Observer-Dependent Entropy and Diagonal Rényi Invariants in Quantum Reference Frames

Anne-Catherine de la Hamette · 2026

Read Observer-Dependent Entropy and Diagonal Rényi Invariants in Quantum Reference Frames by Anne-Catherine de la Hamette (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-23598.txt.

Introduction

de la Hamette asks how far quantum observers can disagree about a system's entropy. Quantum reference frames describe systems only relative to an observer. She finds a family of diagonal Rényi entropies that no frame choice can change. Those invariants yield a trade-off between coherence and entanglement across parts. For ideal frames, entropy gaps split exactly into frame coherences plus cross-frame links. For rougher frames, a bound from the shared space's size takes over. The limits may matter where gravity meets observer-based entropy.

Catalog record

CREATORAnne-Catherine de la Hamette
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE37828
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.23598

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Observer-Dependent Entropy and Diagonal Rényi Invariants in Quantum Reference Frames Anne-Catherine de la Hamette Abstract Quantum reference frames provide a relational description of multipartite quantum systems in which physical states and observables are defined relative to quantum observers. Yet different observers can assign different entropies to the same system, raising the question of how such observer-dependence is constrained. We identify a family of frame-independent diagonal Rényi entropies for arbitrary subsystems, yielding a generalized multipartite coherence–entanglement tradeoff. For ideal frames, the observer-dependence of subsystem entropy admits an exact decomposition into a sum of single-frame coherences and inter-frame correlations; for non-ideal frames, it is instead bounded by the dimension of an effective relational Hilbert space determined by the representation structure of the frames. Our results place quantitative limits on how much quantum observers can disagree about subsystem entropy, with potential implications for observer-dependent entropy assignments in gravitational settings. I Introduction In physics, properties assigned to physical systems generally depend on the reference frame used to describe them. In quantum theory, this feature becomes particularly subtle, especially when reference frames themselves are treated as quantum systems. Recent developments in quantum reference frames (QRFs) have shown that coherence, entanglement, and even subsystem structure are in general frame-dependent 16 ; 28 ; 11 ; 26 ; 2 ; 10 ; 19 ; 21 ; 7 . At the interface of quantum information and gravity, such perspective dependence has been suggested to play a role in understanding observer-dependent entropy assignments 14 ; 13 , for instance in the description of quantum fields and black hole radiation by different observers. For ideal QRFs – frames carrying the regular representation of a symmetry group G – changes of perspective act as permutations in the natural group-label basis. One consequence of this permutation structure is a coherence–entanglement tradeoff between two observers describing the same physical situation 7 . It is known that this tradeoff fails for non-ideal frames, but the breakdown has not yet been quantitatively characterized. In this work, we considerably extend the previously identified coherence–entanglement tradeoff for ideal QRFs. First, we derive a family of diagonal Rényi invariants for subsystems containing a reference frame, yielding a generalized multipartite coherence–entanglement tradeoff. Second, for ideal frames, we show that the observer-dependence of the entropy assigned to a system of interest admits an exact decomposition into contributions from single-frame coherences and multipartite correlations between frames. Third, building on the representation-theoretic analysis of non-ideal frames in the perspective-neutral framework 10 ; 12 , we derive a state-independent bound on the observer-dependent entropy difference in terms of effective relational Hilbert space dimensions determined by the representation multiplicities of the frames. Together, these results place structural limits on observer-dependent entropy assignments and clarify how frame non-ideality constrains the redistribution of information between observers. II Permutation structure and invariants for ideal frames We consider a collection of N quantum reference frames R_{1},\dots,R_{N} and an additional system S . All systems carry unitary representations of a compact group G equipped with normalized Haar measure dg . In this section we restrict to ideal frames , meaning that each frame R_{i} carries the left-regular representation of G on \mathcal{H}_{R_{i}}=L^{2}(G) , with group-label basis \{{|g\rangle}\}_{g\in G} satisfying \langle g|g^{\prime}\rangle=\delta(g,g^{\prime}) , while the system S carries an arbitrary unitary representation of G . The kinematical Hilbert space is \mathcal{H}_{\rm kin}=\mathcal{H}_{R_{1}}\otimes\cdots\otimes\mathcal{H}_{R_{N}}\otimes\mathcal{H}_{S} , equipped with the diagonal action U(g):=U_{R_{1}}(g)\otimes\cdots\otimes U_{R_{N}}(g)\otimes U_{S}(g) . The physical Hilbert space is defined as the invariant subspace \mathcal{H}_{\rm phys}=\{{|\psi\rangle}\in\mathcal{H}_{\rm kin}\;|\;U(g){|\psi\rangle}={|\psi\rangle}\ \forall g\in G\}, (1) equivalently obtained via coherent group averaging, with projector \Pi_{\rm phys}=\int_{G}dg\,U(g) . Throughout, we restrict to pure physical states \rho_{\rm phys}={|\psi\rangle}\!{\langle\psi|} with {|\psi\rangle}\in\mathcal{H}_{\rm phys} as naturally obtained in the perspective-neutral framework by coherent group averaging of pure kinematical states. For each frame R_{i} , the (pure) relational state in the perspective of R_{i} is obtained via the reduction map \mathcal{R}_{i}:\mathcal{H}_{\rm phys}\to\mathcal{H}_{SR_{\bar{i}}|R_{i}} , defined by conditioning on the identity element e\in G 10 , \rho^{(R_{i})}_{SR_{\bar{i}}}:=\mathcal{R}_{i}(\rho_{\rm phys})=N_{i}\,{}_{R_{i}}\langle e|\rho_{\rm phys}|e\rangle_{R_{i}}, (2) where SR_{\bar{i}} denotes the complement of R_{i} , and N_{i} a normalization constant with N_{i}=d_{R_{i}} when d_{R_{i}}=\dim\mathcal{H}_{R_{i}}<\infty . For any g\in G , conditioning on {|g\rangle}_{R_{i}} instead yields U_{SR_{\bar{i}}}(g)\,\rho^{(R_{i})}_{SR_{\bar{i}}}\,U_{SR_{\bar{i}}}(g)^{\dagger} , so different choices of g are related by the induced group action on SR_{\bar{i}} . We next recall the change of perspective between two ideal frames. The QRF transformation from R_{i} to R_{j} can be written explicitly in the group-label basis as 1 1 1 While we formulate the results for compact groups in general, in the special case of finite groups Haar integrals reduce to \frac{1}{|G|}\sum_{g\in G} and probability densities become finite probability vectors on G . U_{i\to j}=\int_{G}dg\;{}_{R_{i}}{|g^{-1}\rangle}\!{\langle g|}_{R_{j}}\;\otimes\;U_{SR_{\overline{ij}}}(g^{-1}), (3) where U_{SR_{\overline{ij}}}(g) denotes the action of G on all systems excluding frames R_{i} and R_{j} 11 . The relational states are related by \rho^{(R_{j})}_{SR_{\bar{j}}}=U_{i\to j}\rho^{(R_{i})}_{SR_{\bar{i}}}U_{i\to j}^{\dagger}. (4) One can equally obtain this frame change by composing the reduction maps: \rho^{(R_{j})}=\mathcal{R}_{j}\mathcal{R}_{i}^{\dagger}\rho^{(R_{i})}\mathcal{R}_{i}\mathcal{R}_{j}^{\dagger} . Before stating the first lemma, let us fix some notation that will be used throughout the paper. Let \Delta denote the full dephasing map in the group-label basis on any subsystem of frames and/or the system S . Diagonal states in this basis correspond to classical probability distributions over the basis labels. Fix a perspective R_{i} , and choose any subsystem X\subseteq SR_{\bar{i}} that contains at least one other frame R_{j} . The reduced relational state of X relative to R_{i} is \rho^{(R_{i})}_{X}:=\operatorname{Tr}_{\overline{X}}[\rho^{(R_{i})}] with \overline{X}:=SR_{\bar{i}}\setminus X the complement of X . After changing perspective to R_{j} , the subsystem that is described relationally is Y:=(X\cup\{R_{i}\})\setminus\{R_{j}\}\subseteq SR_{\bar{j}} , obtained from X by exchanging R_{j} for R_{i} . Its complement is \overline{Y}:=SR_{\bar{j}}\setminus Y and the corresponding reduced relational state of Y relative to R_{j} is \rho^{(R_{j})}_{Y}:=\operatorname{Tr}_{\overline{Y}}[\rho^{(R_{j})}]=\operatorname{Tr}_{\overline{Y}}[U_{i\to j}\rho^{(R_{i})}U_{i\to j}^{\dagger}] . It was shown in 7 that the full frame change between two ideal frames acts as a permutation in the group-label basis. Let us now state the following for the case of arbitrarily many frames on reduced subsystems. Lemma 1 . There exists a unitary P_{X\to Y}:\mathcal{H}_{X}\to\mathcal{H}_{Y} that acts as a permutation in the group-label basis such that \Delta\rho^{(R_{j})}_{Y}=P_{X\to Y}\,\Delta\rho^{(R_{i})}_{X}\,P_{X\to Y}^{\dagger}. (5) The detailed proof is given in Supplemental Material A . In the group-label basis, the change of frame from R_{i} to R_{j} acts by relabeling basis vectors. Although this does not, in general, imply that the reduced states \rho_{X}^{(R_{i})} and \rho_{Y}^{(R_{j})} are related by a permutation, it does so after full dephasing in the group-label basis. After dephasing, the reduced states are diagonal, and the frame change simply permutes the retained labels. Hence the dephased reduced states are related by the permutation P_{X\to Y} . Lemma 1 motivates considering quantities that depend only on the diagonal entries of reduced states in the group-label basis. Applying full dephasing and evaluating the Rényi- \alpha entropy S_{\alpha}(\rho):=\frac{1}{1-\alpha}\log\operatorname{Tr}(\rho^{\alpha}),\quad\alpha>0,\ \alpha\neq 1, (6) with the von Neumann entropy recovered in the limit \alpha\to 1 , yields a family of invariants. Take the subsystems X and Y as defined above. Theorem 1 . For any \alpha>0 for which the entropies are finite, S_{\alpha}\!\Big(\Delta\rho^{(R_{i})}_{X}\Big)=S_{\alpha}\!\Big(\Delta\rho^{(R_{j})}_{Y}\Big). (7) Proof. By Lemma 1 , the dephased reduced states \Delta\rho^{(R_{i})}_{X} and \Delta\rho^{(R_{j})}_{Y} are related by a permutation P_{X\to Y} . Since S_{\alpha} is invariant under unitary conjugation, the diagonal Rényi entropies coincide. ∎ The diagonal

Read the complete text