SkillClone: Multi-Modal Clone Detection and Clone Propagation Analysis in the Agent Skill Ecosystem Conference: The 41st IEEE/ACM International Conference on Automated Software Engineering; October 12–16, 2026; Munich, Germany The 41st IEEE/ACM International Conference on Automated Software Engineering (ASE 2026), October 12–16, 2026, Munich, Germany CCS: Software and its engineering Software maintenance tools CCS: Software and its engineering Software libraries and repositories CCS: Security and privacy Software security engineering
Jiaying Zhu, Lyuye Zhang, Wenbo Guo, Yang Liu · 2026
Read SkillClone: Multi-Modal Clone Detection and Clone Propagation Analysis in the Agent Skill Ecosystem Conference: The 41st IEEE/ACM International Conference on Automated Software Engineering; October 12–16, 2026; Munich, Germany The 41st IEEE/ACM International Conference on Automated Software Engineering (ASE 2026), October 12–16, 2026, Munich, Germany CCS: Software and its engineering Software maintenance tools CCS: Software and its engineering Software libraries and repositories CCS: Security and privacy Software security engineering by Jiaying Zhu, Lyuye Zhang, Wenbo Guo, Yang Liu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-22447.txt.
Introduction
Zhu and co-authors hunt for hidden reuse among agent skills, the add-on packages that extend language model agents. Public stores host over two million skills, yet reuse through copying or renaming goes untracked. Their detector, SkillReuse, checks metadata, prose, and code channels together to score likely clones. On a benchmark of 300 skill pairs it beats standard text matching, above all on deep semantic clones. Run at scale, it finds clone links touching two thirds of all skills.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jiaying Zhu, Lyuye Zhang, Wenbo Guo, Yang Liu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 63174 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.22447
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
SkillClone: Multi-Modal Clone Detection and Clone Propagation Analysis in the Agent Skill Ecosystem Conference: The 41st IEEE/ACM International Conference on Automated Software Engineering; October 12–16, 2026; Munich, Germany The 41st IEEE/ACM International Conference on Automated Software Engineering (ASE 2026), October 12–16, 2026, Munich, Germany CCS: Software and its engineering Software maintenance tools CCS: Software and its engineering Software libraries and repositories CCS: Security and privacy Software security engineering Jiaying Zhu, Lyuye Zhang, Wenbo Guo, Yang Liu Abstract . Agent skills are modular instruction packages that combine YAML metadata, natural language instructions, and embedded code, and they have reached 196K publicly available instances, yet no mechanism exists to detect clone relationships among them. This gap creates systemic risks: a vulnerability in a widely copied skill silently persists across derivatives with no alert to maintainers. Existing clone detectors, designed for single-modality source code, cannot handle the multi-modal structure of skills, where clone evidence is distributed across three interleaved content channels. We present SkillClone , the first multi-modal clone detection approach for agent skills. SkillClone fuses flat TF-IDF similarity with per-channel decomposition (YAML, NL, code) through logistic regression, combining strong detection with interpretable type classification. We construct SkillClone-Bench , a balanced benchmark of 300 ground-truth pairs with stratified difficulty. On SkillClone-Bench , SkillClone achieves F1 of 0.939 with precision 0.952, outperforming flat TF-IDF (F1 = 0.881) and achieving 4.2 × \times higher Type-4 (semantic) recall than MinHash. Applying SkillClone to 20K skills reveals 258K clone pairs involving 75% of all skills, with 40% crossing author boundaries. A deduplication analysis shows the ecosystem is inflated 3.5 × \times : only 5,642 unique skill concepts underlie the 20K listed skills, and 41% of skills in clone families are superseded by a strictly better variant. 1. Introduction Large language model (LLM) agents have rapidly evolved from standalone chatbots into extensible platforms that delegate specialized tasks to modular instruction packages called agent skills . A skill is a structured document, typically a SKILL.md file, that bundles YAML metadata, natural language instructions, and embedded code blocks into a single artifact that an LLM agent such as Claude Code, Cursor, or Windsurf can load at runtime to acquire new capabilities. Since the public launch of skill ecosystems in late 2025, adoption has been explosive: over 196K skills are now publicly available on registries and GitHub repositories, spanning domains from code generation and security analysis to DevOps automation. This growth mirrors the early trajectories of package ecosystems like npm and PyPI ( Zimmermann et al. 2019 ; Decan et al. 2019 ) , which took years to reach comparable scale. Recent surveys ( Xu and Yan 2026 ) and empirical studies ( Ling et al. 2026 ) have begun to characterize this ecosystem’s architecture and growth dynamics. Despite this rapid expansion, the agent skill ecosystem lacks fundamental infrastructure that traditional package ecosystems take for granted. Skills declare no dependencies on other skills, carry no version identifiers, and provide no provenance metadata linking derived skills to their origins. When a developer copies, adapts, or extends an existing skill, this relationship is entirely invisible to the ecosystem. The consequence is a growing body of duplicated and near-duplicated content whose relationships cannot be traced, audited, or monitored. This situation creates concrete security risks: when a vulnerability is discovered in a widely copied skill, there is no mechanism to identify which other skills share its content and therefore share the same flaw. Unlike a CVE advisory that can propagate through a dependency graph in npm ( Liu et al. 2022 ) , a flawed skill pattern can silently persist across hundreds of derivative skills with no alert to their maintainers. The January 2026 ClawHavoc campaign ( Koi Security 2026 ) , which infiltrated over 1,200 malicious skills into the OpenClaw registry, demonstrated the real-world consequences of this gap. Existing tools for skill analysis treat each skill as an isolated unit. SkillScan ( Liu et al. 2026b ) performs static security checks on individual skill files. SkillFortify ( Bhardwaj 2026 ) validates skill structure and metadata quality. MalTool ( Liu et al. 2026a ) detects malicious intent in single skills through behavioral analysis. SkillJect ( Jia et al. 2026 ) and SKILL-INJECT ( Schmotz et al. 2026 ) have demonstrated that skills serve as potent attack vectors for prompt injection ( Schmotz et al. 2025 ) . Yet none of these tools examine relationships between skills, and no prior work has studied clone patterns at ecosystem scale, despite extensive evidence from traditional package ecosystems that such relationships are critical for security ( Zimmermann et al. 2019 ; Liu et al. 2022 ) . The absence of such analysis means that the community cannot answer basic questions: How prevalent is skill cloning? Do clone relationships cross organizational boundaries? What is the blast radius when a hub skill contains a vulnerability? The key insight behind our work is that agent skills are inherently multi-modal documents that resist analysis by any single similarity technique. For the dominant SKILL.md format studied in this paper, we scope the artifact to its three primary in-file modalities: YAML metadata specifying the skill’s name, tags, and configuration; natural language prose describing when and how to apply the skill; and embedded code blocks implementing concrete functionality. This scope targets the content carried directly inside the skill file, not auxiliary repository artifacts such as images, linked documents, or external scripts. Detecting clones requires fusing similarity signals across these three channels, because two skills may share identical code blocks while differing in their natural language framing, or may paraphrase the same instructions while referencing different code examples. Preliminary ecosystem analysis revealed that clone relationships are not rare edge cases but a dominant organizing force in the ecosystem: most skills participate in at least one clone relationship, a substantial fraction of clones cross author boundaries, and malicious patterns often propagate through these latent reuse links. These observations motivate a hybrid contribution. We study undeclared reuse empirically at ecosystem scale, and we introduce a multi-modal clone detector designed specifically for the mixed YAML, natural-language, and code structure of skills. To address this gap, we present SkillClone , the first approach for detecting clone relationships across the agent skill ecosystem. SkillClone implements a three-channel clone detection approach that synergistically computes similarity over YAML metadata, natural language instructions, and embedded code blocks, then fuses these signals through a weighted aggregation scheme to produce a unified clone score for each skill pair. We apply SkillClone to a representative sample of 20K skills drawn from the 196K-skill corpus crawled from GitHub and construct the first ecosystem-wide clone graph , where nodes represent skills and edges represent detected clone relationships. Over this graph, we perform blast radius analysis to quantify how a vulnerability in a single skill can propagate through chains of clones. An important distinction underlies our work: clone detection identifies structural similarity between artifacts, but does not by itself establish causal reuse (i.e., that one skill was derived from another). Establishing reuse requires additional provenance signals such as fork relationships, commit timestamps, or explicit attribution. We validate that our clone detection enables downstream reuse discovery by confirming provenance in fork-mined pairs and identifying real-world clone-and-rebrand cases (Section 2.3 ). For security