Basic Canonical Brackets and Nilpotency Property of Noether (anti-)BRST Charges: Non-Abeian 1-Form Gauge Theory

R. P. Malik · 2026

Read Basic Canonical Brackets and Nilpotency Property of Noether (anti-)BRST Charges: Non-Abeian 1-Form Gauge Theory by R. P. Malik (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-24514.txt.

Introduction

Malik studies BRST and anti-BRST charges in a D-dimensional non-Abelian gauge theory with no matter fields. Applying Noether's theorem alone does not yield charges that are both invariant and nilpotent, due to a nontrivial Curci-Ferrari condition. Partial integration, the Gauss theorem, and the equations of motion are also needed. Malik uses basic canonical commutators to prove the Noether charges are the true generators of the off-shell nilpotent symmetry transformations. The invariance of suitably modified charges is established the same way.

Catalog record

CREATORR. P. Malik
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE93509
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.24514

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Basic Canonical Brackets and Nilpotency Property of Noether (anti-)BRST Charges: Non-Abeian 1-Form Gauge Theory R. P. Malik Abstract Abstract: In the case of a D-dimensional non-Abelian 1-form gauge theory (without any interaction with the matter fields), we show that the application of the Noether theorem does not lead to the derivations of the Becchi-Rouet-Stora-Tyutin (BRST) and anti-BRST charges that obey (i) the (anti-)BRST invariance, and (ii) the nilpotency property (despite the fact that these charges are derived from the infinitesimal, continuous and nilpotent (anti-)BRST symmetry transformations). This happens because of the presence of the non-trivial Curci-Ferrari (CF) condition on our non-Abelian theory (whose limiting case is the Abelian gauge theory where the CF-type restriction is trivial and the corresponding Noether (anti-)BRST charges turn out to be nilpotent as well as (anti-)BRST invariant together ). We exploit the theoretical strength of the basic canonical approach to prove (i) the non-nilpotency of the conserved Noether (anti-)BRST charges, and (ii) the (anti-)BRST invariance of the consistently modified versions of the Noether conserved (anti-)BRST charges. We very briefly comment on the nilpotency property of the consistently modified versions of the conserved (anti-)BRST charges, too. Our present observations are very sacrosanct because they have been proven by (i) using the beauty of the symmetry properties, and (ii) exploiting the theoretical strength of the basic canonical (anti)commutators. PACS numbers: 11.15.-q, 12.20.-m, 03.70.+k Keywords : Noether theorem; continuous (anti-)BRST symmetries; Curci-Ferrari condition; Noether (anti-)BRST charges; nilpotency property; basic canonical (anti)commutators 1 Introduction The principle of local gauge invariance is at the heart of the interacting (non-)Abelian 1-form gauge theories that provide a precise theoretical description * * * One of the cardinal examples for such kinds of gauge theories is the well-known standard model of elementary particle physics where the agreement between theory and experiment, to put mildly, is outlandish in nature. This theory, despite a few shortcomings, provides the corner stone for the unified theoretical description of the electromagnetic, weak and strong interactions of nature. of three (out of the total four) fundamental interactions of nature. One of the mathematically elegant and physically intuitive methods to covariantly quantize such kinds of gauge theories is the Becchi-Rouet-Stora-Tyutin (BRST) formalism [1-4] where the unitarity and quantum gauge (i.e. BRST) invariance are respected together (see, e.g. [5] for more details) at any arbitrary order of perturbative computations for a given physical process (that is allowed by a given interacting gauge theory). The validity of unitarity is primarily ensured by the presence of the (anti-)ghost fields in a BRST-quantized interacting gauge theory [5]. The classical interacting gauge theories always respect the infinitesimal, continuous and local gauge symmetry transformations that are generated by the first-class constraints (in the terminology of Dirac’s prescription for the classification scheme) which exist on these theories. Within the framework of the BRST formalism, the local gauge symmetry transformations are traded with the infinitesimal continuous and nilpotent BRST and anti-BRST symmetry transformations. These nilpotent symmetry transformation operators are required to absolutely anticommute with each-other so that they can maintain their independent identity. The nilpotency and absolute anticommutativiity properties are a couple of sacrosanct requirements of the quantum gauge (i.e. BRST and anti-BRST) symmetry transformation operators. In particular, the requirement of the absolute anticommutativity property of the (anti-)BRST transformation operators distinguishes them from the \mathcal{N}=2 SUSY transformation operators which are also nilpotent of order two. However, these set of (a couple of \mathcal{N}=2 ) SUSY operators do not anticommute with each-other. This specific feature is one of the sacrosanct properties of the \mathcal{N}=2 SUSY transformation operators. The key motivating factors behind our present investigation are as follows. In our recent earlier work [6], we have established that the Noether conserved (anti-)BRST charges are always found to be non-nilpotent if the BRST-quantized theory is endowed with the non-trivial CF-type restrictions(s). Furthermore, these Noether charges are also found to be non-invariant under the (anti-)BRST symmetry transformations. As a consequence, these Noether charges are not physical (in the true sense of the word within the framework of BST formalism). However, these non-nilpotent (anti-)BRST charges are useful in the sense that they are the generators for the infinitesimal, continuous and nilpotent (anti-)BRST symmetry transportations from which they are derived. It is crystal clear that such kinds of non-nilpotent and non-(anti-)BRST-invariant Noether (anti-)BRST charges can not be used in the discussion on the BRST cohomology (see, e.g. [7]). Hence, one has to use the appropriate Euler-Lagrange (EL) equations of motion (EoM) to recast these non-nilpotent charges in the forms that are found to be (anti-)BRST invariant. In our earlier works [8-10], we have been able to establish that the (anti-)BRST versions of the (anti-)BRST charges are useful in the physicality criteria because they lead to the derivation of the conditions on the physical states that are found to be consistent with the Dirac quantization conditions for the gauge theories that are endowed with the first-class constraints in the terminology of Dirac’s prescription for the classification scheme (see, e.g. [11,12]). In other words, we find that the physicality criteria w.r.t. the (anti-)BRST invariant versions of the (anti-)BRST charges lead to the annihilation of the physical states by the operator forms of the first-class constraints (of the original classical gauge theories that are properly BRST-quantized). Against the backdrop of the above paragraph, it is pertinent to point out that, in our earlier work [6], we have exploited the standard relationship between the continuous symmetry transformations and their generators as the Noether conserved charges to prove (i) the non-nilpotency of the Noether conserved (anti-)BRST charges (that are derived using the off-shell nilpotent (anti-)BRST symmetry transformations), and (ii) the (anti-)BRST invariance of the appropriately modified versions of the Noether (anti-)BRST charges where the suitable EL-EoM are used. The latter have been used in our earlier works (see, e.g. [8-10] for details) where we have discussed the physicality criteria w.r.t. them in great detail(s). The central purpose of our present investigation is to exploit the theoretical strengths of the canonical (anti)commutators to prove (i) the non-nilpotency of the Noether (anti-)BRST charges, and (ii) the (anti-)BRST invariance of the consistently modified versions of the Noether (anti-)BRST charges (in the context of the D-dimensional non-Abelian 1-form gauge theory). Our present canonical method of these proofs is superior to the same kinds of proofs discussed in our earlier work [6] where a different method is adopted (for such proofs). The latter method has a questionable issue as far as the nilpotency property is concerned. Such issues are not present in the canonical approach (cf. Sec. 6 for details). The theoretical contents of our present endeavor are organized as follows. In the next section, we briefly recapitulate the bare essentials of the nilpotent (anti-)BRST symmetry transformations and derive the Noether conserved (anti-)BRST charges. The subject matter of our Sec. 3 is related to the canonical method of the proof that Noether (anti-)BRST charges are the generators for the nilpotent (anti-)BRST symmetry transformations. Our Sec. 4 is devoted to the proof that these charges are not nilpotent where we exploit the basic definitions of the canonical (anti)commutators. Sec. 5 of our present endeavor deals with the proof that the consistently modified versions of the Noether conserved (anti-)BRST charges satisfy the property of (anti-)BRST

Read the complete text