Can an Actor-Critic Optimization Framework Improve Analog Design
Sounak Dutta, Fin Amin, Sushil Panda, Jonathan Rabe, Yuejiang Wen, Paul FranzonDepartment of Electrical and Computer EngineeringNorth Carolina State University {sdutta6, samin2, spanda4, jcrabe, wyuejia, paulf}@ncsu.edu · 2026
Read Can an Actor-Critic Optimization Framework Improve Analog Design by Sounak Dutta, Fin Amin, Sushil Panda, Jonathan Rabe, Yuejiang Wen, Paul FranzonDepartment of Electrical and Computer EngineeringNorth Carolina State University {sdutta6, samin2, spanda4, jcrabe, wyuejia, paulf}@ncsu.edu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-24714.txt.
Introduction
Dutta and co-authors present ACOF, an actor-critic optimisation framework for analog circuit sizing. Analog design is slow because small changes demand costly simulations, and good solutions sit in a narrow part of a huge search space. ACOF splits the search into two roles. An actor proposes promising regions, while a critic reviews the choices, enforces design legality, and redirects a stalled search. The flow stays compatible with standard simulator-based tools. Across test circuits, ACOF improves the top-10 figure of merit by 38.9 percent over the strongest baseline.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sounak Dutta, Fin Amin, Sushil Panda, Jonathan Rabe, Yuejiang Wen, Paul FranzonDepartment of Electrical and Computer EngineeringNorth Carolina State University {sdutta6, samin2, spanda4, jcrabe, wyuejia, paulf}@ncsu.edu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29361 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.24714
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Can an Actor-Critic Optimization Framework Improve Analog Design Optimization? Thanks: ∗ Equal contribution. Preprint. Under review. Sounak Dutta, Fin Amin, Sushil Panda, Jonathan Rabe, Yuejiang Wen, Paul FranzonDepartment of Electrical and Computer EngineeringNorth Carolina State University {sdutta6, samin2, spanda4, jcrabe, wyuejia, paulf}@ncsu.edu Abstract Analog design often slows down because even small changes to device sizes or biases require expensive simulation cycles, and high-quality solutions typically occupy only a narrow part of a very large search space. While existing optimizers reduce some of this burden, they largely operate without the kind of judgment designers use when deciding where to search next. This paper presents an actor-critic optimization framework (ACOF) for analog sizing that brings that form of guidance into the loop. Rather than treating optimization as a purely black-box search problem, ACOF separates the roles of proposal and evaluation: an actor suggests promising regions of the design space, while a critic reviews those choices, enforces design legality, and redirects the search when progress is hampered. This structure preserves compatibility with standard simulator-based flows while making the search process more deliberate, stable, and interpretable. Across our test circuits, ACOF improves the top-10 figure of merit by an average of 38.9% over the strongest competing baseline and reduces regret by an average of 24.7%, with peak gains of 70.5% in FoM and 42.2% lower regret on individual circuits. By combining iterative reasoning with simulation-driven search, the framework offers a more transparent path toward automated analog sizing across challenging design spaces. I Introduction and Motivation The demands on modern analog design continue to increase with new technology nodes, tighter specifications, and faster development cycles. Each node changes transistor behavior, invalidates earlier biasing strategies, and requires renewed exploration of the design space. From an optimization standpoint, this is no longer merely schematic tuning, but the search for a feasible region where gain, bandwidth, phase margin, and power can be satisfied together. Because performance varies nonlinearly with sizing, designers need SPICE simulations, and more knobs mean more costly trials. Even after the topology is fixed, analog sizing is rarely straightforward. It typically requires repeated evaluation and careful adjustment to satisfy several coupled specifications while managing trade-offs among performance, power, and area. In practice, analog design is still a slow and labor-intensive process, requiring extensive simulation and considerable designer expertise [ 3 , 1 , 2 ] . Fig. 1: Example of interactions between our actor and critic components over rounds during analog sizing optimization. Our framework defines a closed-loop optimization process that alternates between proposal, audit, search, and reflection. Fig. 2: An overview of our actor–critic optimization framework (ACOF). At each time step, n , the actor proposes a candidate search region \tilde{\Omega}_{n} , the critic adjusts it to a PDK-legal region \Omega_{n}^{+} , BO selects candidates x\in\Omega_{n}^{+} for simulation, and simulator outcomes are summarized into e_{n} for the next round. ACOF is agnostic to the specific choice of BO. For that reason, analog sizing has long been viewed as a constrained optimization problem. From that perspective, the central challenge is not simply to evaluate better candidate points, but to direct the search toward regions of the design space that are more likely to produce feasible and high-performing solutions under competing design constraints [ 15 , 29 , 1 , 2 ] . Human designers address this problem differently. They do not treat the search space as uniformly promising; they use judgment to focus attention, interpret trade-offs, and revise direction when progress stalls. This paper is motivated by the idea that such guidance should become part of the optimization loop itself. Recent LLM-based studies in electronic design suggest that language models can contribute to design automation as reasoning agents rather than as mere text generators [ 12 , 4 , 14 , 11 , 33 , 21 ] . Building on that perspective, our contribution is investigating casting analog sizing as an actor–critic process in which one agent proposes promising regions of the design space, another evaluates whether the search direction should be preserved or revised, and a conventional optimizer explores within the resulting region. In this way, automated analog sizing can become not only more sample-efficient, but also more interpretable and more aligned with the way experienced designers reason about difficult trade-offs. II Prior Art II-A Bayesian Optimization for Analog Circuit Sizing Bayesian optimization (BO) has advanced analog circuit sizing in several important ways [ 32 ] . WEIBO [ 15 ] formulates sizing as constrained BO with Gaussian-process (GP) surrogates and weighted expected improvement, and extends the approach to multi-objective design. Local BO [ 29 ] scales this idea to larger spaces through trust-region-based local models and batch candidate evaluation. tSS-BO [ 7 ] targets the high-dimensional setting by restricting search to an effective truncated subspace while retaining local GP guidance and Bayesian selection. II-B Language Driven Optimization Recent LLM-based work in analog design has begun to open several distinct directions rather than one unified path. LayoutCopilot [ 12 ] reimagines analog layout interaction by turning natural-language design requests into executable layout actions through a multi-agent framework, while LLANA [ 4 ] brings language models into the BO loop to generate design-dependent layout constraints, particularly net-weighting parameters for layout synthesis. AmpAgent [ 14 ] approaches amplifier design as a coordinated reasoning process across literature understanding, formula derivation, and device sizing. In contrast, AnalogCoder [ 11 ] treats analog design as a code-generation problem, using a training-free workflow to produce and iteratively correct Python-based circuit implementations. ADO-LLM [ 33 ] more directly couples an LLM with Bayesian optimization for circuit sizing, using the model to propose promising design candidates alongside a GP-based search process. LEDRO [ 10 ] , in turn, shifts the emphasis from asking the LLM for a single sizing answer to asking it to progressively narrow the search region so that optimization can proceed within a more meaningful part of the design space. More recent frameworks extend this picture in complementary ways: EEsizer [ 13 ] formulates transistor sizing as a closed-loop LLM-guided process built around simulation, analysis, and iterative parameter updates, while LLM-USO [ 26 ] focuses on structured knowledge reuse across related circuits. II-C Takeways from Prior Art These prior works point to the same recurring pressures: GP-based BO becomes harder to scale as the sample set and parameter dimension grow. Constrained search remains difficult, and exploration becomes increasingly fragile in high-dimensional spaces. Furthermore, these methods mainly act as black boxes [ 29 , 4 , 7 ] . Recent LLM-based methods have begun to address these limitations in different ways: some strengthen the reasoning and decomposition side of analog design [ 14 ] , some couple LLMs with BO to improve candidate generation within the optimization loop [ 33 ] and some demonstrate the broader value of self-reflection [ 24 ] for iterative improvement in workflows using optimizer [ 10 ] . But in these systems, guidance is still driven mainly by simulator feedback or by the model’s own reflective process, leaving a natural opening for an independent critic that can examine a proposal from outside the actor’s reasoning stream. That distinction matters because prompt-heavy LLM systems already report performance dilution under long, multitask context [ 12 ] .