Bayesian Inference for Epidemic Final Size Datasets with Hidden Underlying Household Structure
Joseph Brooks, Thomas House, Lorenzo Pellis, Joe Hilton · 2026
Read Bayesian Inference for Epidemic Final Size Datasets with Hidden Underlying Household Structure by Joseph Brooks, Thomas House, Lorenzo Pellis, Joe Hilton (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-25235.txt.
Introduction
Brooks and co-authors infer how fast a disease spreads inside homes when the home layout itself is hidden. Final-size data say who fell ill, but not how homes were structured. The spread rate that modelers need hides behind that missing structure. Their Bayesian method fills in plausible household layouts as it samples, using a Markov chain search. It works at several reporting resolutions. On fake data it covers the true rate over 90 percent of the time. A COVID-19 dataset shows size-split reporting cuts error a lot.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Joseph Brooks, Thomas House, Lorenzo Pellis, Joe Hilton |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 56344 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY SA |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.25235
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Bayesian Inference for Epidemic Final Size Datasets with Hidden Underlying Household Structure Joseph Brooks, Thomas House, Lorenzo Pellis, Joe Hilton Abstract Households represent a key unit of interest in infectious disease epidemiology, in both empirical studies and mathematical modelling. The within-household transmission potential of an infectious disease is often summarised in terms of a secondary attack ratio, the proportion of an index case’s household contacts who become infected during the index case’s infectious period. Despite its widespread use, the secondary attack ratio depends on the distribution of household compositions seen during the study period, making the information it conveys difficult to generalise to new populations and different contexts. Extending estimates of transmission potential to new populations instead requires estimates of person-to-person transmission rates which can be convoluted with data on population structure to parametrise mechanistic transmission models. In this study we present a new Bayesian inference method which uses an MCMC algorithm to infer the transmission intensity by imputing the unreported household structure underlying the epidemic dynamics. This method can be run on household epidemiological data reported at varying levels of resolution. For synthetic data from a realistic underlying household size distribution, we were able to achieve over 95% coverage in our estimates of transmission rate over a range of transmission intensity scenarios. The method was also able to consistently achieve over 95% coverage for data generated with a pathological underlying household size distribution, given strong information about the household size distribution. Using an existing dataset which recorded micro-scale household epidemiological outcomes during the COVID-19 pandemic, we show that at least stratifying observed secondary attack ratios by household size substantially reduces the uncertainty in transmission parameter estimates. Our findings suggest that researchers conducting household epidemiological studies can drastically improve the utility of their results to infectious disease modellers by reporting household-stratified estimates, without needing to report full micro-level transmission outcomes. These results aim to encourage the reporting of higher resolution outputs in future epidemiological field work as, in the absence of strong priors, the transmission parameters were not easily identifiable from low resolution datasets, which are commonly reported. Introduction Households are important units of study in infectious disease epidemiology, both as sites of prolonged intense social contact and as convenient population units for empirical studies [ 26 , 24 ] . Studies that investigate within-household transmission studies are common and provide essential data on emerging pathogens, while household structure plays an extremely important role in determining the onward spread of infection. For example, during the COVID-19 pandemic contact-tracing studies showed household contacts to be much more likely to be infected than other types of contacts (e.g. workplace, social) [ 42 , 3 , 4 ] . Household structure also plays a key role in interventions against infection, with non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) such as stay-at-home orders acting at the household level, and uptake of vaccines showing correlations within families. In field studies of household transmission, secondary attack rate (SAR), defined as the number of secondary cases divided by the number of contacts, is ubiquitous as a measure of transmissibility of a pathogen in enclosed settings such as households. As a simple ratio, it can be calculated from relatively coarse epidemiological data, requiring field researchers only to identify cohabitants of an index case and record their infection status over a sufficiently long period. Despite its widespread use, its simplicity makes the SAR poorly suited to capture the complex dynamics of person-to-person transmission. Infectious disease dynamics arise from a combination of biological and sociological factors which the SAR summarises as a single number, meaning that an estimate of SAR from an outbreak in one population provides very limited insight into the behaviour of future outbreaks in other populations with differing demographic and social contact structures. Instead, mechanistic models that are parameterised to reflect the social structure of specific populations are necessary to analyse infectious disease outbreaks and to make predictions. Mechanistic mathematical models play an important role providing quantitative evidence and models have been developed that take account the geographical, gender/sex, age, workplace and household structured complexity in social mixing patterns [ 6 , 33 , 14 ] . Despite the considerable literature on household-structured epidemic modelling and due to the ubiquity of the SAR, empirical household transmission studies most often report their data with SAR and logistic regression in mind. These studies often only report the number of cases and the number of contacts, giving little to no information on the household size distribution and only reporting the mean of the household final size distribution. Because each secondary infectious cases increases the infectious pressure on any remaining susceptible household members and thus increases their likelihood of being infected, the household final size distribution is often bimodal and so particularly poorly-described by its mean (see, e.g. [ 15 ] , Figure 2). While efficient likelihood-based methods for parameterising mechanistic models exist and are relatively efficient in populations of the small scale of a household [ 1 , 15 ] , they require higher resolution data than just the reported overall SAR. Therefore, in order to estimate person-to-person transmission rates from these studies we must augment the datasets, imputing the household structure that underlies them. Data augmentation and data imputation have a long and successful history of use in inference for a variety of applications in infectious disease modelling [ 31 , 20 , 46 , 41 ] . The central problem these methods seek to address is that epidemics are rarely fully observed, meaning that epidemiological datasets are often incomplete and so we cannot directly evaluate the model likelihood based on these data alone. Data imputation approaches address this by augmenting these datasets with the missing information and treating the unobserved data as parameters. Standard parameter inference methods, often using MCMC, can then be used with additional steps which propose values for the missing data and identify scenarios which are most consistent with the outcomes we do observe. In this study we present a novel mass imputation MCMC method for estimating transmission rates from household-stratified datasets at three different levels of detail: low information datasets which report the total number of contacts, the total number of secondary cases, and the number of households, with no information on how infection stratifies by household size; medium information datasets which report these same outcomes stratified by household size; and high information datasets which report the number of contacts and cases for each individual household included in the study. In the high information setting our method resembles a standard likelihood-based MCMC approach, while in the low and medium information cases we impute the number of contacts and cases in each household and evaluate the joint likelihoods of specific combinations of parameter and distribution of contacts and cases by household. Our method can incorporate existing knowledge of background demography by using the household size distribution of the ambient population as a basis for its proposals of household-specific contact and case numbers. We validate our method by demonstrating that it is able to successfully recover transmission rates from synthetic data generated with an underlying household size distribution taken from the UK labour force survey [ 30 ] over a range of parameter values. For data generated from a pathological