Inside the Black Box of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis: Parameter Sensitivity Studies in Light of new LBT Data
Anne-Katherine Burns · 2026
Read Inside the Black Box of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis: Parameter Sensitivity Studies in Light of new LBT Data by Anne-Katherine Burns (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-22414.txt.
Introduction
Burns maps how sensitive Big Bang nucleosynthesis is to the settings behind it. The study tracks how the first helium, deuterium, and lithium levels shift. It varies 14 core physics and cosmology parameters plus 63 reaction rates. Each shift is run through the public PRyMordial code. Burns also ranks which inputs drive the theory error budget. A new LBT helium measure, with half the past error, sharpens the test. The atlas serves models that tweak physics at the MeV scale.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Anne-Katherine Burns |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 106127 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.22414
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Inside the Black Box of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis: Parameter Sensitivity Studies in Light of new LBT Data Anne-Katherine Burns Abstract In this study we present a comprehensive sensitivity atlas for Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) in which we quantify the dependence of the primordial abundances of helium-4, deuterium, and lithium-7 as well as N eff N_{\rm{eff}} on variations in 14 fundamental particle physics and cosmological parameters and 63 thermonuclear reaction rates. We use the publicly available BBN code PRyMordial to compute each sensitivity using two nuclear reaction rate compilations and two weak-rate normalization schemes, and provide a model independent reference applicable to Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) models in which MeV scale physics is modified. In addition, we rank each parameter’s contribution to the theoretical uncertainty budget. We compare our predictions against the latest observational determinations of the primordial abundances, including a recent LBT measurement of the helium-4 abundance 8 which roughly halves the observational uncertainty relative to previous determinations. We present these results both fixing Δ N eff \Delta N_{\rm eff} at its Standard Model (SM) value, and allowing it to be a free parameter using the latest uncertainty from the combined CMB+BAO+BBN 2026 value 33 . When Δ N eff \Delta N_{\rm eff} is allowed to be a free parameter, it dominates the theoretical uncertainty of the helium-4 abundance, highlighting the importance of upcoming observations from the Simons Observatory 2 . As illustrative applications, we examine the deuterium tension and the lithium problem in light of our sensitivity analysis. The full set of numerical results and figures is publicly available on GitHub bbn-sensitivity-atlas . I Introduction The prediction of the light-element abundances produced during Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) 61 is one of the most quantitatively successful achievements of modern cosmology. The primordial abundances of helium-4 ( Y_{p} ) and deuterium ( D/H ) have been measured to percent-level precision, and corresponding theoretical predictions are comparably precise 8 ; 37 ; 51 . The theoretical uncertainty on the helium-4 prediction is roughly two orders of magnitude smaller than the current observational error, while that for deuterium is at the percent level 8 ; 56 . Today, BBN plays an important role in modern cosmology, serving both as a consistency check of Standard Model (SM) physics, nuclear physics inputs, and cosmological parameters, and as a constraint on beyond the SM scenarios that alter the radiation content, neutrino properties, or expansion rate, or that introduces late-time particle decays or energy injection 18 . These constraints are complementary to those from the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and Large Scale Structure (LSS): BBN probes MeV-scale physics at early times, whereas the CMB and LSS constrain related parameters at lower energies and later epochs. Among the parameters connecting these probes, the effective number of relativistic neutrino species, N_{\rm eff} , is particularly impactful. In the Standard Model, N_{\rm eff} = 3.044, accounting for three active neutrino species with small corrections from non-instantaneous neutrino decoupling from the thermal bath. Deviations from this value, parametrized by \Delta N_{\rm eff} , arise in a variety of BSM scenarios involving light degrees of freedom that contribute to the total radiation energy density during or after neutrino decoupling. Because N_{\rm eff} directly affects the expansion rate of the universe during BBN, even modest deviations propagate strongly into the predicted helium-4 abundance. The recent combined CMB+BAO+BBN determination of N_{\rm eff}=2.990\pm 0.070 33 has nearly halved the previous uncertainty, making it timely to assess how this improved constraint reshapes the BBN error budget. Because the helium-4 and deuterium abundances have been so precisely measured, small shifts in their predicted values are meaningful. As observational uncertainties improve, theoretical uncertainties and modeling choices may become a limiting factor and must be quantified clearly. Currently, there exists extensive literature exploring the impact of varying physics inputs on BBN 18 ; 10 ; 12 ; 13 ; 43 ; 52 ; 32 ; 9 ; 31 ; 24 ; 65 . However, it is not straightforward to compare the sensitivity of the predicted abundances to different parameters across existing studies, since those analyses rely on different compilations of empirical nuclear reaction-rate data, different implementations of QED plasma and weak-rate corrections, different likelihood choices and datasets, and different numerical codes. To address this, we present a single-code sensitivity atlas that studies 77 parameters independently within a uniform framework, repeated across two weak-rate normalization schemes and two nuclear rate compilations. In addition, we provide the explicit ranking of contributions to the theoretical uncertainty from these parameters. Finally, we present these results in light of the most recent data, particularly highlighting the determination of the helium-4 abundance from the LBT 8 . The goal of this paper is to provide a unified atlas of parameter response functions and sensitivities for the full set of inputs relevant to the BBN calculation, using the code PRyMordial . To do this we will use the latest observations of helium-4, deuterium, lithium-7, and N_{\rm{eff}} . While the so-called Lithium-Problem persists, we include it in our analysis in order to quantify the way in which parameter variation affects the predicted value. We include these results not as proposed solutions, but rather as a starting point for future work. Tables 2 , 3 , 4 , and 5 present sensitivity matrices for the BBN observables considered here. These tables clearly identify which parameters dominate the local response of each observable, allowing rapid estimates of the induced changes in the predicted abundances. These tables can be easily used as a diagnostic tool in searches for new physics. In scenarios where one or more parameters take values in the early universe that differ from their present-day determinations, the response functions presented here provide a simple first estimate of how the primordial abundances are shifted, and therefore which directions in parameter space are most promising to explore. Although our sensitivities are computed locally about fiducial SM values, they offer a useful guide for identifying early-universe modifications that could motivate a full non-linear analysis. In addition, we present ranked uncertainty budgets clearly showing current limitations on BBN predictions. We construct these budgets by propagating the uncertainties in the input quantities to the predicted abundances. For each observable, Tables 7 , 8 , 10 , and 11 provide an ordered list of the parameters that most strongly contribute to the theoretical error for each observable. This allows us to identify which future measurements could most effectively sharpen BBN predictions. All of these results will be presented for two different compilations of nuclear reaction rates, allowing us to identify compilation-dependent systematics. This shows us which sensitivities are robust, and which are dependent on the chosen nuclear reaction rate set. These results are particularly timely in light of the newly published helium data from the Large Binocular Telescope (LBT) 8 , discussed in detail in Section II.1 . As observational data continue to improve, a standardized framework for interpreting parameter sensitivity and theoretical uncertainty will become increasingly important. This paper is organized as follows. In Section II , we review the observational inputs adopted in this work, including the current determinations of the primordial abundances of helium-4, deuterium, and lithium-7, as well as the latest constraint on N_{\rm{eff}} . Section