Bridging the Dual Nature: How Integrated Explanations Enhance Understanding of Technical Artifacts

Lutz Terfloth, Heike M. Buhl, Vivien Lohmer, Michael Schaffer, Friederike Kern, Carsten Schulte · 2026

Read Bridging the Dual Nature: How Integrated Explanations Enhance Understanding of Technical Artifacts by Lutz Terfloth, Heike M. Buhl, Vivien Lohmer, Michael Schaffer, Friederike Kern, Carsten Schulte (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-24325.txt.

Introduction

Terfloth and co-authors test whether explanations of technical objects should cover both structure and purpose. Dual Nature Theory says understanding needs both the architecture of a thing and its relevance. In an experiment with 104 participants, trained explainers described the board game Quarto! in three ways: structure only, purpose only, or both. The two single-focus styles gave equal understanding. The integrated style raised enabledness, the ability to use the knowledge, over both. Comprehension scores did not differ. The authors link integrated explanation to agency.

Catalog record

CREATORLutz Terfloth, Heike M. Buhl, Vivien Lohmer, Michael Schaffer, Friederike Kern, Carsten Schulte
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE73607
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.24325

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Bridging the Dual Nature: How Integrated Explanations Enhance Understanding of Technical Artifacts Lutz Terfloth, Heike M. Buhl, Vivien Lohmer, Michael Schaffer, Friederike Kern, Carsten Schulte Abstract Purpose: Understanding a technical artifact requires grasping both its internal structure (Architecture) and its purpose and significance (Relevance), as formalized by Dual Nature Theory. This controlled experimental study investigates whether how explainers address these perspectives affects explainees’ understanding. Methods: In a between-subjects experiment, 104 participants received explanations of the board game Quarto! from trained confederates in one of three conditions: Architecture-focused (A), Relevance-focused (R), or Integrated (AR). Understanding was assessed on comprehension (knowing that) and enabledness (knowing how). Results: The A and R conditions produced equivalent understanding despite different explanation content. The AR condition yielded significantly higher enabledness than the focused conditions combined ( F ⁡ ( 1,102 ) = 4.83 \mathrm{F}(1,102)=4.83 , p = .030 p=.030 , η p 2 = .045 \eta^{2}_{p}=.045 ), while no differences emerged for comprehension. Conclusion: Integrating Architecture and Relevance specifically enhances explainees’ ability to apply their understanding in practice, suggesting that fostering agency with technical artifacts requires bridging both perspectives. This has implications for technology education and explainable AI design. keywords dual nature theory, technical artifacts, explanation, understanding, enabledness, co-construction 1 Introduction When we encounter a technical artifact, be it a smartphone, a sorting algorithm, or a recommendation system, really understanding it involves more than knowing what it does. It also requires understanding how it is built and why it was designed the way it was. The Dual Nature Theory formalizes this intuition, positing that technical artifacts possess two essential characteristics: their Architecture (how they are built) and their Relevance (what they are for) ( 15 ; 39 ) . 39 formalize these as distinct but integrated perspectives on the artifact: the perspective on the Architecture encompasses the physical and formal structures (hardware, algorithms, protocols) while Relevance encompasses functions, societal purposes, discourses, and values. This distinction is not merely techno-philosophical, it has concrete consequences for how explanations of technical artifacts are structured and, as this paper argues, for how well those explanations are understood. But how are these two perspectives actually addressed when one person explains a technical artifact to another? Fundamental to this question, research on verbal explanation, particularly in face-to-face instructional dialog, has consistently shown that comprehension is shaped by interactive explanatory processes, as speakers adapt explanations to learners’ knowledge, monitor understanding, and support the construction of coherent mental representations ( 2 ; 7 ; 3 ; 9 ) . In everyday life, when one person explains a technical artifact to another, given that both parties are motivated, a dynamic process of sense-making unfolds. The explainer selects, frames, and sequences information, while the explainee interprets it against their prior knowledge and interests, asks questions, and communicates confusion ( 6 ; 26 ) . Previous work began to characterize this dynamic process empirically by operationalizing the dual nature perspectives as codes for qualitative content coding. A study of board game explanations ( 38 ) indicated that explainers naturally draw on both the Architecture and the Relevance perspective when explaining technical artifacts, with an Architecture-first ordering that converges with findings from program comprehension research ( 24 ) . A second study ( 36 ) further revealed that explainers adapt their explanations to the explainees’ interests in Architecture or Relevance while maintaining a broadly Architecture-dominant structure. Together, these findings paint a picture of explanation as a flexible activity in which the two perspectives are navigated somewhat systematically. Yet an important question has so far remained unanswered: does the particular way in which an explainer addresses the dual nature actually affect how well the explainee understands the artifact? The prior studies observed explanation dynamics as they occurred naturally, but they did not experimentally vary the explanatory approach, making it difficult to draw causal conclusions about explanation effects. The kind and depth of understanding that develops may differ depending on whether explainers emphasize Architecture, foreground Relevance, or explicitly integrate both dimensions. Moreover, the practical stakes of this question are high. If certain patterns of dual nature addressing consistently produce better understanding, such evidence could inform teacher training, curriculum design, and the development of social explainable AI (XAI) systems, where structuring explanations to support not only comprehension but also user agency is an active area of concern ( 20 ; 10 ) . The current study addresses this gap by reversing the observational logic of the previous work. Rather than examining how explainers naturally adapt their explanations, we systematically vary the way they address the dual nature of a technical artifact and examine the causal effect of these variations on understanding outcomes. The study was designed as foundational research: the goal is to test theoretically grounded hypotheses under conditions that minimize confounding variables, using an explanandum accessible enough to recruit a broad participant pool without requiring domain-specific prior knowledge. We separate understanding into two dimensions based on 1 : (1) comprehension (knowing that) and (2) enabledness (knowing how). Only if both dimensions are achieved does a learner not only know what and how an artifact works but can also act with and upon it, a condition 1 associate with agency. We postulate that the deepest forms of understanding—that is, agency—will be achieved through integrated explanations, which explicitly connect Architecture and Relevance of the explanandum, the two sides of its dual nature. Consequently, we anticipate that various explanatory approaches will generate distinct forms of understanding. 2 Related Work 2.1 The Dual Nature of Technical Artifacts When we try to understand a technical artifact, we frequently encounter two distinct but interrelated questions: how does it work and what is it for? The Dual Nature Theory, developed primarily through a research program at Delft University of Technology, formalizes this intuition by positing that technical artifacts possess a dual nature: a physical structure operating according to natural laws and a function rooted in human intentionality ( 15 ) . Crucially, neither aspect alone captures the artifact fully. As 15 puts it, the physical conceptualization may account for how the artifact works in terms of physical processes, but without its function, the object loses its status as a technical artifact. Conversely, purely functional descriptions effectively ”black box” the physical structure ( 15 , p. 56) . A holistic understanding would therefore require engaging with both perspectives and, importantly, with the relationship between them, their integration ( 4 , cf.) . In accordance with 39 , who specifically tailored the dual nature framework to digital artifacts, this paper conceptualizes these two aspects as perspectives on the Architecture (how the artifact is constructed and works) and on the Relevance (what it is intended for, including purposes, values, and societal significance). This terminology deliberately extends narrow notions of function ( 15 , see, e.g.,) . For complex digital artifacts in particular, whose societal impact often extends well beyond their originally intended purposes, a richer notion of Relevance is needed, one that situates artifacts within broader human practices, goals, and values ( 27 ; 39 ) . 2.2 Understanding Technical Artifacts If understanding a technical artifact requires engaging with both its Architecture and its Relevance, a natural follow-up question is: what does such understanding actually look like? Research in computing

Read the complete text