More Than Power: Revisiting the CMB Hemispherical Power Asymmetry with Morphological Descriptors
Javier Carrón Duque, Mikel Martin Barandiaran, Joseba Martínez-Arrizabalaga † · 2026
Read More Than Power: Revisiting the CMB Hemispherical Power Asymmetry with Morphological Descriptors by Javier Carrón Duque, Mikel Martin Barandiaran, Joseba Martínez-Arrizabalaga † (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-22449.txt.
Introduction
Carrón and co-authors test whether the cosmic microwave background's hemispheric power asymmetry reaches beyond raw variance. They measure shape and topology statistics on local patches of the Planck SMICA map. Fits to those measures yield local estimates of variance, gradient variance, and fit quality. They confirm the known variance dipole at high significance. They also report a separate dipole in gradient variance, plus mild spatial change in fit quality. All three dipoles point toward the same sky region.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Javier Carrón Duque, Mikel Martin Barandiaran, Joseba Martínez-Arrizabalaga † |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46525 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.22449
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
More Than Power: Revisiting the CMB Hemispherical Power Asymmetry with Morphological Descriptors Javier Carrón Duque, Mikel Martin Barandiaran, Joseba Martínez-Arrizabalaga † Abstract Context. The Cosmological Principle assumes a statistically isotropic Universe, but the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) exhibits some anomalous statistical features, such as the hemispherical power asymmetry, that challenge this core assumption. Aims. We aim to expand the characterization of this anomaly by investigating the uniformity of the CMB’s morphological and topological properties, testing whether the asymmetry extends beyond the variance of the temperature field. Methods. We evaluate the three Minkowski Functionals (MFs) on local patches of the Planck SMICA temperature map and compare them against 999 FFP10 realistic simulations including noise. By fitting the local MFs to the analytical expectations for Gaussian isotropic fields, we extract local estimates of the temperature variance ( σ 2 \sigma^{2} ), the variance of the field gradients ( τ 2 \tau^{2} ), and the goodness-of-fit ( χ 2 \chi^{2} ). We then evaluate the presence, amplitude, and alignment of dipoles in these locally varying quantities. Results. We confirm the highly significant dipole in σ 2 \sigma^{2} (p-value ∼ 0.3 % − 1.0 % \sim 0.3\%-1.0\% ). Furthermore, we report a moderately significant dipole in the gradient variance τ 2 \tau^{2} (p-value ∼ 2.6 % − 3.7 % \sim 2.6\%-3.7\% ) that is statistically independent of the σ 2 \sigma^{2} dipole under the Λ \Lambda CDM model. We also find a mild spatial variation in the goodness-of-fit to the Gaussian isotropic predictions (p-value ∼ 2.1 % − 5.6 % \sim 2.1\%-5.6\% ). Remarkably, the Planck dipoles for all three quantities are clustered and point toward the same region of the sky. We find that the asymmetries in all quantities are well described by dipoles. Conclusions. The Hemispherical Asymmetry in the CMB extends beyond its local variance, as we found it to be also present in its local morphology. The MFs of the CMB present a dipolar pattern that can be characterized by independent dipoles in the variance and gradient variance, plus a hint of a non-Gaussian nature of this asymmetry. These results provide a more complete characterization of the Hemispherical Asymmetry, and will therefore contribute to better determine the nature of the physical effect behind it, whether cosmological, residual foregrounds, or unknown systematics. 1 Introduction The Cosmological Principle is one of the core assumptions of modern cosmology, being a cornerstone of the \Lambda CDM model and many of its extensions. It states that the universe is homogeneous and isotropic on sufficiently large scales. This assumption, initially established from a philosophical point of view, became empirically testable at the end of the twentieth century thanks to the discovery of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) perturbations. Until the present day, three full-sky microwave missions have been launched, aiming to measure the CMB and its anisotropies with increasing precision: COBE ( 111 ) , WMAP ( 113 ) , and Planck ( 91 ) . † † † All authors contributed equally to this work. The ordering of the authors is merely alphabetical. Although the CMB data is roughly compatible with the Cosmological Principle, many researchers have claimed that the CMB reveals a subtle but statistically significant violation of this principle, as several different statistics are found to be in mild tension with the assumption of statistical isotropy of the CMB; these are called the CMB anomalies ( 119 ; 33 ; 124 ; 69 ; 66 ; 67 ; 68 ; 76 ; 77 ; 60 ; 57 ; 114 ; 32 ; 18 ; 29 ; 12 ; 11 ; 88 ; 10 ; 78 ; 17 ; 16 ; 81 ; 41 ; 129 ; 6 ; 110 ; 40 ; 106 ; 46 , see, e.g, ) . Four representative statistics of the CMB anomalies have recently been shown to be independent, even in the tails, under the (isotropic) \Lambda CDM model, implying that the violation of the Cosmological Principle may be much more significant than any of these anomalies independently suggest ( 61 ) . Among the CMB anomalies, one of the most significant is the so-called hemispherical power asymmetry : a directional dependence of the variance of the CMB, i.e. , its power ( 36 ) . This directional dependence can be characterised as a dipole pointing at (\ell,\,b)\approx(225^{\circ},\,-27^{\circ}) in the variance of the map ( 37 ) . Thereafter, multiple works have reported the presence of this asymmetry in both WMAP and Planck data with different methodologies, reporting significances around 3\sigma ( 51 ; 49 ; 83 ; 101 ; 5 ; 3 ; 44 ; 109 ; 45 ; 63 ; 106 ; 105 ) . Given that this anomaly is explicitly connected to a violation of statistical isotropy, a deeper characterization and understanding of this anomaly could open the door to a more complete understanding of the validity of the Cosmological Principle. The mechanism responsible for the power asymmetry is not yet understood, but several possibilities have been proposed in the literature. One possibility is that it is caused by some residual effect of galactic foregrounds or unknown systematics ( 99 ) . Another possibility is that it is a secondary CMB effect caused by the nearby Universe, possibly through the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect of large structures ( 59 ; 13 ; 80 ) or some possibly unknown physical effect related to nearby galaxies ( 52 ; 53 ) . A third possibility is that the early Universe really is anisotropic, with different models being proposed in the literature, including causal horizons ( 39 ) or modified power spectra, possibly as a result of a new primordial field acting as a modulating field ( 126 ; 112 ; 75 ; 43 ; 42 ) . A particularly interesting option is that the Universe could have a non-trivial spatial topology ( 30 ; 104 ; 103 , and references therein) : this would introduce a violation of statistical isotropy in the Universe without the need to extend neither General Relativity nor the Standard Model of Particle Physics, but it has not been shown yet that the anisotropies induced are the kind needed to explain the CMB anomalies ( 25 ) . Although this list is far from exhaustive, it is clear that we need more insights on the hemispherical power asymmetry in order to potentially distinguish between different proposals. In this work, we explore a novel aspect on the hemispherical asymmetry by analysing the uniformity of morphological descriptors of the CMB. In particular, we study the three Minkowski Functionals (MFs), a popular set of statistics that characterize the morphology and topology of a field with a rich body of research in the Mathematical literature 1 1 1 In the Mathematical literature they are sometimes referred to as Lipschitz-Killing curvatures. They differ from MFs in the ordering of the labels and constant multiplicative factors. ( 2 ; 65 ; 123 ; 19 ; 24 ; 71 ) . MFs are sensitive to both the variance of the map, \sigma^{2} , and the variance of the gradient of the map, \tau^{2} . In fact, for zero-mean Gaussian isotropic fields, these two quantities are the only ones that come into play