Consistent Gauge Conditions for Dust-Shell Dynamics in Effective Quantum Gravity
Dongxue Qu, Cong Zhang · 2026
Read Consistent Gauge Conditions for Dust-Shell Dynamics in Effective Quantum Gravity by Dongxue Qu, Cong Zhang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-24168.txt.
Introduction
Qu and Zhang build a systematic way to choose gauges for dust-shell dynamics in effective quantum gravity. Past work on shell-crossing shocks suffered from poor gauge choices. As a first step, they study one thin dust shell on its own. Their method builds consistent gauges for generally covariant effective gravity. In the classical limit, the shell dynamics match the Israel junction conditions, which validates the method. With the quantum parameter on, real corrections appear. Some standard gauges prove incompatible with a shell, they show.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dongxue Qu, Cong Zhang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42162 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.24168
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Consistent Gauge Conditions for Dust-Shell Dynamics in Effective Quantum Gravity Dongxue Qu, Cong Zhang Abstract Previous analyses of shocks generated by shell-crossing singularities are affected by inappropriate gauge choices, and no systematic method is available for selecting a consistent gauge. In this work, we develop such a method for effective quantum gravity coupled to a dust shell. We illustrate it in classical general relativity and verify it numerically, with results in agreement with the Israel junction condition. We also show that gauges such as the Painlevé-Gullstrand and Schwarzschild ones are incompatible with the presence of a dust shell when imposed on the whole spatial slice. This explains the difficulties in previous treatments. The framework developed here provides a basis for studying shell-crossing singularities and shock dynamics in generally covariant effective black-hole models. I Introduction Black holes (BHs), among the most mysterious objects in the universe, have been extensively studied since they were first predicted Wheeler 1968 ; Oppenheimer and Snyder 1939 . The singularities at their centers signal the breakdown of classical general relativity (GR) Penrose 1965 , and motivate the study of quantum-gravity (QG) effects in black-hole physics Modesto 2007 ; Gielen and Menéndez-Pidal 2025 . Loop quantum gravity, one of the most promising approaches to quantum gravity Ashtekar and Lewandowski 2004 ; Rovelli 2004 ; Han et al. 2007 ; Thiemann 2007 , has been extensively applied in this context Modesto 2010 ; Gambini and Pullin 2008 ; Corichi and Singh 2016 ; Ben Achour et al. 2017 ; Ashtekar et al. 2018 ; Zhang et al. 2020 ; Kelly et al. 2020 ; Zhang et al. 2022 ; Husain et al. 2022a ; Alonso-Bardaji et al. 2022a ; Zhang 2021 ; Münch 2021 ; Gambini et al. 2022 ; Husain et al. 2022b ; Alonso-Bardaji et al. 2022b ; Gambini et al. 2023 ; Lewandowski et al. 2023 ; Alonso-Bardaji and Brizuela 2024 ; Giesel et al. 2023a ; Giesel et al. 2023b ; Alonso Bardají 2023 ; Fazzini et al. 2024 ; Zhang et al. 2025a ; Cafaro and Lewandowski 2024 ; Lin and Zhang 2024 ; Cipriani et al. 2024 ; Zhang et al. 2025b ; Lin et al. 2024 ; Yang et al. 2025 ; Fazzini 2025 ; Liu and Qu 2025 ; Fazzini and Mehmood 2025 ; Sahlmann and Zhang 2025 . Following many studies of regular black-hole solutions in vacuum, attention has gradually shifted toward their formation through the gravitational collapse of dust Husain et al. 2022a ; Husain et al. 2022b ; Lewandowski et al. 2023 ; Fazzini et al. 2024 ; Giesel et al. 2023a ; Giesel et al. 2023b ; Cipriani et al. 2024 ; Shi et al. 2024 ; Fazzini 2025 ; Liu and Qu 2025 ; Fazzini and Mehmood 2025 . Recently, attention has turned to the occurrence of shell-crossing singularities and their dynamics. During the collapse of a dust ball with an inhomogeneous density profile, adjacent dust shells may develop different velocities, so that their worldlines intersect, leading to the formation of a shell-crossing singularity Fazzini et al. 2024 ; Cipriani et al. 2024 ; Fazzini 2025 ; Liu and Qu 2025 ; Fazzini and Mehmood 2025 ; Bobula and Fazzini 2026 . Although the existence of shell-crossing singularities is widely accepted, their dynamics remains an open question Fazzini et al. 2024 ; Liu and Qu 2025 ; Sahlmann and Zhang 2025 . In classical GR, issues such as shell-crossing singularities are treated using the Israel junction conditions, which provide a weak formulation of the Einstein equations Israel 1966 . In quantum black-hole models, however, especially those formulated within the Hamiltonian framework, no analogous junction condition is currently available. This is the main obstacle to addressing such problems. In previous works, issues related to shell-crossing singularities have typically been addressed by fixing a gauge, that is, by choosing coordinates such as the Painlevé–Gullstrand (PG) coordinates, and then solving the Hamilton equations using the Rankine–Hugoniot conditions Husain et al. 2022b ; Cipriani et al. 2024 . However, it is often not checked whether the chosen gauge-fixing condition is compatible with the presence of a dust shell-crossing singularity. In the absence of a covariant junction condition analogous to the Israel condition, the shell dynamics must be studied directly from the Hamilton equations together with the Rankine–Hugoniot conditions, which requires a coordinate system that is well defined across the shell. However, it is well known in classical GR that commonly used coordinates, such as the PG and Schwarzschild coordinates, are not continuous at the dust shell Israel 1966 ; Friedman et al. 1997 . This shows that such coordinates are not suitable for analyzing the shell dynamics within the Hamiltonian framework. More generally, coordinate artifacts are a common source of confusion in GR. For example, some discontinuity effects predicted in Husain et al. 2022a were later shown to be purely coordinate artifacts Fazzini et al. 2023 , highlighting the importance of choosing coordinates with care. The main goal of this work is to develop a framework for choosing appropriate coordinates in the presence of a dust shell. Within the Hamiltonian framework, choosing a coordinate system corresponds to specifying the lapse function and shift vector that determine the dynamics. Our goal is to derive equations that constrain their choice. Our analysis shows that imposing gauges such as the PG or Schwarzschild gauges on the entire spatial slice, where the areal radius g_{\theta\theta} is assumed to vary smoothly with the coordinate, is not compatible with the presence of a dust shell, since they lead to ill-defined expressions involving the division by zero. To derive such equations, a natural starting point is to write down the full set of constraints, including both the gravitational and shell contributions, and then analyze these constraints together with the Hamilton equations, as done, for example, in Louko et al. 1998 ; Friedman et al. 1997 . The difficulty is that the shell contribution to the constraints is generally not known. In the case of interest here, namely when a shell-crossing singularity forms during the collapse of an inhomogeneous dust ball, one cannot explicitly write down the shell contribution to the constraints, since the interaction between the dust shell and the collapsing dust ball is not known. This motivates an alternative approach in which the explicit form of the shell contribution is not required. In this work, we follow an idea inspired by classical GR: instead of using the explicit shell contribution to the constraints, we characterize the dust shell through its energy-momentum tensor. This requires identifying the tensor that plays the role of the Einstein tensor in the effective quantum black-hole model within the Hamiltonian framework Del Águila and Morales-Técotl 2025 . We refer to this tensor as the effective Einstein tensor. The full set of equations, including the constraints and Hamilton’s equations, can then be written as a single equation equating the effective Einstein tensor with the energy-momentum tensor of the dust shell. We show that the equations constraining the gauge choice can be derived from this equation. One further point should be emphasized. The above strategy applies only when the theory is covariant, since only then can one define an effective Einstein tensor and