Understanding Balmer Decrements in T Tauri stars in terms of Multiflow Magnetospheric Accretion Astropy ( 5 ; 3 ; 4 ) , emcee ( 14 ) , SciPy ( 48 ) , NumPy ( 16 )

Naiara Patiño, Nuria Calvet, Gladis Magris, Marbely Micolta, Thanawuth Thanathibodee, Thomas K. Waters, María José Colmenares · 2026

Read Understanding Balmer Decrements in T Tauri stars in terms of Multiflow Magnetospheric Accretion Astropy ( 5 ; 3 ; 4 ) , emcee ( 14 ) , SciPy ( 48 ) , NumPy ( 16 ) by Naiara Patiño, Nuria Calvet, Gladis Magris, Marbely Micolta, Thanawuth Thanathibodee, Thomas K. Waters, María José Colmenares (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-24807.txt.

Introduction

Patiño and co-authors explain Balmer decrements in T Tauri stars with a two-flow accretion model. The standard one-flow model cannot reproduce the observed line ratios. Their model uses two flows with different rates and geometries side by side. Line fluxes for three Balmer lines are fitted with Bayesian statistics to 139 stars across four regions. One flow is compact and fast, hugging the star; the other is wider, thicker, and slower. Together they fit the decrements and the known luminosity correlation.

Catalog record

CREATORNaiara Patiño, Nuria Calvet, Gladis Magris, Marbely Micolta, Thanawuth Thanathibodee, Thomas K. Waters, María José Colmenares
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59024
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.24807

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Understanding Balmer Decrements in T Tauri stars in terms of Multiflow Magnetospheric Accretion Astropy ( 5 ; 3 ; 4 ) , emcee ( 14 ) , SciPy ( 48 ) , NumPy ( 16 ) Naiara Patiño, Nuria Calvet, Gladis Magris, Marbely Micolta, Thanawuth Thanathibodee, Thomas K. Waters, María José Colmenares Abstract Magnetospheric accretion is the paradigm for accretion in Classical T-Tauri Stars (CTTS). However, the standard, one-flow magnetospheric accretion model fails to replicate important characteristics such as the observed Balmer decrements. We address this limitation by adopting a model with two axisymmetric magnetospheric accretion flows of different accretion rates and geometries. We calculate the fluxes of the hydrogen H α \alpha , H β \beta , and H γ \gamma lines of each flow with the magnetospheric accretion model and use Bayesian statistics to fit the Balmer line fluxes of 139 CTTS in the Orion OB1b subassociation, and in the Upper Scorpius, Lupus and Chamaeleon I star-forming regions. We find that the Balmer decrements and line fluxes can be fitted by two distinct but coexisting flows: a compact, high accretion rate flow, close to the star and narrow (mean inner radius R i ∼ 2.9 ​ R ∗ R_{i}\sim 2.9R_{*} and mean width Δ ​ R ∼ 0.7 ​ R ∗ \Delta R\sim 0.7R_{*} ), covering a few percent of the emitting area, and a more spread out flow, thicker ( Δ ​ R ∼ 1.2 ​ R ∗ \Delta R\sim 1.2R_{*} ), and larger ( R i ∼ 3.7 ​ R ∗ R_{i}\sim 3.7R_{*} ), with lower accretion rate, encompassing the rest of the emitting area. The two-flow model can also reproduce the empirical correlation between the luminosity in H α \alpha and the accretion luminosity. Overall, our findings suggest that a multicolumn approach provides a more accurate representation of the observed Balmer line emission, in agreement with results of numerical simulations. I Introduction Conservation of angular momentum leads to the development of a disk of gas and dust during the formation of a star from the collapse of a molecular cloud core. Young stars accrete mass from this disk, and this process plays a crucial role in shaping the early evolution of both star and disk (see 17 , for a review) . Some of the best studied young stellar objects are the T Tauri stars (TTS), which are low-mass stars of late spectral types ( 17 ) . These objects can be further classified into accreting Classical T Tauri Stars (CTTS) and non-accreting Weak-lined T Tauri Stars (WTTS). Investigating the physical processes at play in these systems is essential for understanding the evolution of protoplanetary disks and the formation of planets. The prevailing model for mass accretion in TTS is the magnetospheric accretion paradigm ( 17 ; 34 ; 36 ; 35 ; 18 ) . In this framework, the stellar magnetic field truncates the inner disk, channeling disk material along field lines in accretion columns onto the stellar surface. Several lines of evidence support this model, including the observed ultraviolet (UV) excess produced by accretion shocks at the stellar surface, where infalling material decelerates and merges with the stellar atmosphere ( 9 ) , as well as the broad wings observed in emission lines ( 35 ) . The excess continuum, and the profile width and flux of emission lines are widely used to estimate mass accretion rates in TTS ( 18 ; 34 ; 36 ; 35 ) . Despite its success, 35 found that the magnetospheric accretion model tends to underpredict the Balmer lines ratio H \gamma /H \beta . They attributed this discrepancy to an inherent limitation of the model. One of the core assumptions of the magnetospheric accretion model is that of axisymmetry and homogeneity of the stellar magnetic field. However, both observational studies ( 13 , e.g.,) and magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations ( 50 ; 43 , e.g.,) indicate that the accretion flows are typically neither axisymmetric nor homogeneous. Here, we explore the implications of considering an inhomogeneous magnetosphere. In this work, we approximate the complex magnetospheric geometry expected in CTTS with a model consisting of two distinct accretion flows with different parameters, aiming to explain the observed hydrogen emission lines. The concept of multicolumn accretion has previously been applied to accretion shock models; columns of different energy density - or volume mass density, since the model adopts free-fall velocities - can successfully account for both near-ultraviolet (NUV) and optical excess emission in CTTS ( 21 ; 41 ) . There is also evidence for density gradients in the hot spots produced by accretion columns on the stellar surface ( 13 ) , agreeing with the interpretation of multiple accretion streams of varying density. Here, we extend this concept by studying multicolumn accretion, focusing on the line emission originating from the extended accretion flows themselves rather than from the shock on the stellar surface. We analyze CTTS in four star-forming regions: Lupus ( 2 ; 1 ) , Chamaeleon I ( 26 ; 31 ) , Orion OB1b ( 8 ) , and Upper Scorpius ( 29 ) (hereafter, Lup, Cha I, OB1b, and USco, respectively). These regions offer a diverse sample in terms of age, stellar parameters, and evolutionary stages, enabling us to probe accretion across different environments. This paper is organized as follows. In Section II , we describe the sample of T Tauri stars, their properties, and the observational data used. Section III presents the standard single-column magnetospheric accretion model and its limitations, introduces our proposed multicolumn model, and outlines the spectral analysis, correction procedures, and statistical methods employed. Section IV reports our findings on the impact of this modeling approach on Balmer decrements, while Section V details the results obtained from modeling the line fluxes of the stars in the samples. Finally, we discuss the broader implications of our results in Section VI . II Sample For all of our targets, we use spectra obtained with the X-Shooter spectrograph on the Very Large Telescope (VLT) ( 47 ) . The X-Shooter spectrograph offers medium resolution, broad wavelength coverage, and flux calibration. Its spectral range spans \sim 300–2500nm, enabling the extraction of key stellar parameters, as well as diagnostics of the accretion process and inner disk structure. II.1 Classical T Tauri Stars Figure 1: From left to right, distribution of relevant stellar parameters of the total sample, Lup, Cha I, Ori OB1b, and USco. These parameters are as reported in 2 ; 1 (Lup), 26 ; 31 (Cha I), 41 for \dot{\text{M}} and 28 for the rest (OB1b), and 29 (USco). Note that stellar ages increase from left to right. Top: Distribution of spectral types in our sample. Middle: Distribution of stellar masses. Bottom: Distribution of accretion rates. The key stellar and accretion parameters adopted for the final sample of 139 CTTS are shown in Figure 1 . We took the parameters from 2 ; 1 (Lup), 26 ; 31 (Cha I), 41 and 28 (OB1b), and 29 (USco). A complete table listing all parameters extracted from the literature is provided in Table 3 . Our sample focused on targets with accretion rates lower than 10^{-7}M_{\sun}\,\rm{yr^{-1}} and that did not exhibit a “P Cygni” profile in their

Read the complete text