Quantum Tunneling of Primordial Black Holes to White Holes: Rates, Constraints, and Implications for Fast Radio Bursts

and Stefano Profumo · 2026

Read Quantum Tunneling of Primordial Black Holes to White Holes: Rates, Constraints, and Implications for Fast Radio Bursts by and Stefano Profumo (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-22516.txt.

Introduction

Ewasiuk and Profumo compute how often primordial black holes might tunnel into white holes today. The rate hinges on a race between Hawking evaporation and tunneling over cosmic time. It peaks where the black hole lifetime roughly matches the age of the universe. The authors fold in realistic abundance limits and wider mass ranges. They find burst rates like fast radio bursts only in narrow, fine-tuned corners. Current radio, gamma-ray, and host-galaxy data allow at most a minor white-hole share of those bursts.

Catalog record

CREATORand Stefano Profumo
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE78913
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.22516

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantum Tunneling of Primordial Black Holes to White Holes: Rates, Constraints, and Implications for Fast Radio Bursts and Stefano Profumo Abstract We calculate the present-day and cosmological volumetric rate of primordial black hole (PBH) quantum tunneling events to white holes, incorporating the competition between Hawking evaporation and tunneling, cosmological depletion, realistic mass-dependent abundance constraints, extended mass functions, and the alternative memory-burden scenario. The burst rate is maximized along a narrow ridge in the mass–tunneling-parameter plane where the effective PBH lifetime is comparable to the age of the Universe. Within the canonical Planck-star range of tunneling timescales, FRB-level rates arise only in two highly restricted regions: a low-mass window near the evaporation boundary, and a narrow sequential window where evaporation precedes tunneling; broadening the PBH mass function does not qualitatively alter this conclusion. We further assess observational constraints from FRB repetition statistics, radio spectral properties, prompt and diffuse gamma-ray limits, host-galaxy demographics, and gravitational-wave signatures. All current observations are consistent with a subdominant white-hole contribution to the FRB population but strongly disfavor a dominant origin. The rate calculation does not generically support FRB-level event densities, and any viable FRB interpretation requires narrow, fine-tuned, and strongly assumption-dependent corners of parameter space. 1 Introduction Black holes are traditionally considered long-lived classical objects, whose only quantum effect is slow evaporation via Hawking radiation on timescales vastly exceeding the age of the Universe for astrophysical masses [ 31 ] . However, several approaches to quantum gravity suggest that black holes may undergo a quantum transition to white hole (WH) states, a process sometimes referred to as a “Planck-star bounce” [ 29 , 43 , 17 ] . In this picture, the classical singularity is replaced by a region of finite density that eventually tunnels to a white hole geometry, releasing the remaining mass-energy in a burst of high-energy radiation. If primordial black holes (PBHs) are formed in the early Universe [ 12 , 14 ] and if they make up a fraction f_{\rm PBH} of the dark matter density, their quantum tunneling decays could be an observable probe of quantum gravity. The volumetric burst rate R_{\rm PBH} depends on both their abundance and the quantum tunneling lifetime [ 29 , 43 , 17 ] : \tau(M)=\alpha\bigg(\frac{M}{M_{\rm Pl}}\bigg)^{2}t_{\rm Pl}, (1.1) where \alpha is a dimensionless parameter encoding non-perturbative gravitational dynamics. In current heuristic models, \alpha is assumed to be {\cal O}(0.01 – 1 ), yielding relatively prompt bounces for light PBHs. Fast radio bursts (FRBs) [ 3 ] , bright millisecond-duration radio transients of unknown origin, have motivated interest in PBH quantum bursts as possible progenitors [ 7 , 6 ] . If even a small fraction of PBHs exploded today, their integrated rate could approach the observed FRB volumetric density of 10^{4-5} Gpc -3 yr -1 . However, existing estimates of R_{\rm PBH} are highly uncertain, with only order-of-magnitude estimates available and little exploration of the full (M,\alpha) parameter space, nor of the depletion of PBHs that would have tunneled earlier in cosmic history. In this work, we revisit the calculation of R_{\rm PBH} in detail. We: 1. Derive the expected volumetric rate as a function of M , \alpha , and f_{\rm PBH} , accounting for cosmological depletion of early tunneling events; 2. Perform a comprehensive parameter scan over \alpha\in[10^{-4},10^{25}] and M\in[10^{8},10^{20}] kg, producing updated constraints and rate predictions; 3. Compare the results to the observed FRB rate and assess detectability with current instruments; and 4. Discuss the theoretical implications of requiring \alpha\gg 1 for FRB-level rates and the prospects for probing quantum gravity with PBH tunneling. Relative to earlier order-of-magnitude estimates [ 7 , 6 ] , the principal novelties of our treatment are: (a) explicit inclusion of the competition between Hawking evaporation and quantum tunneling through a combined effective lifetime; (b) cosmological depletion of PBHs that tunneled at earlier epochs; (c) incorporation of realistic, mass-dependent upper bounds f_{\rm PBH,max}(M) from microlensing, CMB, and evaporation constraints; (d) a systematic scan of the full (M,\alpha) parameter space; (e) extension to lognormal mass functions; and (f) a parallel analysis under the memory-burden hypothesis, which enforces sequential rather than competitive evolution. Our findings show that the present-day PBH tunneling burst rate is sharply peaked along the locus where the effective lifetime satisfies \tau_{\rm eff}(M)\simeq t_{0} , with t_{0} the current age of the universe, producing a narrow ridge on the (M,\alpha) plane. For the canonical Planck-star range 10^{-2}\lesssim\alpha\lesssim 1 , FRB-level volumetric rates, R\sim 10^{4-5}\,\mathrm{Gpc}^{-3}\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} , are not generically obtained but may arise in two highly-restricted regions: (i) a low-mass window near the evaporation boundary M\sim 10^{11-12}\,\mathrm{kg} , where tunneling becomes competitive with Hawking depletion, and (ii) a narrow sequential window in the memory-burden scenario, where evaporation first reduces the mass before tunneling activates. Outside these finely tuned regions, the rate is exponentially suppressed or too small to be observationally relevant. Including realistic PBH abundance limits and cosmological evolution further compresses the viable parameter space, so that PBH tunneling can at most account for a subpopulation of FRBs under highly specific mass and abundance assumptions. The remainder of our study is organized as follows. In Sec. 2 we review the black-to-white hole tunneling framework, including its quantum-gravity motivation, lifetime scaling, and emission signatures. Sec. 3 discusses the multi-channel detectability of Planck-star bursts (PSBs) across radio, gamma-ray, and cosmic-ray observations. Sec. 4 reviews observational status and constraints on FRB rates. In Sec. 5 we derive the expected volumetric burst rate from black-to-white hole transition, present results for the monochromatic mass function and present-day rate, discuss redshift evolution, extend the analysis to non-monochromatic mass functions, and examine the theoretical status of the tunneling parameter \alpha . Sec. 6 studies gamma-ray and multiwavelength signatures and constraints. Finally, we synthesize the implications for FRB phenomenology and quantum gravity in Sec. 7 . 2 Black-to-White Hole Tunneling Model In general relativity, the gravitational collapse of matter beyond its Schwarzschild radius leads to the formation of an event horizon enclosing a spacetime singularity. This description is widely believed to be incomplete, since spacetime singularities signal the breakdown of the classical gravitational theory. Loop Quantum Gravity (LQG) provides a background-independent, non-perturbative quantization of spacetime geometry that naturally resolves singularities through quantum gravitational repulsion at Planckian densities [ 4 , 44 ] . In this context, black holes are conjectured to be metastable states that can undergo a quantum tunneling process into white holes [ 29 , 17 ] . The transition connects the trapped region inside the horizon with an expanding geometry, enabling information and matter initially captured by the black hole to be released after a finite delay. This is the basis for the so-called “Planck star” scenario [ 43 ] , in which the black hole core never reaches a singularity but bounces due to quantum pressure, subsequently emerging as a white hole. 2.1 Lifetime of the Metastable Black Hole The quantum tunneling process is not instantaneous. Calculations in simplified models and spinfoam quantizations of LQG indicate that the expected lifetime of a black hole before transitioning to a white hole scales quadratically with its mass; in Planck units (G=c=\hbar=1) , Eq. ( 1.1 ) reads: \tau(M)=\alpha\,M^{2}\,, (2.1) where \alpha is a dimensionless constant that encodes details of the transition amplitude

Read the complete text