Generalized thermodynamic closure in ultrafast phonon dynamics
Sheng Qu, Jiyong Kim, Jaco J. Geuchies, Sergey Kovalev, Jan-Christoph Deinert, Thales de Oliveira, Alexey Ponomaryov, Min Chen, Nilesh Awari, Igor Ilyakov, Mischa Bonn, Heejae Kim · 2026
Read Generalized thermodynamic closure in ultrafast phonon dynamics by Sheng Qu, Jiyong Kim, Jaco J. Geuchies, Sergey Kovalev, Jan-Christoph Deinert, Thales de Oliveira, Alexey Ponomaryov, Min Chen, Nilesh Awari, Igor Ilyakov, Mischa Bonn, Heejae Kim (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-22632.txt.
Introduction
Qu and co-authors report an experiment on a driven phonon mode in a quantum material. They ask whether driven, energy-losing systems can still follow a thermodynamic account. Past a threshold drive strength, the phonon mode shows a delayed ultrafast response. The authors link that delay to excitations spreading across many phonon levels. Lindblad dynamics fitted to the data support this view. Trajectories for three drive settings fall on one shared surface, set by energy and coherence together. The result frames a coherence-extended thermodynamic regime.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sheng Qu, Jiyong Kim, Jaco J. Geuchies, Sergey Kovalev, Jan-Christoph Deinert, Thales de Oliveira, Alexey Ponomaryov, Min Chen, Nilesh Awari, Igor Ilyakov, Mischa Bonn, Heejae Kim |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34277 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.22632
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Generalized thermodynamic closure in ultrafast phonon dynamics Sheng Qu, Jiyong Kim, Jaco J. Geuchies, Sergey Kovalev, Jan-Christoph Deinert, Thales de Oliveira, Alexey Ponomaryov, Min Chen, Nilesh Awari, Igor Ilyakov, Mischa Bonn, Heejae Kim Abstract Driven-dissipative dynamics underlie a wide range of nonequilibrium phenomena in quantum materials, yet reduced descriptions beyond the quasi-equilibrium picture remain difficult to establish. Here, we experimentally demonstrate that a resonantly driven phonon mode admits a generalized thermodynamic description in which coherence and energy jointly organize the nonequilibrium evolution. Beyond a threshold driving field strength, we observe a delayed ultrafast response of a coherently driven phonon mode. Combined with experimentally constrained Lindblad dynamics, we show that this delay reflects the finite-time spreading of excitations across many phonon levels. At the same time, the full density-matrix trajectories for three driving conditions collapse onto a common surface defined by energy and coherence. Our results establish a coherence-extended thermodynamic regime for driven phonons and provide a framework for broader state engineering in driven-dissipative bosonic excitations. keywords driven-dissipative dynamics, ultrafast dynamics, far-from-equilibrium matter, generalized thermodynamic closure, halide perovskites † † equal-contributors: These authors contributed equally to this work. † † equal-contributors: These authors contributed equally to this work. 1 Introduction Driven-dissipative quantum systems lie at the intersection of quantum information science 43 , Floquet engineering 13 , and active matter 28 . A central challenge in studying these systems is identifying a reduced set of state variables that captures the essential physics without resolving the full microscopic complexity. Whereas equilibrium statistical mechanics provides a general answer through thermodynamic closure, no comparably universal principle is known far from equilibrum 38 . In equilibrium, conservation laws and the thermodynamic state postulate guarantee that a small number of macroscopic variables (e.g. P,T ) uniquely determine the state and its entropy 9 . Close to equilibrium, this framework remains robust, and formalisms such as Mori–Zwanzig projection rigorously separate slow collective dynamics from fast microscopic noise 31 ; 46 . Far from equilibrium, however, driving and dissipation can undermine these safeguards by violating fundamental conservation laws, thereby obscuring the boundary between emergent macroscopic dynamics and microscopic fluctuations. In such regimes, the system’s evolution may no longer be captured by a single-valued thermodynamic manifold 38 . From an experimental standpoint, ultrafast spectroscopy is uniquely positioned to resolve these evolutionary paths with femtosecond precision. By synchronizing non-adiabatic excitation with real-time observation, these techniques offer a window into the transient trajectories of far-from-equilibrium matter 12 ; 30 . Despite this potential, experimental analysis has conventionally defaulted to quasi-equilibrium variables—such as effective temperatures 1 ; 11 —or highly truncated few-level models 35 ; 20 . Such reduced-order descriptions implicitly assume that the system’s physics can be confined to a narrow subset of its Hilbert space. However, these approximations are fundamentally ill-equipped to describe regimes where the drive forces the system into a higher-dimensional state space. Consequently, a comprehensive experimental characterization of how these trajectories escape and eventually return to the thermodynamic manifold has remained elusive 12 ; 27 . Here, we experimentally demonstrate the breakdown of quasi-equilibrium thermodynamic closure in a driven-dissipative many-body system. By resonantly driving a specific lattice vibration in a crystalline solid with intense terahertz (THz) pulses, we interrogate the electronic evolution with sub-picosecond resolution. Above a critical threshold, we observe a delayed electronic response that cannot be explained by standard few-level truncations. Through simulations using an experimentally constrained Lindblad master equation, we reveal that this delay signifies the delayed multi-level occupation spreading. Yet, the full density-matrix evolution remains confined to a low-dimensional manifold: for three driving conditions, the trajectories collapse onto a common surface S=S(E,C) , with E the phonon energy and C the total coherence. Thus, our results provide evidence that coherently driven lattice excitations can realize a coherence-extended thermodynamic regime in solids. Figure 1: Experimental realization of a driven-dissipative phonon system far from equilibrium. (a) The differential transmission spectrum, \Delta T/T , of MAPI at 100 K via the THz pump pulse centered at 1 THz. The spectra at the probe energy below 1.65 eV are magnified to better display the sub-band-gap response (see main text). (b) The temporal profile of the pump THz pulse. (c) The dynamics of the differential transmission at the probe energy of 1.6 eV. The 1.6 eV response reaches its maximum after \sim 3 ps from the maximum of the THz pump. (d) The differential transmission spectrum at the pump-probe delay time, t_{\rm pr} , of 3 ps. (e) The transient spectra of the suppressed sub-gap transition at t_{\rm pr}= 3 ps at various peak field strengths of the drive THz pulses. (f) The threshold behavior of the suppression of sub-gap transition upon the drive peak field strengths. 2 Results To achieve a genuinely far-from-equilibrium state of matter, we use intense narrowband THz pulses from the accelerator-based TELBE THz facility 15 ; 22 , where the spectral brightness is three orders of magnitude higher than that of typical \mathrm{LiNbO_{3}} -based (100 kV/cm level) THz tabletop sources 20 . The frequency is tuned to be resonant (1 THz) with, slightly detuned (0.8 THz) from, and non-resonant (0.3 THz) with the target phonon mode (centered at 1 THz) of methylammonium lead iodide perovskite (( \mathrm{CH_{3}NH_{3}PbI_{3}} , MAPI, see Supplementary Fig. S1 (a-b)). Upon the strong, transient drive, the subsequent electronic response from the near-gap transitions (Supplementary Fig. S1 (c)) that are strongly coupled with the particular phonon mode 36 ; 20 is captured by subsequent near-infrared probe pulses. The thus obtained electronic response via a driven collective lattice mode (Fig. 1(a)) is displayed together with the temporal profile of the THz driving pulse shown above (on the same time axis, Fig. 1(b)). At the experimental temperature (100 K), the system is in its orthorhombic phase ( T_{c}\sim 160 K) where the band gap is located around 1.67 eV 29 . A noticeable, instantaneous response in the probe energy of 1.66-1.72 eV is the expected Franz-Keldysh effect 2 ; 39 ; 20 . It has a purely electronic origin arising from the electric field-modified Bloch-like electron wave function 20 ; 6 . Unexpectedly, above a certain drive threshold ( > peak field strength of 50 kV/cm with the spectral width of 0.2 THz), a distinct electronic response in the probe energy of 1.58-1.63 eV ( \sim 60 meV below the band gap) starts to appear and peaks approximately 3 ps after the driving pulse (Fig 1. (c-f)). The positive differential transmission (Fig 1. (d)) indicates a suppression of the sub-gap absorption, which corresponds to the significant tail below the band gap (Supplementary Fig. S1 (c)) due to the dynamic structural disorder 4 . Such a dynamically delayed, suppression of the sub-gap absorption (i) emerges only when the THz pump frequency is (near-) resonant (i.e. 0.8 and 1 THz), not when non-resonant (i.e. 0.3 THz, Supplementary Fig. S2) (ii) exhibits identical delay times when the THz field strength varies (with the Fig 1(a) obtained by the maximum, 183 kV/cm, Supplementary Fig. S3(a-b)), and (iii) persists over the temperature range of 100-140 K (Supplementary Fig. S3(c-e)). As the frequency selectivity of the THz driving pulse testifies to, this distinct electronic response directly reflects the evolution of a strongly driven system via a specific collective