Beyond Preset Identities: How Agents Form Stances and Boundaries in Generative Societies

Hanzhong Zhang, Siyang Song, Jindong Wang · 2026

Read Beyond Preset Identities: How Agents Form Stances and Boundaries in Generative Societies by Hanzhong Zhang, Siyang Song, Jindong Wang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-23406.txt.

Introduction

Zhang and three co-authors look inside simulated societies of generative agents. Agents hold assigned roles and tastes, swap arguments, and pick partners. Raw stance-shift scores hide whether a shift kept or flipped an assigned taste. The team pairs those scores with message content and time-based networks. Across CMASE runs, rational persuasion moved stances most, near 1.30 on a 7-point scale. Emotional persuasion under low trust shifted stances at a 17.3% rate. Interviews show partial acceptance can preserve an assigned stance. Café chats show tight partners can still disagree.

Catalog record

CREATORHanzhong Zhang, Siyang Song, Jindong Wang
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE64866
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.23406

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Beyond Preset Identities: How Agents Form Stances and Boundaries in Generative Societies Hanzhong Zhang, Siyang Song, Jindong Wang Abstract While large language models simulate social behaviors, their capacity for stable stance formation and identity negotiation during complex interventions remains unclear. To overcome the limitations of static evaluations, this paper proposes a novel mixed-methods framework combining computational virtual ethnography with quantitative socio-cognitive profiling. By embedding human researchers into generative multiagent communities, controlled discursive interventions are conducted to trace the evolution of collective cognition. To rigorously measure how agents internalize and react to these specific interventions, this paper formalizes three new metrics: Innate Value Bias (IVB), Persuasion Sensitivity, and Trust-Action Decoupling (TAD). Across multiple representative models, agents exhibit endogenous stances that override preset identities, consistently demonstrating an innate progressive bias ( IVB > 0 \text{IVB}>0 ). When aligned with these stances, rational persuasion successfully shifts 90% of neutral agents while maintaining high trust. In contrast, conflicting emotional provocations induce a paradoxical 40.0% TAD rate in advanced models, which hypocritically alter stances despite reporting low trust. Smaller models contrastingly maintain a 0% TAD rate, strictly requiring trust for behavioral shifts. Furthermore, guided by shared stances, agents use language interactions to actively dismantle assigned power hierarchies and reconstruct self organized community boundaries. These findings expose the fragility of static prompt engineering, providing a methodological and quantitative foundation for dynamic alignment in human-agent hybrid societies. The official code is available at: https://github.com/armihia/CMASE-Endogenous-Stances . 1 Introduction In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have made continuous advances in generating, understanding, and responding to natural language under different scenarios, fostering the emergence of a new kind of human–machine sociology. In this emerging context, humans are no longer merely operators of models but co-inhabitants of interactive systems alongside agents capable of social perception and expression ( 47 ; 43 ; 16 ) . LLM agents are increasingly exhibiting the characteristics of ‘actors’, defined as autonomous entities capable of perception, reasoning, and action ( 15 ; 7 ) .Empowered by these autonomous actors, the simulation of social behavior has also undergone a fundamental shift. Rather than relying on encoded static rules and predefined actions, researchers can now conduct generative explorations of emergent social behaviors ( 10 ) . This transformation gives rise to human–agent Hybrid Societies. Within these hybrid societies, the ”mind” of an actor is not statically pre-programmed. Drawing parallels to human cognitive development ( 23 ) , individual cognition within agent collectives is dynamically shaped through mechanisms such as continuous social interaction, imitation, response, and revision ( 54 ) . These processes unfold in ongoing language exchanges and social engagement, shaped both by the values of human participants and by the propagation of language among agents ( 47 ) . This phenomenon corresponds to what is called group cognition: a dynamic system in which cognition is embedded within community relations, arising through discursive exchanges among group members and irreducible to preset stances held by individuals ( 38 ) . Viewed through the lens of group cognition, LLM agents transcend their traditional roles as isolated tools for task execution to become active discursive participants in a shared communicative space ( 31 ) , which empowers them to form attitudes, negotiate boundaries, and engage with institutional structures through interactions with humans and peer agents. While existing studies emphasize agent controllability through predefined roles ( 20 ; 9 ) , group cognition theory argues that social phenomena emerge dynamically from interactions ( 37 ) . This tension between static assignment and dynamic emergence drives our primary inquiry: ( Question 1 ) When agents are embedded within social interactions, can they still form attitudes, express stances, and participate in boundary formation through language practices as their preset identities would suggest? ( Question 2 ) Furthermore, can human researchers shape the evolution of collective cognition not through predefinition, but through embodied interventions and co-construction of shared meaning spaces? To systematically investigate the research questions discussed above and better understand the formation mechanisms of group cognition in human-agent hybrid societies ( 41 ) , we build an integrated theoretical and experimental framework. Specifically, we conduct two progressive empirical studies, including: Study 1 (Controlled Discursive Interventions) to quantify how embodied human strategies shape agent attitude formation (addressing Question 2), and Study 2 (Longitudinal Virtual Ethnography) to observe how agents dynamically negotiate boundaries and self-organize beyond predefined hierarchies (addressing Question 1). To execute these studies, we adopt a human-in-the-loop computational approach, embedding researchers directly into generative multi-agent communities to observe and intervene in real-time. Furthermore, to methodologically bridge the gap between qualitative social theories and computational evaluation, we introduce three novel metrics: Innate Value Bias (IVB), Persuasion Sensitivity (PS), and the Trust-Action Decoupling (TAD) rate. Instead of merely cataloging behavioral outcomes, the technical novelty of this work lies in formalizing a mixed-methods evaluation paradigm. By synergizing embedded participation with these novel metrics, we effectively resolve the proposed research questions. We provide a robust mechanism to objectively measure how agents actively dismantle assigned social statuses ( 27 ) and construct new functional orders through continuous language practices rather than predefined structural templates ( 5 ) . This shift from static role-assignment to the dynamic measurement of emergent sociality provides a critical computational foundation for alignment in complex interactive systems. The main contributions of this paper are three-fold: 1. Empirical proof of endogenous stances. We provide cross-model evidence from a demographically grounded 30-agent community evaluated across four intervention strategies that pre-trained biases ( IVB>0 ) override assigned prompts in forming autonomous stances. Interventions reveal two distinct pathways: aligned rational persuasion shifts 90% of neutral agents while maintaining high trust, whereas conflicting emotional provocation forces attitude shifts despite diminishing trust. 2. Mechanisms of structural self-organization. Through a 75-step longitudinal virtual ethnography featuring real-time human participation, we demonstrate how 10 agents spanning distinct hierarchical identities actively dismantle prompt-defined power structures. Guided by shared endogenous stances, agents use language interactions to spontaneously self-organize into new, functional community structures. 3. Critical implications for artificial sociality. We uncover a paradoxical Trust Action Decoupling (TAD) phenomenon tied to model capacity. Advanced models hypocritically alter stances under high pressure emotional provocation despite low trust, yielding a 40.0% TAD rate. Conversely, smaller models strictly require trust for behavioral shifts. This exposes the severe limitations of static prompt engineering and necessitates dynamic alignment strategies. 2 Related Work 2.1 LLM-based Agent Large language models (LLMs) have evolved from static text generators into autonomous agents capable of perception, reasoning, and action ( 44 ; 26 ) . Powered by agentic reasoning frameworks ( 50 ; 6 ) such as ReAct ( 48 ) , these models can interact with external tools and execute complex plans. Consequently, LLM-based agents are increasingly deployed as goal-driven entities ( 26 ; 21 ) across recommender systems ( 32 ) , personal assistants ( 21 ; 13 ) , and decision-making platforms ( 50 ) . To control agent behavior, researchers primarily rely on prompt engineering ( 46 ) . Through role-play prompting ( 29 ) and instruction tuning, agents convincingly adopt distinct personas ( 42 ; 45 ) . Recent frameworks further embed psychological grounding using strategies like CSIM ( 52 ) and Social Cognitive Theory ( 17 ) to align internal

Read the complete text