Stable black hole solutions with cosmological hair

Laurens Smulders, Johannes Noller · 2026

Read Stable black hole solutions with cosmological hair by Laurens Smulders, Johannes Noller (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-22398.txt.

Introduction

Smulders and Noller find stable black hole solutions that carry cosmological hair. Dynamic dark energy adds a time-based field to the universe. A black hole inside that setting feels the field, not just its own mass and spin. Known hairy solutions of this kind were unstable. The authors work through the cubic Galileon as a test case. They derive solutions that behave well at both long and short range. The hair near the hole encodes data about the wider cosmos.

Catalog record

CREATORLaurens Smulders, Johannes Noller
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE146263
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.22398

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Stable black hole solutions with cosmological hair Laurens Smulders, Johannes Noller Abstract Dynamical dark energy theories generically introduce a time-dependent field that causes the accelerated expansion of the Universe on large scales. When embedding black hole solutions in such a cosmological spacetime, this time dependence naturally gives rise to cosmological hair, i.e. the local black hole physics is no longer controlled by just the mass and spin of the black hole, but also impacted by the dark energy field. However, known such solutions are unstable. Focusing on the cubic Galileon as a concrete and illustrative example, we discuss the restrictions imposed on physical solutions by their regularity and stability in detail. We explicitly derive regular and stable solutions, that both recover the desired cosmological long-range behaviour and give rise to well-behaved short-range dynamics around black holes. We show how the nature of the scalar hair around these local black hole solutions encodes cosmological information, highlighting novel and tantalising prospects of directly probing cosmological dynamics with black hole observations. I Introduction While no-hair theorems have a long history 46 ; 23 ; 15 ; 78 ; 13 ; 76 ; 16 ; 44 ; 85 ; 22 ; 92 ; 61 , they can be violated. Where in General Relativity (GR) the phenomenology associated with black holes is controlled by at most three parameters – mass, spin and charge – in theories introducing novel gravitational physics, additional parameters, i.e. ‘hair’, can control the dynamics. This novel gravitational physics typically arises in the form of additional fields coupling to the usual tensorial degrees of freedom of GR. Scalar-tensor theories, where an additional scalar degree of freedom is introduced, are a minimal modification in this sense and have therefore unsurprisingly been a workhorse for understanding beyond-GR black hole solutions. Cosmology provides some of the most compelling theoretical and observational clues suggesting that physics beyond GR – or, in a cosmological context, beyond \Lambda{} CDM – may be present. In particular, the presence of dynamical dark energy, i.e. dark energy different from a pure cosmological constant \Lambda , would generically introduce new degrees of freedom with non-trivial time dependence and many candidate scalar-tensor theories, where the scalar corresponds to dynamical dark energy, exist – see 26 ; 25 ; 2 ; 48 ; 57 ; 56 for reviews. Unlike for static scalar profiles, for which there are strong no-hair theorems even for scalar-tensor theories 16 ; 44 ; 85 ; 22 ; 92 ; 61 , such time-dependent degrees of freedom (whether dark energy-related or not) are known to generically give rise to hairy solutions, see e.g. 47 ; 5 . However, while several such hairy solutions are known to exist at the background level, where the stability of such known black hole solutions (and hence the behaviour of perturbations around known background solutions) has been fully investigated, they have been found to be unstable, with the instability typically associated with even parity modes in black hole perturbation theory 5 ; 54 ; 9 ; 17 ; 62 ; 24 ; 34 ; 86 ; 50 ; 87 . 1 1 1 Note that there exist scalar-tensor black hole solutions where only some modes have been investigated and found to be stable, e.g. the solution found in 10 was shown to be stable for odd parity modes in 82 , but has yet to be investigated for even parity modes. In this context, a key challenge is therefore to establish whether a stable black hole solution in such scalar-tensor theories can be identified, which is embedded in a cosmological spacetime whose expansion is accelerated by dynamical dark energy as described by the scalar degree of freedom present. Or, alternatively, whether/in what sense the instability of solutions investigated until now points at an underlying no-go result. The stability of black hole solutions in the presence of timelike scalar profiles has predominantly been investigated for so-called stealth solutions, i.e. solutions where the metric background corresponds to a GR solution (e.g. a Schwarzschild-de Sitter spacetime) and the hair purely arises via the existence of a non-trivial scalar profile. Indeed, requiring the existence of such stealth solutions already places constraints on the underlying scalar-tensor theories 51 . However, the generic instabilities encountered when investigating such solutions motivate going beyond this ansatz and exploring theories where also the metric solution is deformed away from GR solutions and displays hair. In this paper we do so by investigating the cubic Galileon 70 in detail, for which the existence of non-GR black hole solutions is known 5 ; 4 . In this paper we discuss challenges in constructing such regular solutions, building on the analysis of 7 , as well as the stability properties of the solutions we find. We identify generic obstacles to finding a stable and regular solution in the context of static black hole solutions, but show how these can be evaded as well. In particular, we explicitly derive novel, stable and regular solutions that are quasi-stationary (i.e. not static, but slowly varying). Outline : The paper is organised as follows. In section II we review the cubic Galileon and the cosmological/long-range limit of static black hole solutions in this theory. In section III we then derive approximate analytical short-range solutions for such black holes, discuss what the branching structure of the general solution implies for how short- and long-range solutions can be connected, and then construct full numerical solutions across the full range of scales. Black hole perturbations around these solutions are then discussed in section IV , where we carry out a detailed stability analysis for the identified solutions. We find that solutions with the desired cosmological long-range behaviour generically display instabilities in the scalar field around the short-range black hole solution. In section V we therefore relax the initial assumption of a purely static black hole solution and allow the introduction of a mild time dependence, arguably a rather natural extension given the scalar background already displays time dependence. We repeat the analysis of the previous sections and show that stable and regular solutions with the desired cosmological long-range behaviour exist in this setup, therefore identifying a candidate dark energy theory (the cubic Galileon) with a well-behaved black hole solution. We finally conclude in section VI before collecting additional relevant details in the appendices. Throughout we work in natural units, where c=\hbar=1 . II Black Holes in a Cubic Galileon Universe: The cosmological limit Galileon scalar-tensor theories 70 have been one of the primary workhorses in improving our understanding of scalar-tensor theories in both cosmological and strong gravity regimes. They capture some of the essential features of broad classes of scalar-tensor theories (e.g. of the Horndeski type 43 ; 35 ), possessing non-linear interactions that give rise to self-accelerating solutions on larger scales 80 ; 29 as well as a screening mechanism on smaller scales 70 ; 21 ; 6 . In addition, the shift symmetry these models come endowed with protects them from radiative corrections – see 58 ; 71 ; 33 ; 20 ; 19 ; 32 ; 74 and also 31 ; 38 ; 79 ; 72 ; 42 ; 41 ; 39 for recent extensions of these arguments (also in other

Read the complete text