Mainly on the Plane: Observing the Extended, Ionized Disks of Milky Way Analogs in IllustrisTNG Astropy ( 3 ) , cloudy ( 33 ) , roco ( 109 ) , trident ( 58 )
Michael Messere, Kirill Tchernyshyov, Mary E. Putman, Greg L. Bryan, Jessica K. Werk, Yong Zheng, David Schiminovich · 2026
Read Mainly on the Plane: Observing the Extended, Ionized Disks of Milky Way Analogs in IllustrisTNG Astropy ( 3 ) , cloudy ( 33 ) , roco ( 109 ) , trident ( 58 ) by Michael Messere, Kirill Tchernyshyov, Mary E. Putman, Greg L. Bryan, Jessica K. Werk, Yong Zheng, David Schiminovich (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-22257.txt.
Introduction
Messere and co-authors test whether gas around Milky Way-like galaxies sits in an extended disk. They study ion distributions in Milky Way analogs from the IllustrisTNG simulation. For each ion, they measure alignment with the disk and the share of absorption matching rotation. Magnesium II aligns best: 63% of its mass follows the disk's spin axis. Oxygen VI aligns least, at 35%. A mock survey finds corotation shares near 80% for MgII and 60% for OVI. The pattern supports a disk-like, corotating gas structure.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Michael Messere, Kirill Tchernyshyov, Mary E. Putman, Greg L. Bryan, Jessica K. Werk, Yong Zheng, David Schiminovich |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 104688 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.22257
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Mainly on the Plane: Observing the Extended, Ionized Disks of Milky Way Analogs in IllustrisTNG Astropy ( 3 ) , cloudy ( 33 ) , roco ( 109 ) , trident ( 58 ) Michael Messere, Kirill Tchernyshyov, Mary E. Putman, Greg L. Bryan, Jessica K. Werk, Yong Zheng, David Schiminovich Abstract This paper explores the extent to which the circumgalactic medium (CGM) of Milky Way-like galaxies is located in an extended, ionized, disklike structure. To test this hypothesis, we analyze the spatial and kinematic distributions of different ion species within a sample of MW-like systems in IllustrisTNG. We model commonly observed ions (H i , Mg ii , Si iv , C iv , and O vi ) and calculate (1) their angular momentum misalignment from the star-forming disk ( θ \theta ) and (2) the fraction of absorption consistent with galaxy rotation ( f EWcorot f_{\mathrm{EWcorot}} ). We find that 63% of Mg ii , 45% of Si iv , 38% of C iv , and 35% of O vi mass along the major axis have kinematics aligned with the galaxy angular momentum axis. We extend this to a mock absorption line survey and quantify f EWcorot f_{\mathrm{EWcorot}} . We find that f EWcorot f_{\mathrm{EWcorot}} (Mg ii ) ∼ 80 % \sim 80\% and f EWcorot f_{\mathrm{EWcorot}} (O vi ) ∼ 60 % \sim 60\% at ∼ 0.5 R 200 c \sim 0.5\ \mathrm{R_{200c}} , in agreement with recent observational work. We find that in the typical MW analog, there is evidence of cool-warm material in an extended, corotating structure, regardless of whether the angular momentum or observational definition is used. Hence, we expect that the typical MW CGM, especially in the low ions, should be mainly on the plane. I Introduction The idea of a complex, multi-phase medium surrounding the interstellar medium (ISM), often referred to as the circumgalactic medium (CGM), can be traced to the midtwentieth century when a diffuse, hot corona surrounding our Milky Way (MW) was first proposed ( 112 ) . As Lyman Spitzer pointed out, it seems as though an ionized medium composed of cool, warm, and hot components \emph{should} be everywhere we point our instruments. It was subsequently proposed that nearly all absorption lines in external, normal galaxies are the result of a similar extended, gaseous halo ( 4 ) . However, it wasn’t until the launch of the \emph{HubbleSpaceTelescope} (HST) ( 72 ; 18 ) and its Cosmic Origins Spectrograph (COS) ( 46 ; 122 ; 124 ; 131 ; 13 ; 132 ; 130 ; 12 ) that the CGM could be explored in detail from an observational point-of-view, especially the spatial and kinematic extent of the gas. The radial extent of the gaseous disk has been a long-standing question, especially as it relates to how gas accretes onto a galaxy ( 99 ; 40 ) . Over the past decade, there has been mounting evidence for an extended rotating disk in external, edge-on L ∗ galaxies. This has been explored in emission, connecting H i , H \alpha , and the metagalactic UV background ( 75 ; 7 ; 1 ; 43 ; 8 ) . In addition, there has been extensive absorption work, where individual sightlines (e.g., Mg ii , O vi ) have been used to probe the spatial distribution and kinematics of the ionized CGM ( 11 ; 60 ; 10 ; 61 ; 50 ; 76 ; 42 ; 80 ; 81 ; 51 ; 62 ) . For example, a sample of galaxy–quasar pairs from 50 showed evidence of corotating Mg ii out to nearly 100 kpc ( \sim 0.5\ \mathrm{R_{vir}} ) along the midplane. More recently, 51 found that O vi is more likely to co-rotate with the disk when there is a low-ion match (e.g., Mg ii ), suggesting that the low and high ions are co-spatial. 81 (see also 80 ; 62 ) calculated the absorption equivalent width co-rotation fraction ( f_{\mathrm{EWcorot}} ), defined as the fraction of absorption consistent with galaxy rotation. They found evidence for stronger co-rotation in lower ionization gas and found that highly corotating O vi is found preferentially along the major axis. Together, this work has demonstrated that there is a substantial amount of ionized gas out to large radii with evidence of co-rotation. However, the single sightline approach of absorption line spectroscopy has made it difficult to develop a complete picture of this extended, corotating disk and its connection to the inner, star-forming disk is still unclear. In order to aid in the interpretation of these findings, astronomers have turned to the recent advancement in computation, which has enabled the detailed study of the CGM at various scales: from the interaction between the cold and hot phase at the parsec level ( 77 ; 48 ; 35 ) to large-scale cosmological simulations that explore different star-formation and feedback models ( 55 ; 102 ; 21 ; 121 ; 83 ; 87 ; 25 ; 111 ; 125 ) . From the simulation perspective, there has been considerable interest in modeling the CGM and the connection between gas accretion, feedback, and disk-formation ( 56 ; 38 ; 37 ; 39 ; 74 ; 82 ; 143 ; 57 ; 87 ; 27 ; 52 , e.g., ) . Cosmological simulations have shown that cold-mode gas accretion aids in disk-formation and is often corotating with the disk ( 28 ; 118 ; 117 ) . Efforts to bridge simulation and observation have included studying the angular momentum of cold gas ( 27 ) and mock absorption-line studies ( 53 ; 26 ) , both of which suggest that corotating cold gas along the midplane can extend well beyond the optical and emission line-detected disk – consistent with observations. Despite this extensive work looking outside the MW, recent observational work has ironically suggested that we don’t fully understand our own backyard – the same backyard that Lyman Spitzer pointed out. In particular, there is recent observational evidence that our CGM is a possible anomaly compared to the massive and extensive CGM of L ∗ galaxies ( 92 ; 143 ; 137 ; 136 ) . Through the use of both distant quasars and bright halo stars at high Galactic latitude, it has been shown there is a substantial amount of ionized material within 10 kpc of the mid-plane ( 104 ; 100 ; 101 ; 73 ; 133 ) . There has also been recent discussion about the extent of this gas beyond 10 kpc, especially since the low-velocity halo gas blends with the inner disk gas ( 144 ) . The QuaStar Survey ( 6 ) demonstrated that a majority of the ionized gas (as traced using C iv ) is in fact confined within a vertical distance of \sim 10 kpc from the Galactic midplane. These results lend credence to the hypothesis that the Milky Way harbors anomalously low levels of ionized gas compared to observations of external galaxies (see their Figure 6). Although it is possible that the MW-CGM is different, it is important to consider the alternative possibility that a significant component of the ionized gas resides in an extended, rotating