Chirality Cannot Be Ferroic in Enantiomorphic Space-Groups Preprint: APS/123-QED
F. Gómez-Ortiz, S. Mamoudou Taganga, Emma E. McCabe, A. H. Romero, E. Bousquet · 2026
Read Chirality Cannot Be Ferroic in Enantiomorphic Space-Groups Preprint: APS/123-QED by F. Gómez-Ortiz, S. Mamoudou Taganga, Emma E. McCabe, A. H. Romero, E. Bousquet (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-22501.txt.
Introduction
Gómez and co-authors prove that chirality cannot act as a primary ferroic order in certain crystal classes. Some had suggested that handedness itself could order, like magnetism or polarization. The team uses group theory and a full subgroup survey to test that idea. They show no achiral parent can reach an enantiomorphic pair through a zone-center instability. Since a ferroic order must transform at the zone center, such transitions cannot be primary ferroic ones. Any critical fluctuations should appear at finite wavevector instead.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | F. Gómez-Ortiz, S. Mamoudou Taganga, Emma E. McCabe, A. H. Romero, E. Bousquet |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 49576 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.22501
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Chirality Cannot Be Ferroic in Enantiomorphic Space-Groups Preprint: APS/123-QED F. Gómez-Ortiz, S. Mamoudou Taganga, Emma E. McCabe, A. H. Romero, E. Bousquet Abstract With growing interest in structural chirality in periodic solids, it has been suggested that chirality might constitute a new ferroic order parameter. In this work, we demonstrate, by means of a formal group-theoretical proof and a systematic group–subgroup analysis, that achiral-to-chiral transitions that produce either member of an enantiomorphic pair cannot be driven by a Brillouin-zone-center ( Γ \Gamma -point) instability from a common achiral parent. We further substantiate this result by explicitly showing that none of the achiral parent space groups that admit symmetry-chiral phonon eigenvectors host them at the zone center. Given that a primary ferroic order parameter must, among other requirements, transform according to a zone-center irreducible representation, we conclude that phase transitions leading to enantiomorphic space groups cannot be classified as primary ferroic transitions. This predicts that any critical enhancement of fluctuations must occur at finite- q q rather than as a divergence of a uniform macroscopic susceptibility. The study of chirality in crystalline solids has gained renewed momentum in recent years. This resurgence has been driven in part by the identification of chiral phonons Zhu et al. 2018 ; Juraschek et al. 2025 , as well as by the growing recognition that chirality plays a significant role in several high-impact areas of condensed-matter physics, including topological insulators Chang et al. 2018 ; Sanchez et al. 2019 , magnetic skyrmions Mühlbauer et al. 2009 , and unconventional transport phenomena in noncentrosymmetric materials Juraschek and Spaldin 2019 ; Li et al. 2020 . Beyond being a geometric descriptor, chirality has emerged as a structural feature capable of shaping electronic, vibrational, and magnetic properties. Recent reviews Fecher et al. 2022 ; Bousquet et al. 2025 have emphasized chirality as an organizing principle Hlinka 2014 for emergent behavior in solids. In particular, chirality has been discussed in the context of spontaneous symmetry breaking. It has been proposed that structural transitions from achiral to chiral phases may arise from the condensation of soft phonon modes Bousquet et al. 2025 ; Fava et al. 2025a ; Gómez-Ortiz et al. 2025 . Within such a framework, chirality can be treated as an order parameter, and Landau free-energy expansions have been proposed to describe the energy landscape connecting left- and right-handed configurations Bousquet et al. 2025 ; Spaldin 2026 . Motivated by these developments, it has also been hypothesized that chirality itself might be treated in close analogy with conventional ferroic order parameters Fava et al. 2025a . In particular, this question has attracted special attention in the case of the 22 enantiomorphic space groups. With this perspective, the two enantiomorphic variants are viewed as symmetry-related states separated by a double-well potential Fava et al. 2025a ; Bousquet et al. 2025 . This formulation naturally prompts the search for a universal conjugate field that would couple linearly to chirality Bousquet et al. 2025 ; Fava et al. 2025b , allowing selective stabilization of a chosen enantiomorph and opening the highly desirable scenario of externally controllable “ferrochiral” behavior Bousquet et al. 2025 ; Spaldin 2026 . Following the phenomenological definition of ferroicity Wadhawan 2000 ; Tolédano et al. 2015 ; Toledano and Toledano 1987 , for chirality to qualify as a primary ferroic order, it needs to satisfy four criteria Wadhawan 2000 : (i) the spontaneous emergence of long-range order below a critical temperature (T {}_{\text{C}} ), (ii) the existence of enantiomorphic domains that exhibit hysteresis when switched, (iii) the ability to undergo field-induced phase transitions, and (iv) a characteristic enhancement of macroscopic susceptibility near (T {}_{\text{C}} ). In the framework of Landau theory, this further indicates that the primary ferroic transition has to take place at the center of the Brillouin zone ( k=0 ), ensuring that the order parameter is macroscopic and preserves the unit cell size Tolédano et al. 2015 ; Toledano and Toledano 1987 ; Tolédano and Tolédano 1977 . This primary ferroicity has been questioned regarding the gyrotropic properties, e.g., for gyroelectric crystals, where switching the ferroelectric order switches the natural optical activity of the crystal. Optical gyrotropy has then been viewed as an implicit form of ferroicity (often acting as a by-product of ferroelectricity or ferroelasticity) Wadhawan 1979 ; classifying it as an independent primary ferroic order would, however, require the identification of an unique ordering field that can directly couple to the chiral order parameter Wadhawan 2000 . A similar debate has recently arisen in the context of the magnetic toroidal moment Sannikov 2007 ; Van Aken et al. 2007 ; Zimmermann et al. 2014 , where the question of primary ferroicity was carefully examined and ultimately resolved with the recognition of ferrotoroidicity as a genuine ferroic order Tolédano et al. 2015 ; Gnewuch and Rodriguez 2019 . In this sense, the present discussion regarding chirality follows an established line of inquiry. The central symmetry question is: can a single achiral parent phase generate both enantiomorphs of an enantiomorphic pair through a \Gamma -point order parameter? In this work, we address this question at the level of group theory and group-subgroup relationships. We demonstrate, in a general way, that achiral-to-chiral phase transitions among the 22 enantiomorphic space groups cannot arise from \Gamma -point irreducible representations, generalizing a result previously noted for chiral spinels Talanov et al. 2015 ; Talanov et al. 2016 . Instead, such transitions necessarily originate from instabilities at non-zero wave vectors. We further corroborate this result by examining the symmetry properties of chiral phonon modes and showing that none of the achiral parent space groups hosting chiral phonons possess them at the zone center. Our result implies that structural chirality leading to enantiomorphic space groups cannot be classified as a primary ferroic order. We also discuss in the conclusion the case of the 43 Sohnke groups that hold chiral crystals, but where, contrary to the enantiomorphic space groups, the left- and right handed structures belong to the same space group. These results specify the circumstances in which drawing an analogy to ferroic behavior is, or is not, justified. —Zone-Center Exclusion Theorem in chiral transitions to Enantiomorphic pairs— Theorem 1 . Let L_{1} and L_{2} be an enantiomorphic pair. Then, any space group H that is a common supergroup of both enantiomorphs must satisfy [T_{H}:T]>1 . Proof. Since L_{1} and L_{2} are enantiomorphic space groups, they share the same point group and translational subgroup T . Without loss of generality ( L_{1} and L_{2} space groups each include a screw axis n_{p} of opposite helicity), we may assume that the screw operation n_{p}=(C_{n}\mid\tfrac{p}{n}c)\in L_{1}, for some integer p<\tfrac{n}{2} , while its enantiomorphic counterpart n_{n-p}=(C_{n}\mid\tfrac{n-p}{n}c)\in L_{2}. Since both L_{1} and L_{2} are subgroups of H , it follows that n_{n-p}n_{p}^{-1}\in H. A direct computation yields \displaystyle n_{n-p}n_{p}^{-1} \displaystyle=(C_{n}\mid\tfrac{n-p}{n}c)\,(C_{n}^{-1}\mid-\tfrac{p}{n}c) \displaystyle=(E\mid\tfrac{n-2p}{n}c)\in T_{H}\trianglelefteq H. (1) Because p<\tfrac{n}{2} , the quantity \tfrac{n-2p}{n}c corresponds to a non-lattice fractional translation of L_{1} and L_{2} that must lie in the translational subgroup T_{H} of H , implying that [T_{H}:T]>1. ∎ It immediately follows from the theorem that transitions from any parent structure to chiral enantiomorphic pairs cannot occur at the \Gamma point. Indeed, a \Gamma -point instability preserves the translational