A unified variational framework for the inverse Kohn–Sham problem Preprint: AIP/123-QED
Nan Sheng · 2026
Read A unified variational framework for the inverse Kohn–Sham problem Preprint: AIP/123-QED by Nan Sheng (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-23452.txt.
Introduction
Sheng unifies the ways of solving the inverse Kohn-Sham problem. The problem asks for a local potential whose ground state gives a target density. Past schemes speak in split tongues: penalties, iterations, PDE constraints, and more. Sheng anchors them in a fixed-density constrained search with density-potential duality. In that frame, the potential acts as a dual object tied to matching the density. He sorts methods by how they treat the state equations. The map shows where ambiguity and weak-gap trouble enter each design.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nan Sheng |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 68451 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.23452
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A unified variational framework for the inverse Kohn–Sham problem Preprint: AIP/123-QED Nan Sheng Abstract The inverse Kohn–Sham (KS) problem seeks a local effective potential whose noninteracting ground state reproduces a prescribed electron density. Existing inversion formulations are often expressed in disparate languages, including reduced variational optimization, penalty regularization, response-based iteration, and PDE-constrained optimization. In this work, we develop a unified variational framework for inverse KS theory in two steps. First, we identify the fixed-density noninteracting constrained search embedded in exact density functional theory as the natural variational anchor of inverse KS inversion. In this setting, the KS potential appears as the variational dual object associated with density reproduction. Second, we show how the principal inversion formulations may be understood as realizations of the same inverse-KS structure and how they fit into a broader optimization-theoretic classification according to whether the KS state equations and density-reproduction condition are treated as objectives, constraints, penalties, or feasibility relations. Within this framework, Wu–Yang appears as a reduced exact-multiplier formulation, Zhao–Morrison–Parr as a quadratic-penalty relaxation, and PDE-constrained approaches as explicit state-constraint formulations. The same viewpoint also accommodates augmented-Lagrangian and all-at-once residual formulations, and clarifies the roles of additive-constant ambiguity, asymptotic normalization, nonsmooth variational structure, and weak-gap instability across inversion methods. I Introduction Density functional theory (DFT) is one of the central frameworks for the electronic structure of interacting many-body systems in chemistry and condensed-matter physics. Its formal basis is provided by the Hohenberg–Kohn theorems Hohenberg and Kohn 1964 , which establish, under appropriate assumptions, a one-to-one correspondence between the ground-state density and the external scalar potential, up to an additive constant. Within the Kohn–Sham (KS) construction Kohn and Sham 1965 , this correspondence motivates the introduction of an auxiliary noninteracting system whose ground-state density matches that of the interacting problem, while exchange and correlation are absorbed into an effective one-body potential. A persistent question in exact and practical DFT is the inverse Kohn–Sham problem : given a prescribed target density \rho_{\mathrm{tar}}(\mathbf{r}) , determine an effective local potential v_{\mathrm{s}}(\mathbf{r}) whose noninteracting ground state reproduces that density Shi and Wasserman 2021 ; Jensen and Wasserman 2018 . In practice, target densities may be obtained from highly accurate electronic-structure calculations, and inversion then serves both as a conceptual probe of the density–potential correspondence and as a practical route to reference effective and exchange-correlation potentials Shi and Wasserman 2021 ; Kanungo, Zimmerman, and Gavini 2019 . It also provides a useful setting for diagnosing the limitations of approximate functionals and for generating benchmark data for data-driven electronic-structure modeling Kanungo, Zimmerman, and Gavini 2019 ; Shi, Chávez, and Wasserman 2022 ; Kanungo et al. 2023 . Over the past three decades, several influential inversion procedures have been developed, including the Zhao–Morrison–Parr (ZMP) method Zhao, Morrison, and Parr 1994 and the Wu–Yang variational formulation Wu and Yang 2003 . A broader class of inversion and stabilization strategies has since been developed, including variational reconstructions, basis-set-stabilized formulations, and response-based schemes Kadantsev and Stott 2004 ; Gaiduk, Ryabinkin, and Staroverov 2013 ; Zhang and Carter 2018 ; Erhard, Trushin, and Görling 2022 ; Gould 2023 . Closely related wavefunction- and reduced-density-matrix-based reconstructions of KS potentials have also been introduced Ryabinkin and Staroverov 2012 ; Ryabinkin, Kohut, and Staroverov 2015 ; Cuevas-Saavedra, Ayers, and Staroverov 2015 . These methods are often introduced in rather different mathematical languages, including reduced optimization over potentials, quadratic-penalty formulations, response-based iteration, orbital-level reconstruction, and explicit state-equation approaches Shi and Wasserman 2021 ; Jensen and Wasserman 2018 . A main goal of the present work is to place these formulations within a unified variational framework. In this sense, the aim is not primarily an algorithmic comparison, but a structural reorganization in which variational and convex-analytic ideas serve as the main language for relating the principal inversion formulations. The perspective adopted here has two connected levels. At the first level, we argue that the inverse KS problem should be understood not merely as the inversion of a nonlinear density-to-potential map, but as the fixed-density noninteracting constrained-search problem already embedded in exact DFT. More precisely, inverse KS theory is anchored here in the density-constrained inner noninteracting variational problem that appears within the Levy–Lieb and Lieb formulations of exact DFT Levy 1979 ; Lieb 1983 . In this setting, the KS potential appears naturally as the multiplier associated with density reproduction, so that inverse KS theory is placed directly within the variational architecture of exact DFT rather than outside it. At the second level, building on this variational anchor, we develop a broader structural classification of inverse KS formulations. The key observation is that inverse KS inversion is governed by two defining relations: the KS state equations and the density-reproduction condition. Major inversion formulations may then be classified according to how these two relations are assigned the roles of objective, constraint, penalty, or feasibility relation within the optimization architecture. In this sense, Wu–Yang appears as a reduced exact-multiplier formulation Wu and Yang 2003 , ZMP as a quadratic-penalty relaxation Zhao, Morrison, and Parr 1994 ; Penz, Csirik, and Laestadius 2023 , and PDE-constrained approaches as explicit state-constraint formulations at the orbital level Jensen and Wasserman 2018 ; Hinze et al. 2009 ; Tröltzsch 2010 . The same structural perspective also naturally suggests augmented-Lagrangian enrichments, which interpolate between exact multiplier enforcement and pure penalty regularization, as well as enlarged all-at-once formulations in which state consistency and density reproduction are treated within a broader coupled optimization architecture. It also accommodates limiting feasibility-type formulations in which both defining relations are treated primarily as constraints. This viewpoint does not remove the familiar analytical difficulties of inversion. Issues including noninteracting v -representability, nonuniqueness up to constants, nonsmooth variational structure, weak-gap instability, and discretization-induced ill-conditioning remain central in the inversion literature Capelle 2006 ; Lammert 2007 ; Shi and Wasserman 2021 ; Penz et al. 2023 ; Herbst, Bakkestuen, and Laestadius 2025 . The point of the present framework is instead to place these phenomena in a common mathematical setting and to identify how they enter different inversion formulations. The aim is not a complete theorem-driven treatment of inverse KS representability in full generality. Rather, we seek to provide a unified mathematical framework within which the major inversion formulations, their regularity assumptions, and their characteristic numerical failure modes may be understood in common terms. The paper is organized around two connected contributions. Section II develops the variational foundation of the inverse KS problem by identifying fixed-density noninteracting constrained search as its natural anchor within exact DFT and by clarifying the associated roles of multipliers, subdifferentials, gauge structure, and noninteracting representability. Section III then shows how the principal inversion formulations may be understood as distinct realizations of this common variational structure and how they fit into a broader optimization-theoretic architecture, including exact-multiplier, penalty, explicit state-constraint, augmented-Lagrangian, all-at-once, and feasibility-type viewpoints. II Variational Foundation of the Inverse Kohn–Sham Problem A common heuristic description of inverse Kohn–Sham theory treats the problem as the inversion of a nonlinear forward map \mathcal{M}:v\mapsto\rho[v]. This notation is useful at an intuitive level, but it should be understood only schematically, in a regular regime where the ground-state density associated with v is well defined. Its domain and range are not meant to coincide with the full ambient potential