Cordierite-based optical resonators with extremely low thermal expansion Journal: opticajournal Publication type: Research Article

Nico Wagner, 1,2, † {\dagger} Thomas Legero, 3, † {\dagger} ,* and Stefanie Kroker 1,2,3 · 2026

Read Cordierite-based optical resonators with extremely low thermal expansion Journal: opticajournal Publication type: Research Article by Nico Wagner, 1,2, † {\dagger} Thomas Legero, 3, † {\dagger} ,* and Stefanie Kroker 1,2,3 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-24247.txt.

Introduction

Wagner and co-authors study cordierite ceramics for ultra-stable laser resonators outside the lab. Cordierite expands little with heat and is stiff, which suits compact resonators. They revisit the effective expansion of resonators whose spacers and mirrors use different materials. Finite element runs show how mismatch between a cordierite spacer and glass mirrors plays out. Cordierite's steep expansion slope makes it forgiving of mismatch with fused silica mirrors. They also propose designs where mirror bending cancels spacer growth, giving near-zero expansion over wide ranges.

Catalog record

CREATORNico Wagner, 1,2, † {\dagger} Thomas Legero, 3, † {\dagger} ,* and Stefanie Kroker 1,2,3
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42303
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.24247

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Cordierite-based optical resonators with extremely low thermal expansion Journal: opticajournal Publication type: Research Article Nico Wagner, 1,2, † {\dagger} Thomas Legero, 3, † {\dagger} ,* and Stefanie Kroker 1,2,3 Abstract Applications for ultra-stable lasers outside controlled laboratory environments require compact and robust optical resonators with reduced sensitivity to temperature fluctuations. The low thermal expansion coefficient (CTE) and the high stiffness make cordierite-based ceramics, such as NEXCERA ™ , attractive for vibration insensitive room-temperature resonators. We revisit the effective CTE of resonators with spacers and mirrors made of different materials and use finite element simulations to analyze the impact of a CTE mismatch in a cordierite-based resonator with mirrors made of ultra-low expansion (ULE ® ) glass or fused silica (FS). This enabled us to determine the CTE of a cordierite spacer from the measured effective CTE of a resonator. We confirm a six-fold larger CTE slope of cordierite around the zero-crossing temperature than in ULE glass. The steep CTE slope, in combination with the large stiffness, makes cordierite-based resonators far less sensitive to CTE mismatch with FS mirrors, thereby eliminating the need for additional compensation rings. We further consider the so far neglected case, where the CTE of the spacer is larger than that of the mirror, and propose resonator designs in which the thermal length change of the spacer is fully or partially compensated by the deflection of the mirrors. This results in a cordierite-based resonator with ULE mirrors whose effective CTE can be close to zero over a temperature range of several tens of Kelvin. We are extending our concept to resonators based on crystalline materials with high stiffness and low isothermal length change, such as silicon, enabling compact and robust room-temperature resonators for terrestrial and space-born applications. 1 Introduction Fabry-Pérot optical resonators are essential instruments in high-precision measurement science, with applications in optical lattice clocks [ 25 , 27 , 44 , 33 ] , gravitational-wave detection [ 37 , 5 , 3 , 40 , 2 ] , fundamental physics experiments [ 4 , 38 , 11 , 29 , 18 ] and exoplanet detection [ 20 ] . The performance of such systems is limited by the resonators length stability, requiring materials with an extremely low or near-zero coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE). A prominent example is Corning’s ultra-low expansion (ULE ® ) glass, whose CTE has a zero crossing at room temperature. However, ULE exhibits a relatively low Young’s modulus and show large isothermal length drift due to material aging [ 36 , 13 ] . Cordierite-based ceramics, such as NEXCERA ™ by Krosaki Harima Corporation, are considered as a promising alternative [ 6 ] . Its CTE also shows a zero crossing at room temperature and there are hints that its isothermal length drift is smaller than in ULE glass [ 16 ] . The Young’s modulus ( 145\text{\,}\mathrm{GPa} [ 30 ] ) is more than a factor of two larger than ULE glass ( 67.6\text{\,}\mathrm{GPa} [ 9 ] ) which makes the resonator length less susceptible to acceleration, resulting in lower vibration sensitivity. Although the mechanical loss factor of NEXCERA is comparable to that of ULE [ 41 , 42 ] , its higher Young’s modulus leads to reduced Brownian thermal noise. Aside from ultra-stable laboratory systems, there is growing demand for compact optical resonators that can be operated outside of controlled laboratory environments. Applications range from photonic radar systems [ 34 ] and environmental sensing [ 15 ] to mobile atomic clocks [ 7 ] . Recent developments in microcavity technologies further highlight this trend toward miniaturization, enabling resonators with small mode volumes and high finesse for applications in quantum technologies and integrated photonics [ 12 ] . However, the absence of controlled laboratory conditions, in particular lower temperature stability and higher vibration noise, place special demands on the CTE of the resonator and the mechanical properties of its materials. In this article, we show that cordierite, in addition to its excellent mechanical properties, is also an ideal material for such applications in terms of its CTE. The paper is organized as follows. In Sec. 2 we revisit the thermal expansion of optical resonators composed of different materials. This leads us to design strategies for realizing resonators with extremely small effective CTEs. For example, cordierite can be used as a spacer material in order to benefit from higher rigidity, lower isothermal drift and significantly reduced sensitivity to temperature fluctuations. Section 3 revisits the impact of a large CTE mismatch between spacer and mirror material. This is particularly important when using fused silica (FS) mirrors which is a suitable choice due to its low thermal noise at room temperature [ 35 ] . As shown in [ 23 ] , ULE resonators employing FS mirrors suffer from significant mirror deformations, leading to an effective CTE of the resonator that can differ substantially from that of the spacer material. Using finite-element (FEM) simulations, we show that the large slope of cordierites CTE and its high Young’s modulus strongly reduce this effect, eliminating the need for ULE rings. Designing resonators with the lowest possible effective CTE requires a good knowledge of the CTE parameters of the spacer and mirror materials. We have measured the effective CTE of a test resonator consisting of a cordierite spacer and ULE mirrors with known CTE. Based on our analysis and the FEM simulation, we determined the CTE of the cordierite spacer. Our results presented in Sec. 4 confirm that the CTE of cordierite exhibits a steep slope of 8.811(\pm 0.025)\text{\times}{10}^{-9}\text{\,}\text{/}{\mathrm{K}}^{2} at its zero-crossing temperature. In Sec. 5 , we propose a resonator design that combines a cordierite spacer with ULE mirrors, whose effective CTE remains nearly zero over several Kelvin. This concept can be realized with compact cavities in the 1\text{\,}\mathrm{cm} range. We further extend this approach by introducing two additional concepts. One concept considers resonators whose effective CTE is determined solely by the mirror substrates, allowing the spacer to be fabricated from crystalline materials with low length drift and high Young’s modulus. Finally, we discuss a silicon cavity with FS mirrors operated at room temperature that exhibits an effective CTE comparable to that of ULE glass, enabling a thermal-noise-limited frequency stability on the order of 1\text{\times}{10}^{-15} . All designs facilitate compact and transportable systems that combine excellent thermal stability with robust mechanical performance at room temperature. 2 Thermal expansion of optical resonators The theoretical description of thermal expansion in composite materials has been discussed in [ 31 , 43 ] . In this work, we adopt the notation of [ 23 ] , considering a cylindrical resonator of length L with optically contacted mirrors of radius R . When the resonator undergoes a temperature change, the mismatch in the CTEs between the spacer and the mirrors leads to a differential radial expansion between spacer and mirror. This radial expansion, \mathrm{d}R , can be expressed as \mathrm{d}R=(\alpha_{\mathrm{m}}-\alpha_{\mathrm{s}})R\,\mathrm{d}T , where \alpha_{\mathrm{m}} is the CTE of the mirror and \alpha_{\mathrm{s}} is the CTE of the spacer. As the mirrors are rigidly contacted to the spacer, this radial expansion is suppressed and results in a bulging of the mirrors, which leads to an axial displacement, \mathrm{d}A , of the mirror center.

Read the complete text