Special cases of the discretization principle via permutability

Joseph Cho, Mason Pember, Wayne Rossman · 2026

Read Special cases of the discretization principle via permutability by Joseph Cho, Mason Pember, Wayne Rossman (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-21870.txt.

Introduction

Cho and co-authors prove special cases of the discretization principle for surfaces, using permutability of transformations. The discretization principle asks when a smooth surface theory has a faithful discrete twin. Their route starts with smooth surfaces that carry special traits. When the transformations of such a surface permute with each other, that structure carries over to a discrete version. The resulting discrete surfaces keep analogues of the same traits as the smooth originals. The argument is short and general, tying the discrete theory back to classical transformation geometry.

Catalog record

CREATORJoseph Cho, Mason Pember, Wayne Rossman
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27335
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.21870

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Special cases of the discretization principle via permutability Joseph Cho, Mason Pember, Wayne Rossman Abstract . We show how permutability of transforms of smooth surfaces with particular characteristics leads to discrete surfaces with discrete analogues of the same characteristics. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary: 53A70 1. Introduction In this brief note, we prove a result (Theorem 2.10 ) that answers a query which arose during discussions at the July 2025 MATRIX meeting “Integrable Geometry: Smooth and Discrete” in Creswick, Australia. Many classes of surfaces have geometric characterizations, including special coordinate properties or curvature properties, that admit a description using integrable systems. The viewpoint of discrete differential geometry often hovers around the definition of integrable-systems-based discrete versions of these surfaces, reflecting the various coordinate and curvature properties. Such discretization has been carried out in a wide variety of cases, including, for example, pseudospherical surfaces [ 5 ] , constant mean curvature surfaces [ 27 ] , isothermic surfaces [ 4 ] , or \Omega -surfaces [ 8 ] . In this note, we restrict to the case of discrete isothermic surfaces arising from the permutability of Darboux transformations [ 2 ] of smooth isothermic surfaces so that they are circular nets . (Other discretizations of isothermic surfaces include S -isothermic [ 6 ] , S -conical [ 3 ] , or edge-constraint nets [ 30 ] , for example.) For smooth surfaces, the integrable systems properties lead to a transformation theory for the surfaces, and the permutability of these transforms follows. This provides grids of quadrilaterals called Bianchi quadrilaterals that can be used to construct discrete surfaces, by taking a single point in the starting surface together with its images in the transforms. The principle of finding discrete analogues of various smooth surface classes in the permutability of transformations has led to the definition of many discrete surfaces. We note here that this principle applies beyond surface theory; in fact, the principle of using transformation and permutability as a semi-discrete or discrete analogue originated in the field of integrable systems (see, for example, [ 32 ] or [ 34 ] ). In more detail, let f_{0,0}\mathrel{\mathop{\ordinarycolon}}\Sigma^{2}\to M be a map whose image is an initial surface (hence the subscript 0,0 ) in some space form M with some particular property \mathcal{P} . As we are looking at local properties of surfaces, assume \Sigma^{2} is simply-connected. Suppose there is a transformation of a certain type \mathcal{T} that preserves property \mathcal{P} , which we apply separately to produce two transformed property \mathcal{P} surfaces f_{1,0} and f_{0,1} of f_{0,0} . Assume permutability holds, which means there is a unique fourth property \mathcal{P} surface f_{1,1} that is simultaneously a type \mathcal{T} transform of both f_{1,0} and f_{0,1} . Note that all four of these surfaces are in M with common domain \Sigma^{2} . We could repeat this process, for example, by using a type \mathcal{T} transform of f_{1,0} to produce a property \mathcal{P} surface f_{2,0} , and permutability then gives us a property \mathcal{P} transform f_{2,1} simultaneously of both f_{2,0} and f_{1,1} . Continuing in this way, we can choose f_{m,0} (integers m\geq 0 ) and f_{0,n} ( n\geq 0 ), and all other f_{m,n} ( m,n>0 ) are determined by permutability. We then have a full grid of surfaces f_{m,n} discretely parametrized by (m,n)\in(\mathbb{Z}^{+}\cup\{0\})^{2} . See Figure 1 . Now, taking one point x in the common domain of the f_{m,n} , we have a discrete surface \{f_{m,n}(x)\}_{m,n\geq 0} parametrized by m,n . We could ask if this discrete surface will have a discrete analogue of property \mathcal{P} . In many cases such as pseudospherical surfaces, isothermic surfaces, and \Omega -surfaces, the answer is yes. However, the question remains unanswered in many other cases, including the classes of constant mean curvature surfaces in space forms, linear Weingarten surfaces, Guichard surfaces, and L -isothermic surfaces. Each of the surface classes named here admits a transformation that keeps the special properties: Bianchi-Bäcklund transformation [ 1 ] , special cases of Lie-Darboux transformation [ 11 ] , Eisenhart transformation [ 25 ] , and Bianchi-Darboux transformation [ 33 ] , respectively. Our work will answer that indeed the permutability of these transformations gives rise to the discrete counterparts. However, instead of checking this relationship for each surface class named here, we will use a uniform argument stemming from the integrable reduction of the case of isothermic surfaces, where the discrete counterparts are given a well-known interpretation based on the Bianchi quadrilaterals of Darboux transformations of isothermic surfaces. The machinery that allows us to perform such integrable reduction is the following property \mathcal{P} : isothermic surfaces whose associated 1 -parameter family of flat connections admit certain polynomial conserved quantities of degree d ; otherwise said, the property \mathcal{P} is that the surfaces are special isothermic surfaces of type d [ 16 ] . In this case, type \mathcal{T} transforms will be Darboux transforms that do not increase the degree of the polynomial conserved quantities, which we will refer to as Bäcklund transforms . We will show that discrete special isothermic surfaces of type d [ 12 , 13 ] arise from the Bianchi quadrilaterals of Bäcklund transformations. Interpreting the surface classes under consideration within this framework will allow us to answer positively for each case immediately. f_{0,0} f_{0,1} f_{1,0} f_{0,2} f_{1,1} f_{2,0} f_{1,2} f_{2,1} f_{2,2}. Figure 1. Grid from permutability of transforms of smooth surfaces Acknowledgement. We thank Fran Burstall and Udo Hertrich-Jeromin for helpful discussions, and the organizers of the program “Integrable Geometry: Smooth and Discrete” held at MATRIX for the opportunity to clarify the point made here. We gratefully acknowledge the partial support from: Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (C) 23K03091) and NRF of Korea funded by MSIT (Korea-Austria Scientific and Technological Cooperation RS-2025-1435299). 2. Permutability as a bridge between smooth and discrete surfaces 2.1. Smooth surfaces For non-negative integers p and q , let us take (p+q+2) -dimensional pseudo-Euclidean space \mathbb{R}^{p+1,q+1} with (pseudo-)metric denoted by (\cdot,\cdot) , of signature (p+1,q+1) , containing a (p+q+1) -dimensional light cone \mathcal{L} . A (p+q) -dimensional (constant sectional curvature) space form M with signature (p,q) is then given by M=\{X\in\mathcal{L}\mathrel{\mathop{\ordinarycolon}}(X,\mathfrak{q})=-1\} for some nonzero vector \mathfrak{q}\in\mathbb{R}^{p+1,q+1} called the space form vector . Only the direction of X\in\mathcal{L} is needed for it to determine a point in M , and so it is convenient to projectivize \mathcal{L} to \mathbb{P}(\mathcal{L})\subset\mathbb{P}(\mathbb{R}^{p+1,q+1}) , giving us the conformal (p,q) -sphere. Consider a surface in the conformal (p,q) -sphere f\mathrel{\mathop{\ordinarycolon}}\Sigma^{2}\to\mathbb{P}(\mathcal{L}) which we also can view as a null line bundle in the trivial bundle \Sigma^{2}\times\mathbb{R}^{p+1,q+1} . A surface \mathfrak{f} in the space form M determined by the space form vector \mathfrak{q} is recovered locally from a surface f in the conformal (p,q) -sphere via \mathfrak{f}=f\cap M, wherever f is not orthogonal to \mathfrak{q} . 2.1.1. Isothermic surfaces and Darboux transformations A surface f\mathrel{\mathop{\ordinarycolon}}\Sigma^{2}\to\mathbb{P}(\mathcal{L}) is called isothermic when it admits conformal curvature line coordinates around every non-umbilical point. As we are dealing only with local theory of isothermic surfaces, we will assume throughout that f is umbilic-free on \Sigma^{2} , and admits conformal curvature line coordinates on its domain. Then a surface is isothermic exactly when there exists a \wedge^{2}\mathbb{R}^{p+1,q+1} -valued

Read the complete text