Rethinking Self-Sovereign Identity Principles: An Actor-Oriented Categorization of Requirements
Daria Schumm, Burkhard Stiller · 2026
Read Rethinking Self-Sovereign Identity Principles: An Actor-Oriented Categorization of Requirements by Daria Schumm, Burkhard Stiller (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-23177.txt.
Introduction
Schumm and Stiller rethink self-sovereign identity principles from the viewpoint of the actors involved. Centralized identity systems face steady security and privacy problems. Prior work gathered identity principles but left the user view thin. The authors split combined requirements into 24 simple quality requirements. Each is mapped to the actor who owns it: data owner, issuer, verifier, or system. A dependency model then shows how actors rely on each other. The result is a first structured model for such system design.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daria Schumm, Burkhard Stiller |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39785 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.23177
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Rethinking Self-Sovereign Identity Principles: An Actor-Oriented Categorization of Requirements Daria Schumm, Burkhard Stiller Abstract Centralized identity management systems continuously experience security and privacy challenges, motivating the exploration of Decentralized Identity (DI) and Self-Sovereign Identity (SSI) as user-focused alternatives. Although prior research has consolidated SSI principles and derived quality requirements for DI/SSI systems, it is significantly limited in integrating the user viewpoint. This work addresses this gap by embedding a user perspective into the requirements engineering process for DI/SSI systems. Building on existing SSI principles, composite requirements were decomposed into 24 simple quality or non-functional requirements (NFR). The resulting NFR are systematically mapped to the key actors, namely data owner, issuer, verifier, and system, based on varying degrees of responsibility and ownership. A dependency model is introduced to formalize relationships between actors. Inspired by trust modeling concepts, the model explicitly describes how actors interact and rely on each other for requirements fulfillment. By integrating user-centered requirements, responsibility allocation, ownership specification, and dependency modeling, this work provides the first structured model for DI/SSI system architectures. 1 Introduction With the growing number of vulnerabilities in centralized identity management, illustrated by numerous data breaches [ 17 , 1 ] , other alternatives should be considered to enable more secure handling of personal data. Decentralized Identity (DI) and Self-Sovereign Identity (SSI) offer an alternative to traditional identity management approaches by enabling data owners to retain control over their identity data without reliance on centralized services. Existing DI/SSI systems largely build on SSI principles, such as existence, control, and persistence, originally introduced by [ 2 ] . Other works, such as [ 6 ] , extended these principles and provided more elaborate descriptions and classifications based on multiple sources ( e.g. , [ 2 , 8 , 23 , 18 ] ). [ 6 ] outlined a comprehensive set of quality requirements that compose a DI/SSI system. The authors classified identified requirements into five categories, namely security, privacy, adoption and sustainability, usability and user experience, and controllability, and prioritized them based on the expert’s feedback. The main limitation of [ 6 ] is the lack of an individual user perspective on requirements, which largely misrepresents the actual users and user-focused approach of DI/SSI. Similarly, DI/SSI design patterns, presented in [ 7 , 15 ] , provide a limited perspective on user roles and requirements but comprehensively outline the functionality and interactions of DI/SSI systems. Design patterns are frequently used in software engineering to define how a certain objective in software development can be achieved and to describe a solution to a recurring problem [ 19 ] . In the context of DI/SSI, there is currently no explicit mapping between the established design patterns and the quality requirements they are intended to address. The objective of this work is to address the lack of a user viewpoint within the DI/SSI domain and to embed the user into the requirements engineering process. To address this objective, this work builds on the requirements aggregated by [ 6 ] . Some composite requirements ( e.g. , existence and representation) have been broken down into independent, simple quality requirements or non-functional requirements (NFR), resulting in a total of 24 requirements, as outlined in Table 1 . Design patterns, outlined in [ 7 , 15 ] , were considered to identify goals, interests, and involvement of various users (or actors) within DI/SSI systems, as well as explicitly map them to the requirements presented in Table 1 . As a result, this work contributes (i) a refined set of user-centered requirements that consistently reflect a user-based viewpoint, (ii) specification of responsibilities and ownership for each requirement across users, and (iii) a dependency model that specifies where, when, and by whom each requirement is realized within DI/SSI systems. This work is organized as follows. Section 2 specifies a generalized use case, definitions used throughout the paper, and the methodology that was used to map and categorize requirements. Section 3 maps design patterns and NFR, followed by Section 4 , which provides a concise discussion of each NFR concerning its assignment. Section 5 summarizes the results of NFR categorization and introduces the dependency model for DI/SSI systems. Section 6 concludes the work and indicates future work. Table 1: Non-Functional Requirements of DI and SSI Systems Key Quality Description NFR1 Accessibility User must be able to access and retrieve data NFR2 Authenticity Source of identity data must be trustworthy and provable NFR3 Autonomy User must be able to manage their identity independently NFR4 Availability Identity data must be available at any time NFR5 Compatibility Identity data must be compatible with legacy systems NFR6 Consent User must explicitly consent to the use of their data NFR7 Control User must be able to control access to their identity data NFR8 Cost All components must have minimal costs NFR9 Decentralization All components should not rely on centralized elements NFR10 Existence User identity must have an independent existence without relying on other services NFR11 Interoperability Identity data must be usable across different platforms and services NFR12 Persistence Identity data must remain valid and accessible for as long as necessary NFR13 Portability User must be able to move their identity data NFR14 Privacy User must be able to minimize information required to share NFR15 Protection Identity data must be protected against misuse NFR16 Recoverability User must be able to recover identity data in case of loss and compromise NFR17 Representation Users must be able to create multiple identities NFR18 Security All components must ensure the data is secure NFR19 Single Source User must be the single authoritative source of their identity NFR20 Standard Credentials must adhere to open standards NFR21 Transparency Information about data use must be readily available NFR22 Usability User must be able to use their data efficiently and intuitively NFR23 User Experience Identity management process must be simple, consistent, and user-friendly NFR24 Verifiability Identity data must be verifiable 2 Use Case, Definitions, & Methodology Categorizing requirements requires a clear understanding of who is responsible for what within the DI/SSI system. First, a generalized use case is described to illustrate the fundamental processes common to all DI/SSI systems. Then, the users of a DI/SSI system are defined, along with key concepts, such as responsibility and ownership. Lastly, the three-step methodology for systematic requirements categorization is outlined. 2.1 Generalized Use Case Use cases provide a structured mechanism for analyzing responsibilities and requirements within a system [ 13 ] . The DI/SSI domain has numerous use cases, ranging from healthcare to education. By omitting implementation details, each use case reveals a recurring pattern. For example, a DI/SSI system for a government service and for event ticketing might have different goals, but they represent the same underlying functionalities and involve the same core stakeholders or users ( e.g. , credential issuer and verifier), and rely on the same fundamental processes ( e.g. , credential issuance and verification). A shared goal of both systems is the “identification of a human”, adapted to a different context. The validity of a generalized use case argument is supported by evidence from existing systems. For example, Sovrin [ 16 ] and IDunion [ 14 ] operate in different regulatory and operational environments. However, they both rely on