homotopy classes near critical points, i.e., AC\overset{loc}{\sim}XC\overset{loc}{\sim}BC , where X is a critical point connecting strand A and B . Thus, for Birman knot at top level, for a sufficiently small \epsilon>0 , we have A_{1}A_{3}(\epsilon)\sim A_{1}A_{4}(\epsilon)\sim A_{2}A_{3}(\epsilon)\sim A_{2}A_{4}(\epsilon),\cdots with a similar relation holding at the bottom level. The secants homotopic to critical points, also need special treatment (see Definition 5 ). Definition 4 . A knot K:\mathbb{S}^{1}\hookrightarrow\mathbb{R}^{3} is a Birman knot if K is a plat closure of a braid \beta\in B_{2n} (Fig 2 ), which has the following properties: • It is contained in the subset of \mathbb{R}^{3} which is represented by the inequalities -0.25\leq z\leq 1.25 . • It meets the planes z=-0.25 and z=1.25 in precisely n points, and every other plane z=z_{0} , -0.25<z_{0}<1.25 in precisely 2n points denoted by \{X_{j}^{\pm}\}_{j=1}^{2n} , where X_{j}^{+}:=A_{j}(0) and X_{j}^{-}:=A_{j}(1) . Figure 2: Birman knot and generators of K_{2n} . All the knots we mentioned are based on the above braids \beta\in B_{2n} , and we consider their plat closures K:=\hat{\beta} , called Birman knot , which we have two propositions [ 1 ] : Proposition 1 . Every link L can be presented as a plat closure of a braid \beta\in B_{2n} . Proposition 2 . Let L_{1} and L_{2} be (stable) equivalent links. Let \beta_{j}\in B_{2n_{j}} , j=1,2 , such that the plat closure of \beta_{j} is equivalent to L_{j} . Then there exists t\geq\max(n_{1},n_{2}) such that for each n\geq t , \beta_{j}^{\prime}=\beta_{j}\sigma_{n_{j}}\sigma_{n_{j}+2}\cdots\sigma_{2n},\quad j=1,2 are in the same double coset of B_{2n} modulo the subgroup K_{2n}\subset B_{2n} , where K_{2n}:=\langle\sigma_{1},\sigma_{2}\sigma_{1}^{2}\sigma_{2},\sigma_{2k}\sigma_{2k-1}\sigma_{2k+1}\sigma_{2k},1\leq k\leq n-1\rangle. The generators of K_{2n} depicted in Figure 2 . Lemma 1 . Let ABC be a trisecant of a knot, if BC is local secant homortopic to critical point, then we have AC^{+}=AC^{-} . Proof. If BC\overset{loc}{\sim}e_{j}^{\pm} , then AB^{\pm}=AX_{j}^{\pm}=AC^{\pm} . Substituting into equation ( 1 ) to obtain the result, since a\circ a=a is an axiom of quandles. ∎ Lemma 2 . If two trisecants A_{j}B_{j}C_{j}\subset\partial D , j=0,1 , where D is a film-frame, and B_{0},B_{1} are two consecutive intersection points of the ruled surface R_{AC} with strand of B . Then considering the secant-quandle relation ( 1 ) we have A_{0}C_{0}^{-}=A_{1}C_{1}^{+}. Proof. We check whether the action is also compatible with this conclusion. Since A_{0}^{+}=A_{1}^{-},\quad B_{0}^{+}=B_{1}^{-},\quad C_{0}^{+}=C_{1}^{-} (2) According to the secant-quandle relation (for any \pm t_{B}\in T_{B}K inducing different signs of these trisecants), let \star=\circ,/ (since strand A_{j} and A_{k} maybe have different orientations), we have A_{0}C_{0}^{+}=A_{0}C_{0}^{-}\star A_{0}B_{0}=A_{0}C_{0}^{-}\star A_{0}B_{0}^{+} (3) A_{1}C_{1}^{-}=A_{1}C_{1}^{+}\star A_{1}B_{1}=A_{1}C_{1}^{+}\star A_{1}B_{1}^{-} (4) If we substitute ( 3 ) into ( 4 ) then we have A_{0}C_{0}^{-}=A_{1}C_{1}^{+} . ∎ Definition 5 . Let K is a Birman knot [ 1 ] . Let \mathcal{E}_{K}:=\{e_{j}^{\pm}\}_{j=1}^{n} where e_{j}^{\pm}\overset{loc}{\sim}X_{j}^{\pm} . ABC is a trivial trisecant of a knot if it belongs to one of the following two types. • Type 1. If AB or BC\in\mathcal{E}_{K} (in secant homotopy class sense 2 ). The set of all Type 1 trivial trisecants is denoted by \mathcal{T}_{1} . If a trisecant ABC\in\mathcal{T}_{1} , it means ABC:AC^{+}=AC^{-} . • Type 2. If two trisecants A_{j}B_{j}C_{j}\subset\partial D , j=0,1 , satisfy the conditions of Lemma 2 , or the middle secant B_{0}B_{1}\in\mathcal{E}_{K} (in homotopy sense 2 if B_{0}B_{1} exists), see Figure 3 . The set of all Type 2 trivial trisecants is denoted by \mathcal{T}_{2} . If A_{j}B_{j}C_{j}\in\mathcal{T}_{2} , they mean equations ( 3 ) and ( 4 ) in Lemma 2 . Figure 3: Type 2 Definition 6 . Secant-quandle SQ(K) of knot K=\hat{\beta}_{2n} is presented as SQ(K):=\Gamma\langle\mathcal{S}_{K}\mid\mathcal{T}_{K},\mathcal{E}_{K}\rangle, where the relations \mathcal{T}_{K} means the actions induced by any trisecant ABC and CBA\in\mathcal{T}_{M} (see Definition 3 and 5 ; \mathcal{E}_{K} means two typies relaions: • for any secant a\in\mathcal{S}_{K} and e\sim e_{j}\in\mathcal{E}_{K} , we have a\circ e=a. (5) • For a sufficiently small \epsilon>0 and distinct odd indices j,k\in\{1,3,\cdots,2n-1\} , we have the following identification: A_{j}A_{k}(\epsilon)=A_{j}A_{k+1}(\epsilon)=A_{j+1}A_{k}(\epsilon)=A_{j+1}A_{k+1}(\epsilon) (6) with the analogous relation holding at the bottom level. Lemma 3 . (Stability under trivial trisecant additions) Let M and M^{\prime} be two braids (or knots) diagrams that coincide except the trisecant \mathcal{T}_{M^{\prime}}=\mathcal{T}_{M}\cup\mathcal{T}^{\prime} , where \mathcal{T}^{\prime}=\{ABC\} is Type 1, or \mathcal{T}^{\prime}=\{A_{j}B_{j}C_{j}\}_{j=0,1} is Type 2. Then the associated secant-quandles are isomorphic: SQ(M)\cong SQ(M^{\prime}). Proof. Without gen We construct explicit isomorphisms. Case 1: If \mathcal{T}^{\prime}=\{ABC\} is Type 1. By Definition 5 , the secant AB or BC is trivial, hence AC^{+}=AC^{-} . Denote associated secant in SQ(M) by AC . Define a map f:SQ(M^{\prime})\to SQ(M) on generators by f(AC^{\pm})=AC , and f(a)=a for all other a\in\mathcal{S}_{M^{\prime}} . The Type 1 trisecant introduces no new independent generator, so f is a bijective, thus f is an isomorphism.