Direct numerical simulation of out-scale-actuated spanwise wall oscillation in turbulent boundary layers
Jizhong Zhang 1, Fazle Hussain 2, Jie Yao 3,4 · 2026
Read Direct numerical simulation of out-scale-actuated spanwise wall oscillation in turbulent boundary layers by Jizhong Zhang 1, Fazle Hussain 2, Jie Yao 3,4 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-25200.txt.
Introduction
Zhang, Hussain, and Yao simulate a wall that slides sideways to calm a turbulent boundary layer. Long actuation zones and slow cycles, scaled to outer flow units, set this study apart. At short periods, drag savings shrink as the flow speeds up, as older inner-scaled work found. At long periods the trend flips: savings grow with Reynolds number. Part of the gain comes from the flow's own drift downstream. A new formula links drag to the wake's speed shift. Spectra checks pin the cause on near-wall motion.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jizhong Zhang 1, Fazle Hussain 2, Jie Yao 3,4 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 77307 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.25200
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Direct numerical simulation of out-scale-actuated spanwise wall oscillation in turbulent boundary layers Jizhong Zhang 1, Fazle Hussain 2, Jie Yao 3,4 Abstract Spanwise wall oscillation (SWO) of turbulent boundary layers (TBLs) is investigated via direct numerical simulations over an extended actuation region (momentum Reynolds number 344 < R e θ < 2340 344<Re_{\theta}<2340 ) with oscillation periods up to T s c + = 600 T_{sc}^{+}=600 , scaled by the uncontrolled friction velocity u τ 0 u_{\tau 0} at the onset of SWO (i.e. R e θ = 344 Re_{\theta}=344 ). For low periods ( T s c + < 200 T_{sc}^{+}<200 ), drag reduction ( D R DR ) decreases with increasing R e θ Re_{\theta} , consistent with conventional inner-scaled control strategies targeting near-wall turbulence. In sharp contrast, for large periods ( T s c + > 200 T_{sc}^{+}>200 ), D R DR increases with R e θ Re_{\theta} . For example, at T s c + = 600 T_{sc}^{+}=600 , D R DR rises from 1.3% at R e θ = 713 Re_{\theta}=713 to 7.0% at R e θ = 2340 Re_{\theta}=2340 . This unexpected growth is partly explained by the streamwise evolution of the effective oscillation parameter: as TBL develops, u τ 0 u_{\tau 0} decreases downstream, reducing the local-scaled period T + T^{+} and thereby enhancing suppression of near-wall turbulence. Interestingly, even the results are compared at approximately fixed T + T^{+} , D R DR for T + > 350 T^{+}>350 still exhibits a weak positive dependence on R e θ Re_{\theta} , consistent with recent experiments by Marusic et al. Nat. Commun. , vol. 12, 2021, 5805. We further develop a new analytical relationship that links D R DR to the upward shift of mean velocity in the wake region. Unlike previous formulations, the relationship avoids logarithmic-region fitting and does not rely on an invariant Kármán constant under SWO, while maintaining good agreement with DNS data. Flow diagnostics – including Reynolds stresses, skin-friction decomposition, and energy spectra – demonstrate that the observed variation of D R DR with Reynolds number ( R e Re ) arises from period-dependent modulation of near-wall turbulence. Overall, these findings challenge the conventional view that D R DR inevitably deteriorates with R e Re and demonstrate that out-scaled actuation can instead enhance D R DR performance – offering new physical insights for high- R e Re control strategies. † † affiliation: 1 School of Aerospace Engineering, Beijing Institute of Technology, Beijing, China, 100081 2 Department of Mechanical Engineering, Texas Tech University, Lubbock, TX, USA, 79407 3 Beijing Institute of Technology (Zhuhai), Zhuhai, China, 519088 4 School of Interdisciplinary Science, Beijing Institute of Technology, Beijing, China, 100081 1 Introduction Skin friction drag constitutes a major portion of the total resistance experienced by automobiles, aircraft, and marine vessels. Its mitigation is essential to improve energy efficiency and reduce pollution and climate change. Over the past decades, numerous flow control strategies have been explored, including riblets ( 10 ) , opposition control ( 11 ) , large-scale swirls ( 53 ; 70 ) , electromagnetic excitation ( 4 ) , and wall-based forcing ( 29 ; 17 ) . Among these methods, wall-based active control has proven highly effective in achieving significant drag reduction ( DR ). A widely studied approach is the streamwise traveling waves (STW), typically expressed as \displaystyle w_{w}\left(x,t\right)={W_{m}}(x)\sin\left(\kappa_{x}x-\omega t\right), (1) where w_{w} is the spanwise wall velocity, {W_{m}} is its amplitude, \kappa_{x} is the streamwise wavenumber and \omega={2\pi}/{T} the angular frequency. Two limiting cases emerge: spanwise wall oscillation (SWO) when \kappa_{x}=0 , and stationary waves when \omega=0 . STW-based control has been extensively investigated through simulations and experiments in channel ( 42 ; 21 ; 27 ; 22 ; 20 ) , pipe ( 2 ; 35 ) , and turbulent boundary layers (TBLs) ( 57 ; 59 ; 61 ; 5 ) . The primary objective of these studies was to achieve DR through interrupting the regeneration cycle of near-wall coherent structures (i.e. low-speed streaks and quasi-streamwise vortices). Therefore, actuation parameters (e.g. wavenumbers and frequencies) are typically selected in inner-unit scaling – a strategy termed inner-scaled actuation (ISA) by 48 . ISA techniques, though often requiring relatively high actuation frequencies, can achieve substantial DR . For example, 22 reported more than 20% DR in channel flows for Re_{\tau}<1000 with periods near the optimal T^{+}\approx 100 . Here, T^{+}=Tu_{\tau 0}^{2}/\nu is scaled by the uncontrolled friction velocity u_{\tau 0}\equiv\sqrt{\tau_{w0}/\rho} and the kinematic viscosity \nu . Throughout this work, quantities scaled by uncontrolled friction velocity u_{\tau 0} are denoted with a superscript + , while those scaled by actual friction velocity u_{\tau} are denoted with a superscript * . Additionally, in the experimental study of 38 , a maximum DR of nearly 30% at Re_{\tau}(\equiv u_{\tau}\delta_{99}/\nu)=951 is observed with T^{+}\approx 140 , where \delta_{99} is the boundary layer thickness. Despite their high gross DR , ISA strategies suffer from some major limitations. First, the high actuation frequency requires substantial energy input, which can usually exceed the energy saved through DR , yielding little or no net benefit. Second, its performance also deteriorates with increasing Reynolds number ( Re ), as confirmed by numerous studies ( 27 ; 22 ; 71 ; 61 ) . Additionally, achieving ISA in practical applications is challenging due to implementation constraints ( 38 ) . To address these issues, 38 proposed a strategy aimed at altering large-scale eddies in and above the logarithmic region. This approach, termed out-scaled actuation (OSA) by 48 , represents a significant departure from conventional ISA. The actuation periods associated with OSA are characterized by T^{+}\gg 100 . Specifically, OSA typically employs actuation periods of T^{+}>350 ( 38 ) . Although OSA generally yields smaller DR than ISA, the lower actuation frequency reduces input power and thus offers greater potential for net energy savings. Moreover, OSA exhibits a qualitatively different Re -dependence: DR tends to increase with Re_{\tau} ( 38 ; 7 ) , plausibly because outer-layer motions strengthen with Re_{\tau} and constitute increasingly effective control targets. This favorable scaling has recently been challenged by 20 , who conducted direct numerical simulations (DNS) of open channel flow under STW for 1000\leq Re_{\tau}\leq 6000 . Employing control parameters matching 38 and 7 , they found no increase of DR with Re_{\tau} . Instead, their results followed similar Re -dependence observed for ISA. They proposed several explanations for such discrepancies, including differences in flow configurations and experimental non-idealities (e.g. discrete actuators, waveform distortion, phase lag). Although there has been growing interest in OSA-driven DR , numerical studies of this effect are, to our knowledge, lacking in TBLs. To address this gap, we perform here high-fidelity DNS of TBLs under OSA. Previous works have focused almost exclusively on STW, governed by three control parameters: W_{m} , \kappa_{x} , and \omega ( 22 ) . In contrast, SWO involves fewer parameters while retaining the same turbulence-suppression mechanism, making it a cleaner configuration for isolating the effects of OSA. Although SWO in the ISA regime has been extensively studied both