General Intellectual Humility Is Malleable Through AI-Mediated Reflective Dialogue
Mohammad Ratul Mahjabin, Raiyan Abdul Baten · 2026
Read General Intellectual Humility Is Malleable Through AI-Mediated Reflective Dialogue by Mohammad Ratul Mahjabin, Raiyan Abdul Baten (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-23855.txt.
Introduction
Mahjabin and Baten test whether intellectual humility can be raised with AI-guided dialogue. Intellectual humility means seeing that one's beliefs may be wrong and open to change. In a randomized study with 400 people, the dialogue moved from basic concepts to self-relevant scenarios. It used staged scaffolding and Socratic reflection. The group gained humility, and gains held at a two-week follow-up with no clear decay. Effects held across political views and baseline traits, they report.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mohammad Ratul Mahjabin, Raiyan Abdul Baten |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51006 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.23855
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
General Intellectual Humility Is Malleable Through AI-Mediated Reflective Dialogue Mohammad Ratul Mahjabin, Raiyan Abdul Baten Abstract General intellectual humility (GIH)—the recognition that one’s beliefs may be fallible and revisable—is associated with improved reasoning, learning, and social discourse, yet is widely regarded as a stable trait resistant to intervention. We test whether GIH can be elevated through a conversational intervention that combines staged cognitive scaffolding with personalized Socratic reflection. In a randomized controlled experiment ( N = 400 N=400 ), participants engaged in a structured, LLM-mediated dialogue that progressed from conceptual understanding of intellectual humility to applying, analyzing, evaluating, and generating novel, self-relevant scenarios that instantiate it. Relative to a time-matched control, the intervention produced a systematic increase in GIH, reduced rank-order stability, and tripled the rate of reliable individual improvement. Crucially, these effects persisted over a two-week follow-up without detectable decay. The effects generalized across political affiliation and did not depend on baseline personality profile. These findings challenge the prevailing pessimism regarding the malleability of GIH and suggest that scaffolded, Socratic reflection delivered through structured dialogue can produce durable changes in general intellectual humility. keywords General Intellectual Humility | Large Language Models | Behavioral Intervention Introduction General intellectual humility—the recognition that one’s beliefs may be fallible and revisable—has emerged as a promising antidote to a broad range of epistemic and societal challenges 44 ; 45 ; 65 ; 35 . Individuals higher in general intellectual humility (GIH) exhibit more accurate judgment and forecasting, greater openness to learning and discovery, higher-quality interpersonal and political dialogue, and lower susceptibility to polarization, extremism, and conspiracy beliefs 7 ; 41 ; 33 ; 47 ; 37 . These downstream outcomes are often studied separately across domains such as political behavior, scientific reasoning, education, leadership, and interpersonal relationships 54 ; 6 ; 63 ; 23 ; 49 , yet they share a common upstream driver: the willingness to recognize the limits of one’s knowledge and revise beliefs accordingly. If so, cultivating GIH could represent a foundational intervention target capable of simultaneously mitigating multiple epistemic failures 53 . This possibility raises a central question: can GIH itself be elevated , potentially at scale? In principle, there are reasons to believe that it could. GIH ultimately concerns beliefs about the fallibility of one’s own knowledge, and beliefs are known to change through learning, reflection, and experience 36 . Moreover, GIH correlates with broader psychological traits—such as openness to experience, epistemic curiosity, and need for cognitive engagement—that themselves exhibit some malleability over the life course and can respond to environmental and technological interventions 25 ; 58 ; 35 ; 47 ; 51 ; 52 ; 59 ; 17 . Yet substantial evidence points in the opposite direction. Trait measures of GIH exhibit high test–retest reliability 47 ; 34 , and theoretical accounts suggest that it arises from relatively stable cognitive and motivational processes, potentially with evolutionary roots, making it difficult to change 11 ; 35 ; 18 ; 50 ; 46 . Indeed, while many beliefs change, beliefs about the reliability of one’s own beliefs—the metacognitive core of intellectual humility—may be more resistant to revision. As a result, GIH is commonly treated as a durable epistemic disposition rather than a readily malleable psychological construct. This pessimism has shaped the direction of intervention research. If raising GIH is difficult, a more feasible strategy is to target intellectual humility in specific downstream contexts or issues—specific intellectual humility (SIH)—which is more responsive to situational cues 24 ; 64 ; 9 ; 20 ; 48 ; 8 . Correspondingly, much of the experimental literature focuses on momentary or topic-specific manipulations, such as self-distanced reasoning about conflicts 21 ; 31 , writing explanations that reveal gaps in one’s understanding of specific policies 16 ; 26 ; 42 , reading about the benefits of IH 46 , listing one’s “known unknowns” about a question 62 , and undergoing growth-mindset and self-affirmation tasks 47 ; 22 . These approaches can temporarily nudge humility-related responses, but their effects are typically transient, context-dependent, or confined to specific issues rather than the broader disposition 54 ; 24 ; 29 , with some findings showing limited replicability 13 . A few longer-duration interventions report encouraging results—such as self-distanced diary-keeping or guided conversations—but these effects appear contingent on specific situational conditions (e.g., relational affiliation must be established) and sustained, labor-intensive scaffolding 19 ; 60 . Discouragingly, extended educational exposures have shown little to no success in shifting GIH 45 : for instance, a five-week philosophy course introduced students to IH without systematic success in elevating it 39 , and a week-long philosophy summer camp showed no measurable gain in students’ IH 2 . Consequently, the prevailing view is that while state-level, specific intellectual humility can fluctuate momentarily, general intellectual humility remains difficult to alter—let alone at scale. Here, we question this conventional wisdom and ask whether the apparent immutability of GIH reflects the nature of the construct—or the limitations of how it has been targeted. If GIH is sustained by metacognitive processes governing how individuals evaluate knowledge, disagreement, and evidence, then shifting it may require interventions that systematically engage these processes through structured cognitive practice. Two ingredients are particularly relevant. First , a durable change in such metacognitive processes is unlikely to arise from isolated transient cues; rather, it can benefit from scaffolded engagement that progressively deepens how individuals understand and apply GIH in their own reasoning. Bloom’s taxonomy formalizes this progression by organizing learning into stages—from recalling and understanding a concept, to applying and analyzing it in concrete situations, and ultimately evaluating and generating new examples that integrate it into one’s thinking 5 ; 30 ; 3 . This progression may move learners beyond recognizing GIH as an abstract ideal to actively using it to interpret situations, weigh evidence, and guide belief revision across contexts. Second , Socratic questioning provides a mechanism for engaging these metacognitive processes by prompting individuals to examine assumptions, consider alternative viewpoints, and confront the limits of their knowledge 43 ; 61 ; 28 . When paired with later Bloom stages—where individuals analyze or generate scenarios—such questioning naturally personalizes the learning process: participants can draw on their own experiences, beliefs, and mental models to reason about when and how GIH applies. This personalized reflection may support generalization beyond static instruction, encouraging individuals to apply GIH within their own epistemic reasoning. To operationalize these ingredients in a standardized, scalable, and interactive manner, we implemented a scaffolded conversational intervention using a large language model (LLM). LLMs enable adaptive, iterative conversation while preserving consistency across participants 12 ; 4 , allowing us to deliver Bloom-style scaffolding and Socratic probing at scale. In our intervention, participants engage in a structured dialogue that introduces three core facets of intellectual humility—awareness of the limits of one’s knowledge, openness to opposing viewpoints, and willingness to revise beliefs in light of evidence. The conversation progresses through Bloom-inspired stages that first reinforce conceptual understanding of these principles, then apply them to scenarios, and finally prompt participants to evaluate and generate diverse situations in which intellectual humility is beneficial. At each stage, the LLM provides brief guidance and poses targeted Socratic questions that build on the participant’s responses. This structure allows the conversation to remain