A Physical Classification of Exoplanet Thermal Environments: Stellar Irradiation versus Tidal Heating

Daniel Fadrique Barbero · 2026

Read A Physical Classification of Exoplanet Thermal Environments: Stellar Irradiation versus Tidal Heating by Daniel Fadrique Barbero (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-23557.txt.

Introduction

Barbero builds a physical scheme for sorting exoplanets by what heats them. Starlight bathes every planet, yet tides can outshine it as a heat source. His frame centers on a ratio of absorbed star flux to tidal flux. A value near one marks the border where both matter equally. Applied to about 2,000 exoplanets, most worlds prove star-driven. A real share, though, runs on tides. Orbit size and eccentricity sway the tidal flux most. The scheme gives a clear lens on planet heat regimes.

Catalog record

CREATORDaniel Fadrique Barbero
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35933
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.23557

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Physical Classification of Exoplanet Thermal Environments: Stellar Irradiation versus Tidal Heating Daniel Fadrique Barbero Abstract In this study, we introduce a physical framework to analyse and classify the thermal regimes governed by tidal heating and stellar irradiation. Although all planetary systems are exposed to stellar radiation, this source is not always the dominant energy mechanism. This study is motivated by the lack of a physical framework that examines tidal heating in cases where this phenomenon dominates over stellar irradiation. We develop a reproducible physical approach that allows us to classify the relative contribution of both fluxes in a population of exoplanets, identifying the most relevant physical mechanisms that determine the thermal regime. We apply this method to a population of approximately 2000 exoplanets. This framework is centred on the dimensionless parameter Λ = F abs / F tide \Lambda=F_{\mathrm{abs}}/F_{\mathrm{tide}} , which quantifies the relative contribution of each flux. Our results show that most planetary thermal environments are dominated by F abs F_{\mathrm{abs}} , although there is a significant fraction of systems in which the tidal flux dominates. We identify a physical boundary at Λ = 1 \Lambda=1 that defines a regime in which both fluxes are comparable. We identify the semi-major axis a a and the eccentricity e e are the parameters that most influence the tidal flux. This framework provides a transparent and physically motivated tool for characterising planetary thermal environments and exploring the physical trends governing exoplanet populations. 1 Introduction One of the key factors for potential habitability is the thermal environment of exoplanets ( 17 ; 15 ; 10 ) which is characterised by how they receive energy and how they process it ( 3 ) . In most observed planetary systems, stellar radiation is the primary source of energy; however, when certain conditions are met, tidal heating arises ( 13 ) , which may be secondary, comparable or dominant ( 9 ; 2 ; 7 ) to the incident stellar flux depending on the system’s stellar, planetary and orbital parameters ( 16 ; 11 ) . Both heat fluxes can coexist within the same thermal regime, competing to dominate it. In this context, a fundamental question arises: in systems experiencing both energy sources, which of them dominates the thermal environment and how can the two phenomena be compared? In the current literature, there are many articles studying stellar irradiation or tidal heating ( 17 ; 9 ; 7 ; 2 ) . However, there is no simple, reproducible and clear physical framework that directly compares them by classifying in which cases each flux dominates. In this article, we propose a framework based on the dimensionless parameter \Lambda , which allows us to quantify and classify the thermal regimes dominated by each energy source in a given thermal environment. In our analysis, we use a sample of approximately 2000 exoplanets, which we organise within a simple and reproducible physical framework. This allows us to classify them according to \Lambda and to study the orders of magnitude of the stellar, planetary and orbital parameters of each planetary system. This approach highlights a fundamental hierarchy and provides a physically interpretable classification of the physical mechanisms governing tidal heating and, consequently, the classification of planetary thermal environments. 2 Theoretical Framework This article analyses the main heat fluxes that determine the thermal regime of an exoplanet. Stellar irradiation, which is always present, coexists with tidal dissipation in planetary systems where e>0 . The main thermal source for exoplanets is the incident stellar flux ( 5 ) , although under certain conditions it competes with the tidal flux to dominate the planetary thermal environment, revealing a physical boundary where one flux dominates the other or both are comparable. This highlights the need for a physical parameter for systematic classification. 2.1 The Thermal Environment of Exoplanets The thermal environment of an exoplanet is characterised by the balance between the energy it receives and the energy it emits: F_{\mathrm{in}}=F_{\mathrm{out}} (1) We assume radiative equilibrium as a first stationary approximation. To determine the radiative equilibrium of a planetary system, we analyse its main thermal source, the incident stellar flux F_{\mathrm{abs}} . Although this flux is dominant in many of the observed regimes, the thermal phenomenon produced by tides, F_{\mathrm{tide}} , is relevant for characterising the thermal environment of an exoplanet. 2.2 The Incident Stellar Flux Stellar radiation, or incident stellar flux, is the dominant factor for most observed exoplanets. For systems with circular orbits where e=0 , we can attribute radiative equilibrium exclusively to the flux F_{\mathrm{abs}} ( 17 ) . F_{\mathrm{abs}}=\frac{L_{\star}}{4\pi a^{2}}(1-A) (2) Where A is the Bond Albedo, a dimensionless parameter that quantifies the fraction of incident energy reflected back into space. 2.3 The Tidal Heating Flux Planetary systems that satisfy the condition e>0 and have orbits with a small semi-major axis a will experience tidal forces F_{\mathrm{tide}} alongside stellar radiation. The tidal dissipation power in W is calculated using the formula ( 14 ; 8 ; 9 ) : \dot{E}_{\mathrm{tide}}=\frac{21}{2}\frac{k_{2}}{Q}\frac{GM_{\star}^{2}R_{p}^{5}}{a^{6}}ne^{2} (3) Where the fraction \frac{21}{2} represents the numerical factor of the tidal model, k_{2} is an internal parameter of the planet that quantifies the planet’s deformation in response to the gravitational potential, Q is the tidal quality factor ( 4 ; 12 ) that quantifies the efficiency of energy dissipation per cycle, the smaller Q is, the greater the dissipation the planet will experience, G is the gravitational constant and n , which establishes the timescale of the tidal forces, is calculated as n=\sqrt{\frac{GM_{\star}}{a^{3}}} , indicating the rate at which the tidal forces act. To compare tidal heating with the flux F_{\mathrm{abs}} or to characterise the magnitude of tidal heating exhibited by a planet, we calculate the tidal flux from the tidal dissipation power \dot{E}_{\mathrm{tide}} using: {F}_{\mathrm{tide}}=\frac{\dot{E}_{\mathrm{tide}}}{4\pi R_{p}^{2}} (4) Which represents the average energy flux produced by tides at the planet’s surface, expressed in \text{W m}^{-2} , just like F_{\mathrm{abs}} . 2.4 The Coexistence of Both Flows on the Same Exoplanet Stellar radiation is a heat source present in all planetary systems. However, for a planet to experience tidal heating, the condition e>0 must be satisfied, with eccentricity being a necessary condition; although, once this property is satisfied, it acts primarily as a modulator of the flux F_{\mathrm{tide}} given its dependence F_{\mathrm{tide}}\propto e^{2} . Whereas the semi-major axis a exhibits a stronger dependence, F_{\mathrm{tide}}\propto a^{-6} , with a being dominant in the hierarchy based exclusively on the formula for \dot{E}_{\mathrm{tide}} . Having explained both flows and mentioned the possible coexistence of these two within the same thermal environment, naturally, a comprehensive classification requires the formulation of a parameter that allows us to classify thermal regimes depending on the dominance exhibited by each exoplanet, as well as to compare physical mechanisms. 2.5 \Lambda : Physical Parameter for the Classification of Thermal Regimes In this analysis, we use \Lambda as a dimensionless parameter that allows us to easily distinguish whether the thermal regime of an exoplanet is dominated by F_{\mathrm{abs}} , F_{\mathrm{tide}} , or whether both are comparable. We calculate the value of \Lambda using: \Lambda=\frac{F_{\mathrm{abs}}}{F_{\mathrm{tide}}} (5) And we organise the classification as follows: \Lambda>1\to F_{\mathrm{abs}}\text{ dominance} (6) \Lambda<1\to F_{\mathrm{tide}}\text{ dominance} (7) \Lambda=1\to F_{\mathrm{tide}}\sim F_{\mathrm{abs}} (8) This allows us to reveal a fundamental

Read the complete text