Numerical analysis of the thermal relaxation of the dense gas between two parallel plates: the free energy monotonicity for the Enskog equation
Shigeru Takata, Soma Sakata, Aoto Takahashi, Masanari Hattori · 2026
Read Numerical analysis of the thermal relaxation of the dense gas between two parallel plates: the free energy monotonicity for the Enskog equation by Shigeru Takata, Soma Sakata, Aoto Takahashi, Masanari Hattori (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-23839.txt.
Introduction
Takata and co-authors simulate a dense gas relaxing between two plates at the same temperature. They use the Enskog equation to test whether free energy falls steadily over time. They compare the original Enskog factor with a modified factor from recent work. With the modified factor, free energy decreases monotonically in their runs. With the original factor, it does not always do so. The two versions also differ in other quantities, most clearly in the density profile over time.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Shigeru Takata, Soma Sakata, Aoto Takahashi, Masanari Hattori |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34683 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.23839
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Numerical analysis of the thermal relaxation of the dense gas between two parallel plates: the free energy monotonicity for the Enskog equation Shigeru Takata, Soma Sakata, Aoto Takahashi, Masanari Hattori Abstract The thermal relaxation problem between two parallel plates with the same temperature is investigated, aiming to study the behavior of the free energy of the dense gas described by the Enskog equation. Two types of Enskog equation have been used: one is the Enskog equation with the original Enskog factor, while the other is that with a modified Enskog factor proposed recently in Takata & Takahashi, Phys. Rev. E 111 , 065108 (2025). The evaluated free energy is a natural extension of the thermodynamic free energy to the non-equilibrium state. It is observed that this free energy monotonically decreases in time for the modified factor version, while it is not necessarily the case for the original version. Differences are also observed in other quantities in their time evolutions, most typically in the density profile. I Introduction Recent advances in microfabrication technology have led to a growing demand for detailed analyses of gas flows in the micro-, submicro-, and even smaller systems. In such small systems, the mean free path of gas molecules is no longer sufficiently small relative to a system dimension, and the gas is not close to the local equilibrium state implicitly assumed by conventional hydrodynamic descriptions. Under these conditions, it becomes necessary to treat the gas based on microscopic considerations. Kinetic theory provides a reliable and reasonably efficient framework for such treatment, based on the Boltzmann equation and its variants C88 ; S07 . This paper adopts a perspective that addresses the gas behavior in such conditions in terms of the kinetic theory. The Enskog equation E72 ; S16 belongs to the aforementioned framework for a dense gas. It incorporates the effects of differences in the center-of-mass positions of colliding molecules and molecular volume fraction on the intermolecular collision frequency into the Boltzmann equation, thereby providing a kinetic description of systems even when non-ideal gas effects manifest beyond the ideal gas regime. Over the past two to three decades, the Enskog equation has also been applied to the study of gas behavior in even below submicro-scale systems, e.g., F97b ; F99 ; KKW14 ; WLRZ16 ; FGLS18 ; HTT22 , by applying the numerical method originally developed for the Boltzmann equation MS96 ; F97a ; MS97a ; WZR15 . However, for the original Enskog equation (OEE) to which these methods have been applied, the Boltzmann H-theorem, corresponding to the second law of thermodynamics, has not been guaranteed. The H-theorem was shown to hold not for OEE but for the modified (or revised) Enskog equation VE73 ; R78 and its adaptation to bounded domains was also discussed later in MGB18 ; T24 . Nevertheless, the complexity of its mathematical structure hindered the development of numerical methods for this variant. The Boltzmann–Enskog equation, which is another variant, is also known to guarantee the H-theorem. However, it does not account for the exclusion effect on collision frequency. Consequently, its use has been limited primarily to mathematical interest, not to physical applications, see, e.g., BLPT91 ; HN06 . In the meantime, we have recently shown in TT25 that the H-theorem can be guaranteed by slightly modifying a weight factor (the so-called Enskog factor) in the original Enskog equation. This new modification is much simpler than that in VE73 . We call this new variant the Enskog equation with a slight modification (EESM). The EESM can newly provide thermodynamic consistency to the numerical studies based on the Enskog equation. In addition, we have also identified the contribution of the non-ideal gas effect that should be added to the usual Boltzmann H-function in TT25 . This contribution, together with the usual H-function, naturally extends the equilibrium entropy to non-equilibrium systems, and at the equilibrium state reproduces the non-ideal gas effect on the entropy of conventional thermodynamics. In the present paper, we investigate the thermal relaxation problem between isothermal parallel plates based on the Enskog equation, both OEE and EESM. Since the parallel plates serve as a heat bath, the Helmholtz free energy should decrease according to the conventional thermodynamics. We will observe the time evolution of the free energy, which is defined based on the aforementioned extended entropy. For EESM, this extended free energy will be shown to decrease monotonically, both theoretically and numerically. However, for OEE, actual numerical computations indicate that this is not necessarily the case. The paper is organized as follows. After the introduction in Sec. I , the problem and its formulation are presented in Sec. II ; in particular, the statement of the H-theorem for EESM TT25 is briefly summarized in Sec. II.2 . Numerical method, which is a hybrid of the finite-difference method for derivatives and the fast Fourier spectral method for collision integral FMP06 , is described in Sec. III . Numerical results are presented in Sec. IV , and the paper is concluded in Sec. V . II Problem and formulation II.1 Problem Consider a dense gas in the gap between two parallel plates at rest. The plates are located at X_{1}=-L/2 and X_{1}=L/2 , respectively, and are maintained at a common uniform constant temperature T_{0} , see Fig. 1 . Figure 1: Problem setting. Dashed circle indicates a molecule in contact with the plate surface. We will investigate the time evolution of the gas, starting from a resting Maxwellian with a uniform temperature T_{0} and a density profile to be specified later, under the following assumptions. 1. The gas behavior is described by the Enskog equation. 2. The molecules are hard-spheres with a common diameter \sigma and mass m . 3. The gas obeys the Carnahan–Starling equation of state (Carnahan–Starling EoS) CS69 in uniform equilibrium states. 4. The molecules are diffusely reflected S07 on the plates. 5. The gas state does not change in the directions of X_{2} and X_{3} . Let D=\{X_{1}|-(L-\sigma)/2<X_{1}<(L-\sigma)/2\} , where the center of gas molecules can be located. This D is different from D^{\sharp}=\{X_{1}|-L/2<X_{1}<L/2\} , which denotes the spatial domain between the plates. Let t and \bm{\xi} be a time and a molecular velocity, respectively. Then, denoting the one-particle velocity distribution function (VDF) of gas molecules by f(t,X_{1},\bm{\xi} ), the Enskog equation is written as \displaystyle\frac{\partial f}{\partial t}+\xi_{1}\frac{\partial f}{\partial X_{1}}=J(f),\quad\mathrm{for\ }X_{1}\in D, (1a) \displaystyle J(f)\equiv\frac{\sigma^{2}}{m}\int_{\mathbb{S}^{2}\times\mathbb{R}^{3}}[{g(X_{1}^{+},X_{1})f_{*}^{\prime}(X_{1}^{+})f^{\prime}(X_{1})} \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\quad-{g(X_{1}^{-},X_{1})f_{*}(X_{1}^{-})f(X_{1})}] \displaystyle\qquad\qquad\quad\times V_{\alpha}\theta(V_{\alpha})d\Omega(\bm{\alpha})d\bm{\xi}_{*}, (1b) in the present problem, where X_{1}^{\pm}=X_{1}\pm\sigma\alpha_{1} , \bm{\alpha}=(\alpha_{1},\alpha_{2},\alpha_{3}) is a unit vector, d\Omega(\bm{\alpha}) is a solid angle element in the direction of \bm{\alpha} , \theta is the Heaviside function \theta(x)=\begin{cases}1,&x\geq 0\\ 0,&x<0\end{cases}, (2) and the following notation convention has been used: \displaystyle\begin{cases}{f(\cdot)=f(\cdot,\bm{\xi}),\ f^{\prime}(\cdot)=f(\cdot,\bm{\xi}^{\prime})},\\ {f_{*}(\cdot)=f(\cdot,\bm{\xi}_{*}),\ f_{*}^{\prime}(\cdot)=f(\cdot,\bm{\xi}_{*}^{\prime})},\end{cases} (3) \displaystyle\begin{cases}{\bm{\xi}^{\prime}=\bm{\xi}+V_{\alpha}\bm{\alpha},\quad\bm{\xi}_{*}^{\prime}=\bm{\xi}_{*}-V_{\alpha}\bm{\alpha},}\\ {V_{\alpha}=\bm{V}\cdot\bm{\alpha},\quad\bm{V}=\bm{\xi_{*}}-\bm{\xi}.}\end{cases} (4) Here and in what follows, the argument t is often suppressed, unless confusion is anticipated. The convention ( 3 ) will be applied only to the quantities that depend on molecular velocity. The factor g requires detailed explanation, which will be provided later in this subsection. The diffuse reflection boundary condition is written as \displaystyle f(\pm\frac{L-\sigma}{2})=\frac{\sigma_{w}^{\pm}}{(2\pi RT_{0})^{3/2}}\exp(-\frac{{\bm{\xi}}^{2}}{2RT_{0}}),\quad\xi_{1}\lessgtr 0, (5a) \displaystyle\sigma_{w}^{\pm}=\sqrt{\frac{2\pi}{RT_{0}}}\int_{\xi_{1}\gtrless 0}|\xi_{1}|f(\pm\frac{L-\sigma}{2})d{\bm{\xi}}, (5b) while the aforementioned initial condition is f=\frac{\rho_{\mathrm{ini}}(X_{1})}{(2\pi RT_{0})^{3/2}}\exp(-\frac{{\bm{\xi}}^{2}}{2RT_{0}}),\quad t=0, (6a) where R is the specific gas constant. In the numerical analysis, only the following form of \rho_{\mathrm{ini}} will