Glassy magnetic freezing of interacting clusters in LK-99-family materials
Serafim Teknowijoyo, Domenico Napoletani, Vahan Nikoghosyan, Armen Gulian · 2026
Read Glassy magnetic freezing of interacting clusters in LK-99-family materials by Serafim Teknowijoyo, Domenico Napoletani, Vahan Nikoghosyan, Armen Gulian (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-23377.txt.
Introduction
Teknowijoyo and three co-authors re-examine odd magnetic signals in LK-99 family materials. Copper-doped apatite samples made by hydrothermal routes show repeatable anomalies below room temperature. Some readings hinted at vortex-glass behavior like that in superconductors. The team tests that idea with DC and AC magnetization plus memory effects. The signals instead fit glassy freezing of interacting magnetic clusters. Chemistry checks blame covellite, a copper sulfide phase that lurks in these mixed samples. The work warns that phase mixes can fake superconducting signs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Serafim Teknowijoyo, Domenico Napoletani, Vahan Nikoghosyan, Armen Gulian |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 18837 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.23377
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Glassy magnetic freezing of interacting clusters in LK-99-family materials Serafim Teknowijoyo, Domenico Napoletani, Vahan Nikoghosyan, Armen Gulian Abstract We report reproducible magnetization anomalies appearing below room temperature in copper-doped apatite materials belonging to the LK-99 family synthesized via hydrothermal methods. These anomalies are observed consistently across samples prepared under comparable conditions. Although the extracted Mydosh parameter lies within the range often associated with vortex-glass behavior in superconductors, a detailed analysis of DC magnetization, AC susceptibility, field dependence, and magnetic memory effects demonstrates that the observed phenomena are not related to superconductivity. Instead, the data are consistent with glassy magnetic freezing of interacting clusters. Compositional and structural analysis identifies covellite (CuS), an ubiquitous secondary phase in these intrinsically multiphase materials, as the primary origin of the observed behavior. Our results clarify the magnetic origin of LK-99-related anomalies and highlight the importance of phase complexity in interpreting apparent superconducting signatures in this materials family. I. Introduction In 2023, Lee, Kim, and Kwon claimed the discovery of a superconductor operating at room temperature and ambient pressure ref1 . This announcement elicited an intense response from both theoretical and experimental communities. On the theoretical side, it stimulated broad speculation regarding possible mechanisms for superconductivity in the exotic crystal structure of modified apatite ref2 ; ref3 ; ref4 ; ref5 ; ref6 ; ref7 ; ref8 ; ref9 ; ref10 ; ref11 ; ref12 ; ref13 ; ref14 ; ref15 ; ref16 ; ref17 . Experimentally, however, numerous attempts to reproduce the reported results were unsuccessful ref18 ; ref19 ; ref20 ; ref21 ; ref22 ; ref23 ; ref24 ; ref25 ; ref26 ; ref27 ; ref28 ; ref29 ; ref30 ; ref31 ; ref32 . These references arrived within the first two months after the original preprint ref1 and later appeared as journal publications. A central difficulty lay in the fact that the exact chemical composition of the reported material remained unclear, even to the original authors. Moreover, the synthesis reaction described in Ref. ref1 was chemically unbalanced, leaving several key questions unresolved. Subsequent efforts by many independent groups expanded the characterization of this system ref33 ; ref34 ; ref35 ; ref36 ; ref37 ; ref38 ; ref39 ; ref40 ; ref41 ; ref42 ; ref43 ; ref44 ; ref45 ; ref46 ; ref47 ; ref48 ; ref49 ; ref50 ; ref51 ; ref52 ; ref53 ; ref54 ; ref55 and ultimately led to the conclusion that the reported “superconducting” signatures can be explained by a structural phase transition in Cu 2 S ref28 , one of the constituent phases in this inherently multiphase material. This interpretation largely resolved the initial controversy surrounding the reported superconducting signatures and effectively concluded the disputes. Depending on the chosen synthesis route—and, critically, on subtle variations in synthesis parameters (for example, the pH during hydrothermal growth)—the resulting materials exhibit not only quantitative but also qualitative differences. These differences extend beyond chemical composition to include crystal structure as well as magnetic and transport properties. This diversity motivates the conditional grouping of all such multiphase materials produced via different modified-apatite synthesis protocols under the collective designation “LK-99.” Throughout this work, we use the term “LK-99 family” to denote chemically and structurally distinct, yet synthesis-related, multiphase materials rather than a single well-defined compound. In the present work, we set aside the question of superconductivity at or above 300 K, despite a very intriguing behavior above room temperature in some of our samples (as shown in Fig. 1 ); it is out of the scope of this discussion since we admit that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, including reproducibility, long-term stability, and a comprehensive and internally consistent set of physical characteristics, criteria that have not yet been satisfied. While agreeing that phase transitions in Cu 2 S can adequately account for the experimental observations reported in Ref. ref1 , this conclusion naturally raises a further question: could materials belonging to the LK-99 family exhibit superconductivity at lower temperatures? Motivated by this question, we investigated a series of samples that reproducibly display the anomalous behavior shown in Fig. 2 . Although this response at first glance resembles a Meissner-like effect, a detailed analysis demonstrates that it originates from the melting of a spin-glass state. Furthermore, we obtained experimental evidence indicating that the presence of the CuS phase within LK-99-type materials is responsible for this behavior. II. Experimental details and results Modified apatite compositions were synthesized using a standard high-pressure hydrothermal method in stainless-steel autoclaves equipped with PTFE-lined inserts of 30 and 100 mL volume. The starting reagents were copper nitrate [Cu(NO 3 ) 2 ], lead nitrate [Pb(NO 3 ) 2 ], ammonium dihydrogen phosphate (NH 4 H 2 PO 4 ), and potassium sulfide (K 2 S). The synthesis protocol follows Ref. ref54 and consists of two successive stages. At the first stage, the reagents were mixed in a molar ratio Cu 2+ : Pb 2+ : PO {}_{4}^{3-} : S 2- = 9 : 1 : 6 : 2. Ammonium hydroxide was added to deionized water to adjust the pH to 8. The resulting solution was maintained in a water bath at 60 ∘ C for 24 h. Subsequently, the mixture was transferred into the hydrothermal reactor, typically filling \sim 75% of the reactor volume; in some runs, the filling fraction was increased to as much as 90% in order to enhance the autogenous pressure during hydrothermal growth. Hydrothermal treatment was then typically carried out at 150–160 ∘ C for 48 h. During this process, the initially brown solution transformed into a gray precipitate suspended in a nearly colorless supernatant. The precipitate was separated by filtration and dried. In addition to rinsing with deionized water, ethyl alcohol was used to accelerate the drying process. The dried material obtained after the first stage was then mixed with an additional amount of sulfide ions (S 2- ) at a molar ratio of 1:10. The pH was again adjusted to 8 using ammonium hydroxide. This mixture was magnetically stirred at 60 ∘ C for 12 h, followed by a second hydrothermal treatment at 150 ∘ C for 8 h or longer. When these conditions were strictly maintained, the resulting precipitate was black, corresponding to the desired modified apatite phase. A summary of the synthesis temperature regimes is provided in Table 1 . Table 1: Regimes of hydrothermal synthesis of 4 samples (a,b,c in 100 mL and d in 30 mL reactor). # 1st stage 2nd stage Powder Pellet a 150 ∘ C/48h 150 ∘ C/11h \sim 403 mg 84.5 mg b 160 ∘ C/48h 160 ∘ C/16h \sim 532 mg 82.5 mg c 150 ∘ C/53h 150 ∘ C/14h \sim 777 mg 58.5 mg d 150 ∘ C/48h 150 ∘ C/24h \sim 41 mg 40.8 mg The powders were subsequently pressed into pellets, which were used for magnetic characterization. Temperature-dependent magnetization measurements in various applied magnetic fields, as well as AC magnetic susceptibility measurements over a range of frequencies, were performed using a DynaCool physical property measurement system (PPMS, Quantum Design). Panels (a)–(d) in Fig. 2 present the key experimental observation: the bifurcation of zero-field-cooled and field-cooled magnetization curves. Figure 1: Temperature dependence of the magnetization measured in a copper-doped pyromorphite pellet (mass \approx