Model validation and tolerancing of scalar vortex masks in the High Contrast Imaging Testbed (HCIT) facility
Niyati Desai, Garreth Ruane, Daniel Shanks, Lorenzo König, Susan Redmond, Bertrand Mennesson · 2026
Read Model validation and tolerancing of scalar vortex masks in the High Contrast Imaging Testbed (HCIT) facility by Niyati Desai, Garreth Ruane, Daniel Shanks, Lorenzo König, Susan Redmond, Bertrand Mennesson (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-22537.txt.
Introduction
Desai and co-authors check how well lab models of scalar vortex coronagraph masks match reality. Such masks must dim starlight by ten orders of magnitude so future telescopes can image Earth-like planets. The scalar design keeps both polarizations in one path, which simplifies the optics. The team measures mask defects with phase metrology and feeds the results into their control model. They test how errors in angle or wavelength degrade the wavefront control. Lab results from the JPL testbed agree well with the model.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Niyati Desai, Garreth Ruane, Daniel Shanks, Lorenzo König, Susan Redmond, Bertrand Mennesson |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 22877 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.22537
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Model validation and tolerancing of scalar vortex masks in the High Contrast Imaging Testbed (HCIT) facility Niyati Desai, Garreth Ruane, Daniel Shanks, Lorenzo König, Susan Redmond, Bertrand Mennesson Abstract The Habitable Worlds Observatory (HWO) mission will require coronagraphs capable of suppressing starlight at the ∼ 10 − 10 \sim 10^{-10} contrast level to directly image exo-Earths. High contrast achromatic coronagraphic masks are the missing critical component to achieving this. Vortex coronagraphs, particularly scalar vortex designs with an achromatic focal plane mask, offer key advantages. While all vortex coronagraph varieties provide high throughput, a small inner working angle, and rejection of low-order aberrations, the scalar approach enables dual-polarization observation in a single optical path. This simplifies instrument design and increases transmission by maintaining light from the planet in two orthogonal polarization states. In this work we test scalar vortex masks and investigate their contrast limitations. We perform phase metrology to assess the mask defects and manufacturing deviations and use it to refine the coronagraphic model used for electric field conjugation (EFC) algorithms and end-to-end simulations. We also measure the impact of model-mismatch with EFC by varying model parameters including clocking angle, and central wavelength in laboratory demonstrations. Finally, we validate our scalar vortex models against experimental results from the High Contrast Imaging Testbed (HCIT) facility at JPL by finding good agreement between lab and simulated performance. This ultimately helps to benchmark simulated contrast predictions for future scalar vortex coronagraph designs for HWO. a]Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91109, USA keywords High contrast imaging, instrumentation, exoplanets, coronagraph, scalar vortex † † authorinfo: Send correspondence to [email protected] 1 INTRODUCTION The Habitable Worlds Observatory (HWO) mission concept aims to directly image and spectrally characterize Earth-like exoplanets around nearby stars, requiring raw contrast levels on the order of 10^{-10} at small angular separations [ 14 ] . Achieving such performance depends on precise starlight suppression through a coronagraph system, which relies critically on both the design and fabrication of a high-performing focal plane mask and the accuracy of the optical model used in model-based wavefront control algorithms such as Electric Field Conjugation (EFC) [ 10 , 7 ] . As coronagraph mask designs become increasingly complex to mitigate chromatic limitations and fabrication constraints, it becomes essential to understand how mask and model accuracy affect coronagraph performance in the context of future missions like HWO. 1.1 Scalar Vortex Coronagraphs Among the various coronagraph architectures under consideration for HWO, scalar vortex coronagraphs (SVCs) have emerged as a promising solution due to their low inner working angle, high throughput, and dual-polarization capability [ 16 ] . Unlike vector vortex coronagraphs (VVCs), which rely on the geometric phase and require additional polarization optics (e.g., waveplates, analyzers) [ 17 ] , SVCs manipulate the longitudinal phase and can operate identically on both orthogonal polarization states within a single optical path. The SVC applies a spiral phase pattern to the incoming wavefront, redirecting starlight outside of the Lyot stop and enabling high-contrast imaging of off-axis planetary light. This desired phase pattern is typically implemented by spatially varying the thickness or refractive index of a material. This method not only enables precise phase control but also supports dual-polarization operation—a key advantage over vector vortex designs. This dual-polarization capability simplifies system design and integration while preserving more of the planet signal. Recent work developing SVCs has focused on addressing the chromatic limitations of current mask designs to achieve deeper broadband contrast. New SVCs have introduced increasingly complex focal plane mask topographies—such as multi-zone or sawtooth phase patterns—optimized for achromatic performance [ 4 , 3 , 6 , 8 ] . While effective at mitigating chromatic leakage, these designs present new challenges in fabrication precision and model fidelity. 1.2 Model-based Wavefront Control Modern high-contrast imaging systems rely on model-based wavefront control to suppress residual starlight after coronagraphic rejection. One of the most widely used techniques is Electric Field Conjugation (EFC), which iteratively adjusts deformable mirror (DM) commands to drive the intensity in the focal plane to zero based on a model of the optical system [ 13 , 9 ] . EFC assumes that the model accurately predicts how changes in the DM shape affect the complex electric field at the final focal plane. Inaccuracies in the optical model—especially in regions of strong phase gradients introduced by the coronagraph—can lead to suboptimal DM solutions and degraded contrast performance, especially in broadband light where model errors accumulate across spectral channels. The central motivation of this work is to investigate how specific types of model mismatch, particularly in the focal plane mask, affect the performance of SVCs when used with EFC in the lab. We aim to quantify the sensitivity of achievable contrast to mask alignment errors and fabrication deviations and to provide guidance on acceptable model tolerances for future missions such as HWO. 2 MEASURING & MODELING MASK DEFECTS 2.1 Metrology Efforts Figure 1 : (left) Phase measurement of sawtooth with central phase dimple SVC prototype mask taken with the digital holographic microscope. (center) Best fit SVC model to DHM measurement. (right) Residual difference between measurement and model. One approach to improving the model fidelity of complex structured coronagraph masks is through advanced mask metrology. This involves obtaining accurate phase measurements of the vortex masks, with particular attention to the regions near phase discontinuities. For VVCs, commonly used techniques include Mueller matrix measurements to quantify retardance and polarization-dependent leakage, as well as optical microscopy to identify point defects on the mask surface [ 12 ] . In the case of scalar vortex masks, optical microscopy remains useful for initial inspection, but since there is no polarization leakage, the phase must be measured in other ways. This could be done by using a profilometer to measure the surface profile and then translating these measurements to phase. Alternatively, phase measurements could be directly acquired interferometrically using either a digital holographic microscope (DHM) or a Zygo interferometer [ 2 ] . This work measured and modeled a prototype of a combined sawtooth and central Roddier dimple scalar vortex mask presented by Desai et al. 2024a [ 6 ] . Further details regarding mask design and prototype fabrication can be found in Desai et al. 2024b [ 5 ] . Figure 1 shows how a DHM phase measurement of the SVC (left plot of Figure 1 ) is used to identify defects and constrain the model parameters that best fit the prototype. The vortex model (center plot of Figure 1 ) can then be subtracted from the phase measurement to reveal surface smoothness and any fabrication defects. The plot on the right of Figure 1 shows the residual phase difference and is indicative of the quality of mask fabrication. There is great agreement between the measured prototype and the model except at the central defect and around the radial phase discontinuities. While the DHM proved useful for qualitatively evaluating fabrication quality, the profilometer and the Zygo interferometer provide more consistent and reliable measurements [ 5 ] . Although these two methods show stronger agreement with each other than with the DHM results, a common limitation among these methods is their inability to resolve the central region of the mask, particularly within 10 microns of the