Interfacial instability as a trigger for dryout inception in two-phase CO 2 flow

G. Cantini, G. Arnone, F. Capone, J.A. Gianfrani, M. Carnevale · 2026

Read Interfacial instability as a trigger for dryout inception in two-phase CO 2 flow by G. Cantini, G. Arnone, F. Capone, J.A. Gianfrani, M. Carnevale (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-23371.txt.

Introduction

Cantini and four co-authors test a new idea for what triggers dryout in two-phase carbon dioxide cooling. Particle detectors run hotter as luminosity climbs, and tight spaces force millichannel cooling. In annular flow, dryout crashes heat transfer and risks dangerous spikes. The team models the liquid-vapor interface and checks its stability with linear theory. The math reduces to a coupled fourth-order eigenvalue problem, solved with a Chebyshev code. A critical vapor quality marks where the interface turns unstable. Two past experiments match that threshold.

Catalog record

CREATORG. Cantini, G. Arnone, F. Capone, J.A. Gianfrani, M. Carnevale
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63652
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.23371

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Interfacial instability as a trigger for dryout inception in two-phase CO 2 flow G. Cantini, G. Arnone, F. Capone, J.A. Gianfrani, M. Carnevale Abstract Progress in particle physic leads to increasing in detector luminosity and a consequent increasing overheating induced by Joule effect. An effective cooling strategy is the exploitation of CO 2 heat latency in phase-change. An additional challenge, relevant to detectors for High Energy Particles, is the consequent geometrical constrain due to the limited space avialable for the cooling system within the detector arrangement, leading to the implementation of cooling system by means of millichannels. In this context, at relative high vapour quality the liquid phase exhibits annular flow, anticipating the dryout. Dryout is a critical condition where the heat transfer coefficient dramatically drops and dangerous temperature levels can be reached, potentially leading to catastrophic consequences. Experimental evidences reveal that its behavior in two-phase annular flows differs from conventional refrigerants and the fundamental inception-mechanism is not yet understood. This study aims at investigating the key new idea whereby dryout inception is triggered by instability of the liquid-vapour interface. A mathematical model for two-phase annular flow is presented and the stability of the interface between the two fluids is studied through the linear theory. The stability analysis reduces to solving a coupled forth-order differential eigenvalue problem that is treated numerically with an in-house code based on the Chebyshev- τ \tau method. Numerical investigations identify a critical value for the vapour quality, named x d ​ r ​ y x_{dry} , that leads to interface instability. The resulting predictions on x d ​ r ​ y x_{dry} are confirmed by experimental data collected from two independent experimental campaigns, validating the hypothesis that dryout inception is governed by interfacial instabilities. 1 Introduction The dryout phenomenon is known in heat transfer processes as a condition to be avoided in order to keep a cooling system working at its best [ 24 ] . It is defined as the condition where the Heat Transfer Coefficient (HTC) drops drastically within the heat exchanger, reaching values comparable to those of gaseous flows [ 4 ] . In heat management processes, during the evaporation the flow is bi-phase and the heat transfer is more efficient than in flows without phase change [ 10 ] . Nonetheless, as the vapour quality increases along the channel, the progressive depletion of the wall film may trigger dryout. In such a condition, the liquid film detaches from the pipe wall that is then in direct contact with the vapour phase, leading to an abrupt degradation of the local HTC and potentially compromising component integrity. In applications where there is a constant imposed heat flux at the wall, like in nuclear reactor or in electronics cooling, the dryout can raise the wall temperature enough to melt the exchanger bringing the devices to failure or dangerous consequences [ 16 ] . Therefore, a more accurate prediction of the onset of dryout can be useful to support less conservative safety margin in cooling system design, with a more efficient result. Among all refrigerants, boiling carbon dioxide offers numerous advantages over synthetic refrigerants. Its cost, reliability and minimal Global Warming Potential make CO 2 cheap, efficient and environmentally friendly. The high working pressure and low liquid-to-vapour density ratio of CO 2 make it well-suited for efficient heat exchange in milli-scale diameter pipes and for saturation temperatures T_{sat} in the interval (-40^{\circ}C,-10^{\circ}C) [ 14 ] . This is because the evaporation takes place at higher pressure than standard refrigerants and the pressure drop has a limited relative effect on boiling pressure compared to standard fluids [ 23 ] . Additionally, CO 2 is neither toxic nor flammable, and its non-corrosive properties are pivotal for safe operation of the electronics and other equipment. Its resistance to radiation makes it an ideal candidate for cooling applications in particle physics detectors. Furthermore, for small-diameter channels the thermal conductivity of CO 2 is higher than standard fluids as can be seen in Figure 2 in [ 23 ] . The above features, however, make CO 2 two-phase flows qualitatively different from those of conventional refrigerants. As a result, phenomenological models struggle to accurately predict the vapour quality at the onset of dryout, from now on denoted as x_{dry} . Accurate estimation of x_{dry} is therefore pivotal in cooling-system design. In [ 21 ] , two trends have been identified for the CO 2 dryout vapour quality as a function of the mass flux: • \mathbf{\delta}^{+} regime: x_{dry} increases with rising mass flux G . Although less frequently observed in the literature, some instances of this behaviour are documented in [ 26 ] and [ 13 ] . • \mathbf{\delta}^{-} regime: x_{dry} decreases with increasing mass flux G . This regime is widely reported in the literature as in [ 25 ] and [ 9 ] . The flow pattern map proposed by [ 9 ] is considered the most robust for CO 2 but represents solely \delta^{-} behaviour. Correlations informed by the \delta^{-} regime will result in an underestimation of x_{dry} when \delta^{+} behaviour is present. An attempt to describe the transition from \delta^{+} to \delta^{-} is proposed in [ 21 ] where a phenomenological model based on a system of differential equations for liquid and vapour phases is introduced. However, such a model disregards the wall heat flux, which has been shown to be important in the \delta^{+} regime through an experimental study conducted in [ 13 ] . Importantly, all theoretical approaches presented in the open literature fail to model the compound effects of all contributing physical parameters, as stressed by [ 15 ] . A recent paper [ 6 ] provides an initial step toward filling this gap. This research is based on an experimental campaign conducted at CERN, and is intended to investigate the dryout inception in CO 2 in milliscale pipes under representative operating conditions for high-heat-flux applications in the \delta^{+} regime. In [ 6 ] the authors show the inability of existing models to predict dryout inception across all conditions, particularly the less understood \delta^{+} regime where dryout vapour quality increases with mass flux. Moreover, as a novelty, the authors connect experimental observations to stability theory through dimensional analysis, deriving a dryout instability factor , denoted as I_{\delta^{+}} , that naturally emerges from momentum balance at the interface. The empirical correlation between I_{\delta^{+}} and measured x_{dry} bridges first-principles theory and data-driven prediction, validated against independent data from [ 13 ] . Remarkably, this framework is independent of the saturation temperature and the heat flux, namely it reduces the dependence on experiment-specific conditions, making design and extrapolation easier. In this context, motivated by [ 6 ] , the present work aims to support the hypothesis that the dryout phenomenon is triggered by instability of the interface between liquid and gaseous CO 2 , providing a mathematical theoretical counterpart of the experimental empirical campaign. To this end, we develop a mathematical model for two-phase annular flow, with liquid and vapour separated by a sharp interface with appropriately defined interfacial conditions. The present study represents the first application of rigorous stability theory to the \delta^{+} regime in boiling CO 2 annular flow, providing a framework that

Read the complete text