Permeation of hydrogen across graphdiyne: molecular dynamics vs. quantum simulations and role of membrane motion Journal: Surfaces and Interfaces

Mateo Rodríguez, José Campos-Martínez, Marta I. Hernández · 2026

Read Permeation of hydrogen across graphdiyne: molecular dynamics vs. quantum simulations and role of membrane motion Journal: Surfaces and Interfaces by Mateo Rodríguez, José Campos-Martínez, Marta I. Hernández (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-24827.txt.

Introduction

Rodríguez and co-authors compare quantum and classical simulations of hydrogen crossing a graphdiyne membrane. Graphdiyne's sub-nanometre pores suit it to separating small gas molecules, but quantum effects may matter for light molecules. Their rigorous quantum calculations use a static membrane and improved Lennard-Jones force fields fitted to ab initio data. Classical molecular dynamics roughly reproduces how quantum permeance varies with temperature between 250 and 350 kelvin. Adding Feynman-Hibbs quantum corrections gives a lower bound on the quantum permeance.

Catalog record

CREATORMateo Rodríguez, José Campos-Martínez, Marta I. Hernández
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38441
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.24827

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Permeation of hydrogen across graphdiyne: molecular dynamics vs. quantum simulations and role of membrane motion Journal: Surfaces and Interfaces Mateo Rodríguez, José Campos-Martínez, Marta I. Hernández Abstract Previous research based on electronic structure calculations and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations have demonstrated that graphdiyne (GDY) is a very suitable two-dimensional membrane for the separation of small molecules in a gas mixture of different species. However, quantum effects may play a role in the dynamics of these permeation processes when light molecules are the ones involved in the crossing of the GDY subnanometric pores. In this work we report rigorous quantum-mechanical calculations together with equivalent MD simulations of the transport of H 2 molecules through a static GDY membrane, as a case study for the validity of the application to these problems of classical dynamics. The force fields employed are based on an improved Lennard-Jones formulation, with parameters optimized by means of accurate ab initio calculations. It is found that, although quantum effects are still significant at the temperatures of interest (between 250 and 350 K), MD simulations are able to reasonably reproduce the dependence of the quantum permeances with the temperature. Moreover, MD permeances computed with quantum corrections through Feynman-Hibbs effective potentials provide a lower bound to quantum permeances, while the pure classical counterpart gives an upper bound, thus leading to a well delimited range of confidence of the permeation results. Furthermore, within MD simulations it is possible to incorporate the thermal motion of the GDY layer and in this situation it is observed an enhancement of the permeances with respect to the fixed membrane case, due to a significant reduction of the permeation barriers when the GDY atoms are allowed to vibrate. It seems apparent therefore, that modeling the membrane motion is crucial to provide reliable simulations of the gas transport features. 1 Introduction Membrane technologies are of remarkable importance for applications of separation of atoms or molecules from gaseous or liquid mixtures [ 30 , 7 , 4 ] . Since membrane permeances are higher for thinner membranes, the ultimate membrane would be a one-atom thick membrane, the celebrated 2D materials [ 56 ] . In these materials, the existence of nanopores is crucial to provide the required confinement/selectivity for the different species and ultimately for isotopic separation. Graphynes (GY) [ 26 , 47 , 29 , 17 ] are a very popular group of nanoporous carbon-based 2D materials, with several allotropes known as \alpha,\beta,\gamma- GY, [ 47 , 34 ] being a bit more stable the \gamma family [ 1 ] . This variety is well described by benzene type hexagons with vertex joined by triple acetylenic bonds, leading to triangular nanopores regularly disposed. Thus, they can be named as graph- N -ynes, with N the number of acetylene type molecules between the rings. Graphdiyne (GDY) [ 32 , 38 , 25 ] and graphtetrayne [ 20 , 40 ] have been already synthesized, and it is GDY one of the materials most widely used [ 17 , 44 ] and, therefore, almost routinely synthesized in the lab, in particular as an efficient membrane for separation of different species [ 64 , 33 , 57 , 15 ] . In this context, most of the theoretical studies on the separation of different gas species using 2D membranes have resorted to electronic structure calculations [ 28 , 61 , 60 , 54 , 37 , 36 , 23 ] or classical molecular dynamics (MD) simulations [ 51 , 15 , 62 , 2 , 52 , 35 , 3 , 54 , 36 , 23 ] , leading to useful trends and predictions of permeances and selectivities of different kinds of molecular species. However, quantum effects (such as tunneling or quantization of the transition state at the pore center) can be important in the dynamics of these processes, specially those involving light molecules and/or low temperatures. Therefore, it would be very interesting to examine the performance of MD simulations in comparison with quantum dynamics calculations in conditions where both classical and quantum models were as equivalent as possible, since we are not aware of research relevant to this issue in the literature. Most of the quantum approaches adopted so far are somehow approximate, such as the use of Feynman-Hibbs effective potentials [ 19 , 31 ] , Ring Polymer Molecular Dynamics methods [ 14 , 8 ] or quantum models of reduced dimensionality [ 48 , 6 , 24 , 43 ] . Some of us have contributed to the development of more accurate quantum methods for the transmission of molecules across 2D membranes, such as three-dimensional time-dependent wave packet (TDWP) method to compute transmission probabilities [ 22 ] and, more recently, permeances at different temperatures [ 21 ] . In the latter work, the permeation process is modeled as a molecule that can approach a rigid membrane from any incidence direction, in this way resembling the interaction of a dilute gas with a static membrane, which can be typically addressed by means of MD simulations. Figure 1 : (a) Simulation box for MD simulations, with H 2 molecules represented as point particles. Note that, to save space, its height and number of molecules is half of the box actually used in the MD calculations. (b) and (c) Lateral view of the GDY membrane for fixed- and deformable-membrane simulations, respectively. In this work we have extended previous TDWP calculations of permeances of a static GDY membrane for the transport of hydrogen [ 21 ] to higher temperatures (250-350 K) to compare with equivalent MD simulations at the same temperatures. In both classical and quantum approaches, we describe the H 2 molecules as pseudo-atoms (point particles with the mass of H 2 ), employing interaction potentials (force fields) that correspond to averages over the different orientations of these molecules [ 21 , 39 ] . We have also carried out MD simulations with Feynman-Hibbs effective potentials in order to examine the ability of these modifications in approaching the quantum results. A scheme of the setup for the MD simulations is presented in Fig. 1 .a. As in the quantum calculations, the membrane is fixed to its planar structure throughout the MD simulations (Fig. 1 .b). Quantum simulations describing the motion of the membrane are not feasible due to the enormous number of degrees of freedom involved, except in some specific approximate treatments [ 27 ] . As a second goal of this work, we have examined the role of the motion of the atoms of GDY in the transport dynamics of H 2 molecules, within the MD framework. As in free-standing graphene [ 16 , 58 ] , one can expect that a GDY sheet may also exhibit large amplitude undulations or ripples due to thermal fluctuations or interactions with molecules, indeed, as can be seen in Fig. 1 .c. This motion may affect the membrane permeances for the transport of the gas molecules, an aspect that, however, has been scarcely studied [ 9 , 3 ] . Here we find that the permeances obtained by allowing the motion of the GDY membrane are significantly larger than those corresponding to the fixed membrane approximation and analyze the rationale of this

Read the complete text