Geodesic extended modes in low magnetic shear tokamaks and stellarators

Richard Nies \aff 1,2 \corresp, Felix Parra \aff 1,2 · 2026

Read Geodesic extended modes in low magnetic shear tokamaks and stellarators by Richard Nies \aff 1,2 \corresp, Felix Parra \aff 1,2 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-21813.txt.

Introduction

Nies and Parra build a theory of extended plasma modes in fusion devices with very low magnetic shear. Standard theory treats passing electrons as instant responders. At low shear, ion-scale modes stretch far along the field, and that shortcut breaks. Their multiscale expansion of the gyrokinetic equation yields a new mode, the geodesic extended mode. It couples the slow response of both electrons and ions. Tests against gyrokinetic simulations support the theory, and they map how the mode shifts with plasma settings.

Catalog record

CREATORRichard Nies \aff 1,2 \corresp, Felix Parra \aff 1,2
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE83085
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.21813

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Geodesic extended modes in low magnetic shear tokamaks and stellarators Richard Nies \aff 1,2 \corresp, Felix Parra \aff 1,2 Abstract Theories of ion-scale microinstabilities in tokamaks and stellarators typically assume that the passing electrons respond adiabatically due to their fast propagation speed. However, when the magnetic shear becomes sufficiently small, ion-scale modes can extend far along the magnetic field and the non-adiabatic response of passing electrons becomes important. We derive a theory of extended modes at low magnetic shear through a multiscale expansion of the gyrokinetic equation. The theory elucidates the physics of the geodesic extended mode, a new type of microinstability. The new mode couples the non-adiabatic physics of both electrons and ions, unlike extended modes at magnetic shear of order unity. The theory is validated against gyrokinetic simulations and the parameter dependences of the new mode are studied. Geodesic extended modes in low magnetic shear tokamaks and stellarators 1 Introduction In tokamaks and stellarators, the large density and temperature gradients between the hot dense core and the cold dilute edge drive microinstabilities on the scale of the particles’ gyroradii. These microinstabilities give rise to turbulence which mixes the plasma, causing large heat fluxes limiting the energy confinement. The most virulent microinstabilities are typically on ion gyroradius scales, such as the ion temperature gradient (ITG) mode ( 31 ; 11 ; 23 ; 5 ; 12 ) . When considering ion-scale microinstabilities, the passing electron response is generally assumed to be adiabatic. This assumption is motivated by the fast propagation rate of electrons \omega_{{\scriptstyle\|},e}\sim v_{Te}/R parallel to the magnetic field. The typical frequency of ion-scale modes \omega\sim v_{Ti}/R is comparatively slow, as v_{Te}/v_{Ti}\sim(m_{i}/m_{e})^{1/2}\gg 1 . Here, R is the major radius of the tokamak or stellarator, taken to be the typical system scale length, and v_{T{s}}=(2T_{s}/m_{s})^{1/2} is the thermal speed of particles of species {s} with temperature T_{s} and mass m_{s} . Nonwithstanding the fast electron propagation, the non-adiabatic response of trapped electrons can become important even for ion-scale modes. Electrons trapped in regions of small magnetic field strength cannot respond adiabatically; this non-adiabatic trapped electron response can substantially modify the growth rate of ITG modes ( 13 , see e.g.) and give rise to trapped electron modes (TEMs) ( 24 ; 30 ) . Furthermore, the non-adiabatic response of passing electrons can also affect ion-scale modes. The non-adiabatic passing electron response typically leads to modes which extend far along the magnetic field line. Observations of such extended modes go back to early gyrokinetic simulations including kinetic electrons ( 19 ) and they have since been the object of various numerical studies ( 13 ; 4 ; 1 ; 7 ; 8 ) . By performing a multiscale expansion of the gyrokinetic system of equations in m_{e}/m_{i}\ll 1 , 21 uncovered two types of electrostatic modes: the ‘small electron tail modes’ and the ‘dominant electron tail modes’, whose mode frequencies are determined by non-adiabatic ion physics and by non-adiabatic electron physics, respectively. A magnetic shear \hat{s}\sim 1 was assumed in the expansion of 21 , such that the non-adiabatic ion response vanishes for \theta\gg 1 due to finite Larmor radius (FLR) effects. Here, \theta is the poloidal angle and will be used throughout this work as a parallel coordinate. Because of the ion FLR stabilisation, the ‘small electron tail modes’ are peaked at \theta\sim 1 and the non-adiabatic passing electron response only modifies the decay of the mode eigenfunction at \theta\gg 1 . In contrast, the eigenfunctions of the ‘dominant electron tail modes’ are extended in \theta and the non-adiabatic ion response only causes a small change to the eigenfunction at \theta\sim 1 . In this work, we present a theory of extended modes for small values of the magnetic shear \hat{s}\sim(m_{e}/m_{i})^{1/2} . With this ordering of \hat{s} , the ion FLR effects become substantial only for large \theta\sim(m_{i}/m_{e})^{1/2} , the typical distance of electron propagation within a mode period \omega^{-1}\sim R/v_{Ti} . As a result, the mode frequency and eigenfunction are generally determined by non-adiabatic physics of both the electrons and the ions, unlike for the \hat{s}\sim 1 case. Notably, small values of the magnetic shear allow for a new type of microinstability. The new mode is prominent in the precise quasisymmetric stellarators of 25 (see Appendix A ). The mode is also a salient feature of tokamak simulations at small magnetic shear, where it was called a ‘ k_{z}\approx 0 ’ toroidal ITG mode ( 34 ; 36 ) . Henceforth, we call the new mode a geodesic extended mode (GEM), due to its connection with geodesic acoustic mode physics (see Section 4 ). In Figure 1 , we show representative gyrokinetic simulations exhibiting GEMs. The GEMs are indeed very extended compared with modes of a larger magnetic shear case, see Figure 1(b) . Furthermore, compared to the localised modes found at larger magnetic shear \hat{s}\approx 0.8 , the GEMs oscillate rapidly in time and have a larger growth rate at small binormal wavenumbers. (a) Growth rate (top) and real frequency (bottom) as a function of the binormal wavenumber k_{y}\rho_{i} . (b) Potential fluctuation ballooning structure along the magnetic field for k_{y}\rho_{i}=0.1 . Figure 1 : Complex frequency (a) and eigenmode structure for k_{y}\rho_{i}=0.1 (b) at small and large magnetic shear, \hat{s}=0.01 and \hat{s}=0.8 . The data is obtained from gyrokinetic simulations using the stella code ( 2 ) for a tokamak with circular cross-section. The safety factor is q=2.38 , the electron-to-ion mass ratio is m_{e}/m_{i}=1/1836 , and a pure ion temperature gradient drive is considered, a/L_{Ti}=4 and {a/L_{Te}=a/L_{n}=0} . All other parameters are identical to those presented in Section 3.1 . The effects of low magnetic shear values on non-adiabatic passing electron physics has been studied in a series of recent papers by 34 ; 36 ; 35 ; 37 . Small values of magnetic shear are a common occurrence in stellarator magnetic fields, for example in stellarators optimised for quasisymmetry ( 25 ; 28 ; 6 ) . In tokamaks, small magnetic shear values are especially relevant for reverse-shear operating scenarios, where the safety factor has a minimum away from the magnetic axis (in common tokamak operating scenarios, the safety factor monotonically increases from the core to the edge). In some reverse-shear discharges, large internal transport barriers were observed ( 26 ; 32 ; 15 , see e.g.) , with greatly improved plasma confinement. It has been suggested by 37 that these transport barriers arise due to the flattening of the safety factor profile caused by the self-interaction of extended modes, further motivating the study of the GEMs. This paper is structured as follows. We first present the theory of extended modes at small magnetic shear in Section 2 . The theory is then validated against gyrokinetic simulations in Section 3 , which will also reveal the parametric dependences of the GEMs. We then elucidate the physics of the GEMs in Section 4 . We conclude and discuss our results in Section 5 . Finally, we show in Appendix A that the GEMs are important to understand linear and nonlinear gyrokinetic simulations in the precise quasi-axisymmetric stellarator of 25 . 2 Theory of extended modes In Section 2.1 , we review the theory of

Read the complete text