Stoquastic permutationally invariant Bell operators

Jan Li, Owidiusz Makuta, Evert van Nieuwenburg, Jordi Tura · 2026

Read Stoquastic permutationally invariant Bell operators by Jan Li, Owidiusz Makuta, Evert van Nieuwenburg, Jordi Tura (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-22493.txt.

Introduction

Li and co-authors link two ideas from many-body physics: Bell operators and stoquasticity. A Bell operator can be read as a Hamiltonian, and the stoquastic ones have no positive off-diagonal entries in a chosen basis. The team defines a stoquasticity cone that maps exactly where a permutationally invariant Bell operator is stoquastic. For the standard two-setting, two-outcome case with up to three-body terms, they show such operators can always be made stoquastic. They also use the cone to sharpen the quantum-classical gap.

Catalog record

CREATORJan Li, Owidiusz Makuta, Evert van Nieuwenburg, Jordi Tura
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE103184
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.22493

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Stoquastic permutationally invariant Bell operators Jan Li, Owidiusz Makuta, Evert van Nieuwenburg, Jordi Tura Abstract As Hermitian operators, many-body Bell operators can naturally be identified as many-body Hamiltonians. An important subclass of such Hamiltonians is the stoquastic class, characterized by having nonpositive off-diagonal matrix elements in a given basis. Interestingly, this property is shared by the permutationally invariant (PI) Bell operators underlying the largest Bell-correlation experiments to date. In this work, we explore the connection between many-body PI Bell operators and stoquasticity. We introduce the stoquasticity cone, which allows for a full characterization of the stoquastic parameter regimes for any PI Bell operator. We use this to show that PI Bell operators of the binary-input binary-output scenario consisting of at most three-body correlators can always be rendered stoquastic for any set of measurement parameters. Additionally, we also provide examples that use the stoquasticity cone to optimize for the quantum-classical gap. Numerical evidence suggests that the Bell operator used in the largest experiments to date is optimal with respect to stoquasticity. To the best of our knowledge, this work establishes the first connection between PI Bell operators and stoquasticity. I Introduction Bell nonlocality has been of foundational and philosophical interest in physics 4 and it also serves as the key resource for tasks such as quantum key distribution 29 , randomness amplification and expansion 11 ; 28 ; 38 , and self-testing 32 . Moreover, such tasks can be framed within the device-independent paradigm 1 ; 17 , which allows for certification of quantum behavior from a minimal set of assumptions. Central to the device-independent paradigm are nonlocal correlations. Experimental verification of such correlations relies on measuring the expected value of a Bell operator 9 and checking whether it exceeds a classical threshold. Extending Bell certification to the many-body regime is both timely and challenging. On one hand, recent experimental progress in controlling large quantum systems 5 ; 26 makes such certifications increasingly relevant. On the other hand, while multipartite Bell operators have been studied for a long time 25 ; 34 ; 2 , their construction and implementation pose a significant challenge due to the increased complexity of the scenario. Classes of Bell operators that are experimentally friendly have been developed in the last decade, often relying on low-order correlators and symmetric expressions 36 ; 39 ; 37 ; 36 ; 12 ; 30 ; 3 . Indeed, for Bell experiments in the largest system sizes to date, 480 {}^{87}\mathrm{Rb} atoms in a Bose-Einstein condensate 31 and 5\cdot 10^{5} atoms in a thermal ensemble 15 , such Bell operators were used. Demonstrating Bell correlations in systems of this size requires preparing many-body entangled states that are both sufficiently entangled and experimentally accessible with current technology. Stoquastic Hamiltonians, which are Hamiltonians with only nonpositive off-diagonal elements for a given basis, may be particularly well-suited for this purpose. Stoquasticity was introduced in 6 from a complexity-theoretic point of view. This property was used in Ref. 8 to find the first natural complete problem of the classical complexity class MA, which is a probabilistic generalization of NP. Another interesting feature is that stoquastic Hamiltonians do not have the sign problem in Monte Carlo sampling methods 35 ; 7 , making them more amenable to classical simulation. Later, in a similar spirit, it was shown that tensor network contractions become easier on average when there is a positive bias in the entries 22 ; 10 . Additionally, it has been shown that Hamiltonians without the sign problem potentially allow for a subexponential speed up in adiabatic quantum computing compared to classical computing 18 ; 20 . Interestingly, it has so far gone unnoticed that stoquasticity is also related to nonlocality. More precisely, the Bell operators used in the aforementioned experiments 31 ; 15 can be made stoquastic using solely local unitary transformations. This raises the natural question of how general this property is and which Bell correlations remain accessible when restricting to stoquastic operators, which is the central question of this work. In this work, we aim to characterize the conditions under which Bell operators are stoquastic in the locally binary-input and binary-output scenario. We focus on a class of permutationally invariant (PI) Bell operators, which are characterized by Bell coefficients \vec{\alpha} and the measurement parameters \vec{\theta} , and we consider the case where the set of measurements is the same for all parties. In particular, we focus on the symmetric subspace, which is the subspace of states invariant under permutation of the n qubits, as the ground state of two-body PI Hamiltonians is expected to lie there 16 and as the analysis in the other subspaces is qualitatively similar 36 . Our first contribution is that for a class of PI Bell inequalities, the corresponding operators can always be made stoquastic under suitably chosen measurement parameters and we provide the corresponding conditions needed for them. Our second main contribution is a full characterization of the set of Bell coefficients for which the corresponding Bell operator is stoquastic under fixed measurement parameters \vec{\theta} . We show that this set is both a polyhedron and a cone, and thus we name it the stoquasticity cone. Using the stoquasticity cone, we show that Bell operators limited to at most three-body operators can always be made stoquastic. Additionally, we numerically optimize the quantum-classical gap over all stoquastic Bell coefficients at fixed measurement parameters. We conclude from numerical optimizations that the Bell operator used for the largest many-body Bell violations 31 ; 15 is optimal with respect to stoquasticity at its optimal measurement parameters and proves to be a good candidate for other measurement parameters. Finally, we show that with any state with non-negative amplitudes in the Dicke basis, we can associate a stoquastic PI Bell operator whose ground state is that state. As the squared amplitudes of such a state define a probability distribution over the Dicke basis, stoquastic PI Bell operators can serve as parent Hamiltonians for arbitrary such probability distributions. This potentially comes at the cost of requiring operators of order K\sim\mathcal{O}(n) . However for values of k\leq 3 , it is already possible to capture superpositions of Dicke states with a Gaussian profile with the variance scaling at \sqrt{n} , which correspond to spin squeezed states that are routinely prepared in experiments 23 . This highlights the importance of higher-order operators in accessing the full range of ground state probability distributions. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II , we introduce the necessary preliminaries, including permutationally invariant Bell operators, stoquastic Hamiltonians and the relevant notions from polyhedral theory. In Sec. III , we motivate our study by considering the example of the Bell operator used in the largest experiments to date. In Sec. IV , we analyze the stoquasticity of a class of two-body PI Bell operators and establish conditions under which they can be made stoquastic. In Sec. V , we introduce the stoquasticity cone and in Sec. V.1 we provide its full characterization for the two-body case. In Sec. V.2 , we extend the analysis to three-body PI Bell operators and show that they can always be made stoquastic. In Sec. VI , we discuss the connection

Read the complete text