When Data Protection Fails to Protect: Law, Power, and Postcolonial Governance in Bangladesh DOI: 10.1145/1122445.1122456 Conference: CHI; Nov 5-9, 2026; USA CHI’24, Nov, 2026, USA Price: 15.00 DOI: 10.1145/3491102.43 ISBN: 978-1-4503-9157-3/22/04 CCS: Social and professional topics Computing and technology policy

Pratyasha Saha, Anita Say Chan, Sharifa Sultana · 2026

Read When Data Protection Fails to Protect: Law, Power, and Postcolonial Governance in Bangladesh DOI: 10.1145/1122445.1122456 Conference: CHI; Nov 5-9, 2026; USA CHI’24, Nov, 2026, USA Price: 15.00 DOI: 10.1145/3491102.43 ISBN: 978-1-4503-9157-3/22/04 CCS: Social and professional topics Computing and technology policy by Pratyasha Saha, Anita Say Chan, Sharifa Sultana (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-22637.txt.

Introduction

Saha, Chan, and Sultana analyze data protection law in Bangladesh. Fast growth in digital services, finance, and telecoms has raised the amount of personal data collected. The state replied with three ordinances in 2025, covering personal data, cyber security, and data governance. The authors review all three as one legal regime. They map how the rules fit together and where they fall short. Key barriers include weak institutional independence and uneven enforcement capacity. The laws also assume lone, self-reliant data subjects, hiding informal data flows and human helpers.

Catalog record

CREATORPratyasha Saha, Anita Say Chan, Sharifa Sultana
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61362
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.22637

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

When Data Protection Fails to Protect: Law, Power, and Postcolonial Governance in Bangladesh DOI: 10.1145/1122445.1122456 Conference: CHI; Nov 5-9, 2026; USA CHI’24, Nov, 2026, USA Price: 15.00 DOI: 10.1145/3491102.43 ISBN: 978-1-4503-9157-3/22/04 CCS: Social and professional topics Computing and technology policy Pratyasha Saha, Anita Say Chan, Sharifa Sultana Abstract . Rapid digitization across government services, financial platforms, and telecommunications has intensified the collection and processing of large-scale personal data in Bangladesh. In response, the state has introduced multiple regulatory instruments, including the Personal Data Protection Ordinance, the Cyber Security Ordinance, and the National Data Governance Ordinance in 2025. While these initiatives signal an emerging legal regime for data protection, little scholarly work examines how these frameworks operate collectively in practice. This paper presents a legal and institutional analysis of Bangladesh’s emerging data protection regime through a systematic review of these three ordinances. Through this review, the paper provides an integrated mapping of Bangladesh’s evolving data protection framework and identifies key legal and institutional barriers that undermine the effective protection of citizens’ personal data. Our findings reveal that this emerging regime is constrained by limited institutional independence, uneven regulatory capacity, and the misaligned legal assumption of individualized, autonomous data subjects. Furthermore, these frameworks invisibilize prevalent sociotechnical layers, such as informal data flows and mediated access via “human bridges”, rendering formal protections difficult to operationalize. This paper contributes to HCI scholarship by expanding the concept of data protection as a complex sociotechnical design problem shaped by the informal infrastructures of the Global South. 1. Introduction Over the past decade, Bangladesh has rapidly expanded digital governance initiatives through programs such as Digital Bangladesh ( 73 ) , large-scale biometric identity systems ( 58 ) , and the growth of mobile financial services used by tens of millions of citizens ( 32 ) . These infrastructures process vast amounts of personal data, including demographic information, biometric identifiers, financial records, and communication metadata. As the digital ecosystem grows, concerns surrounding privacy, surveillance, and data misuse have increasingly drawn attention from scholars, policymakers, and civil society organizations ( 3 ; 12 ) . In July 2023, a vulnerability in Bangladesh government’s Birth and Death Registration system exposed the personal information of over 50 million citizens, including names, phone numbers, and national identity numbers ( 39 ) . This database could be accessed through publicly available APIs, which revealed sensitive demographic information at national scale. More recently, a technical failure in the Election Commission’s website exposed the personal data of around 14,000 journalists, including national ID numbers and mobile phone details, which demonstrates persistent vulnerabilities in government data management systems ( 31 ) . Beyond data breaches, concerns have also been raised about the broader governance environment surrounding digital regulation in Bangladesh. Investigative reports have revealed that some government employees illegally accessed and sold citizens’ personal data including NID records and phone call details, through hundreds of social media groups and online platforms ( 51 ) . These incidents demonstrate how personal data frequently circulates through informal and mediated networks that remain largely invisible within formal regulatory frameworks such as ICT Act ( 2 ) , Telecommunications Regulation Act, Personal Data Protection Ordinance ( 7 ) , Cyber Security Ordinance ( 5 ) , and National Data Governance Ordinance ( 6 ) . These laws were recently amended by the Bangladesh government to regulate the collection, processing, and sharing of personal data, yet scholars and activists warn that these emerging legislations fail to incorporate adequate safeguards and oversight mechanisms to ensure robust privacy protections for citizens ( 8 ; 4 ; 9 ; 65 ; 18 ) . To understand this mismatch between policy frameworks and the ways data actually circulates in practice, we draw on Arora’s critique of aspirational digital governance. Arora argues that digital governance is often framed through narratives of technological modernization, where regulatory frameworks assume forms of digital participation that mirror idealized technological futures rather than the sociotechnical realities through which digital systems actually operate ( 15 ) . In this framing, governance systems are designed around imagined infrastructures of orderly data flows, institutional capacity, and individualized participation, even when everyday digital practices are mediated through informal networks, infrastructural improvisation, and relational forms of access. Within HCI and ICTD scholarship, however, how data protection regimes operate as sociotechnical systems remains understudied. Existing research often focuses on normative privacy principles or high-level regulatory reforms without examining how multiple laws interact or what kinds of institutional and sociotechnical infrastructures they assume for enforcement ( 69 ; 92 ; 59 ) . As a result, data protection regimes are frequently treated as formal legal frameworks rather than as governance systems embedded within broader institutional and infrastructural contexts ( 95 ) . Our research addresses this gap through a qualitative legal and institutional analysis of Bangladesh’s emerging data protection regime. We examine three key regulatory instruments: the Personal Data Protection Ordinance ( 7 ) , the Cyber Security Ordinance ( 5 ) , and the National Data Governance Ordinance ( 6 ) , to understand how they conceptualize personal data governance and what institutional or sociotechnical infrastructures they assume for enforcement. Our broader goal is to understand why, despite the growing presence of formal legal protections, citizens’ personal data remains vulnerable in practice. Specifically, we address three research questions: • RQ1: What is the legal regime of data protection in Bangladesh? • RQ2: What forms of institutional and technical infrastructure do these frameworks assume for enforcement? • RQ3: Why do existing data protection laws in Bangladesh fail to function as effective protections for citizens in practice? Our analysis reveals several structural weaknesses within the current legal framework. Although multiple ordinances reference principles of data protection and digital governance, they distribute regulatory authority across overlapping agencies while granting broad discretionary powers to state actors. Institutional oversight mechanisms remain weak or ambiguously defined, and the frameworks assume enforcement capacities, such as independent regulatory bodies, technical compliance monitoring systems, and transparent accountability mechanisms, that are largely absent in practice. Most significantly, the framework renders invisible the critical sociotechnical layers of data handling in citizens’ interactions with digital systems, including informal intermediary bodies that remain unrecognized within the law’s regulatory categories - actors we define as “human bridges". Thus, the legal regime constructs a model of data governance that appears comprehensive on paper yet fails to account for both the institutional limitations and the sociotechnical practices through which personal data is accessed, processed, and shared in practice. Thus, this paper makes a threefold contribution to the HCI and ICTD literature. First, we map the emerging data protection regime in Bangladesh by examining how multiple legal instruments collectively structure personal data governance and what institutional capacities they assume for enforcement. Second, we show how personal data governance in practice is mediated through sociotechnical infrastructures like “human bridges" that remain largely invisible within formal regulatory frameworks. Third, we advance the decolonial HCI scholarship by showing how universalized regulatory models can obscure the relational infrastructures through which digital participation and data governance operate in reality, and thus limit the effectiveness of formal regulatory protections. 2. Background 2.1. Privacy, Data Protection and AI Systems A growing body of work in privacy, law, and HCI has examined

Read the complete text