Battery health reporting fails independent validation across manufacturers

Jeongju Park, Kyungkak Kim, Seungho Geum, Junhyung Lee, Hyeongyu Son, Sekyung Han, [6pt] Department of Electrical Engineering, Kyungpook National University,Daegu, Republic of Korea, [6pt] Correspondence: [email protected] · 2026

Read Battery health reporting fails independent validation across manufacturers by Jeongju Park, Kyungkak Kim, Seungho Geum, Junhyung Lee, Hyeongyu Son, Sekyung Han, [6pt] Department of Electrical Engineering, Kyungpook National University,Daegu, Republic of Korea, [6pt] Correspondence: [email protected] (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-21592.txt.

Introduction

Park and co-authors test whether electric vehicle battery health reports can be trusted. State-of-health figures from on-board management systems are what owners and regulators see, but nobody had checked them across brands. Studying 1,114 vehicles from five manufacturers over 375 days, they found real capacity gaps of 12 to 25 percent within single models. The reported health scores barely tracked those gaps, and 384 vehicles exposed no score at all. A marker based on partial charging windows classified degradation far better in lab checks.

Catalog record

CREATORJeongju Park, Kyungkak Kim, Seungho Geum, Junhyung Lee, Hyeongyu Son, Sekyung Han, [6pt] Department of Electrical Engineering, Kyungpook National University,Daegu, Republic of Korea, [6pt] Correspondence: [email protected]
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61654
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.21592

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Battery health reporting fails independent validation across manufacturers Jeongju Park, Kyungkak Kim, Seungho Geum, Junhyung Lee, Hyeongyu Son, Sekyung Han, [6pt] Department of Electrical Engineering, Kyungpook National University,Daegu, Republic of Korea, [6pt] Correspondence: [email protected] Abstract Battery state-of-health (SOH) reported by on-board battery management systems (BMS) is the primary metric available to electric vehicle (EV) owners and regulators, yet no study has validated its reliability across manufacturers against independent measurements. Here we show, through an epidemiological study of 1,114 EVs spanning five manufacturers and 375 days, that battery health reporting is fundamentally unreliable: real capacity differences of 12–25% exist within every model, but BMS SOH fails to track them, with correlations ranging from \rho=0.10 (non-significant) to \rho=0.62 only under restrictive filtering, while 384 vehicles do not expose SOH at all. A manufacturer-independent electrochemical marker achieves 74–89% degradation classification accuracy across all platforms without requiring BMS data, and a controlled laboratory validation on cells identical to those in the fleet confirms that partial-voltage-window charge measurements track reference capacity with \rho>0.80 across all 60 voltage windows ( \textit{p}<0.001 ). These findings reveal a structural information asymmetry with direct implications for the EU Battery Regulation’s 2027 SOH transparency mandate, California’s Advanced Clean Cars (ACC) II durability requirements, warranty enforcement, used-vehicle valuation, right-to-repair legislation, and second-life battery markets. The global electric vehicle (EV) fleet has grown rapidly, with over 40 million battery EVs on roads worldwide as of 2024 and annual sales exceeding 17 million units 1 ; 2 . As lithium-ion battery technology matures and costs decline 3 , a central concern for EV owners, fleet operators, and the used-car market is battery degradation—the gradual loss of capacity and power capability that directly affects vehicle range and resale value 4 . Battery state-of-health (SOH), typically reported as a percentage of original capacity, is the primary metric used by consumers and regulators to assess battery condition 5 . However, SOH as reported by on-board battery management systems (BMS) relies on proprietary algorithms that vary across manufacturers and are not publicly documented 6 ; 7 . The lack of standardization means that “SOH = 95%” from one manufacturer may represent a fundamentally different battery condition than the same value from another. This opacity creates a critical information asymmetry—directly analogous to Akerlof’s “market for lemons” 8 —where the entity responsible for warranty liability is simultaneously the sole arbiter of when that liability is triggered. Battery warranty claims, which commit manufacturers to replace or repair batteries that fall below a specified SOH threshold (typically 70–80%) 9 ; 10 , depend entirely on the manufacturer’s own SOH calculation. The emerging second-life battery market further exacerbates this problem, as repurposing decisions depend critically on accurate health assessment 11 ; 12 . Laboratory studies have characterized degradation mechanisms including lithium inventory loss, solid-electrolyte interphase (SEI) growth, and cathode structural changes 13 ; 14 , while production-induced cell-to-cell variation 15 and non-linear aging “knees” 16 further complicate health assessment. Fleet-scale analyses have reported aggregate trends using BMS SOH at face value 17 ; 18 ; 19 , and data-driven approaches have demonstrated cycle life prediction 20 ; 21 and SOH estimation from laboratory data 22 ; 23 ; 24 . However, no study has quantified cross-manufacturer SOH reliability through a systematic audit using a single, independent measurement protocol applied to a large real-world fleet. This question has added urgency: the EU Battery Regulation 9 mandates SOH transparency from 2027, and California’s Advanced Clean Cars (ACC) II program 10 requires minimum battery durability guarantees—yet both frameworks implicitly assume that reported SOH is meaningful, an assumption our data challenge directly. Our study fills this gap by providing the first independent, cross-manufacturer validation of BMS SOH against a manufacturer-independent benchmark in an operational fleet of over 1,100 vehicles. Here we present a cross-manufacturer epidemiological study of 1,114 EVs from Hyundai, Kia, Genesis, Audi, and Volkswagen using continuous telematics data spanning approximately 12 months (375 days). We develop a BMS-independent capacity measurement protocol based on constant-current (CC) charging segments and validate its consistency across voltage windows. By comparing these independent measurements with BMS-reported SOH, we reveal that SOH reliability is profoundly model-dependent—ranging from complete non-availability to moderate correlation under controlled conditions—and validate universal, BMS-independent health indicators that work across all platforms. Our principal contributions are threefold: (1) the first independent, cross-manufacturer audit of BMS SOH reliability against a single measurement protocol; (2) quantification of the resulting information asymmetry and its implications for warranty and resale markets; and (3) field validation—across 1,114 vehicles and five battery architectures—that established laboratory markers and usage-pattern analysis can serve as manufacturer-independent health indicators without requiring BMS data. Results Capacity heterogeneity within models To establish that real capacity differences exist between vehicles of the same model, we identified CC slow charging sessions from the telematics data and measured the accumulated charge (dQ) across standardized voltage windows (Fig. 2 b)—an approach grounded in differential capacity analysis principles 25 ; 26 . Sessions were selected using physics-validated BMS charging state flags (Precision = 88%, Recall = 91% against a flag-free physics-only detector; see Methods). We imposed strict controls: current coefficient of variation (CV) <25\% , temperature range 10–35°C, edge trimming of 3 minutes to exclude transients, and voltage window boundaries aligned to measurement quantization steps. Pack voltage measurement resolution varies across platforms: E-GMP 192S (97.5 mV pack, 0.51 mV/cell), E-GMP 180S ( \sim 97.5 mV pack, 0.54 mV/cell), Commercial 90S (102.5 mV, 1.14 mV/cell), Niro/Kona 98S (102.5 mV, 1.05 mV/cell), and MEB 96S (252.5 mV, 2.63 mV/cell). Such controlled conditions are essential because charging behavior strongly influences degradation rate estimates 27 ; 28 . Under these controlled conditions, significant inter-vehicle capacity heterogeneity emerged across all model platforms (Fig. 1 a,b; Table 1 ). The Electric-Global Modular Platform (E-GMP) comprises two cell configurations in our dataset: the 192-series (E-GMP 192S; n=59 with CC sessions) showed a 16.4% dQ gap between the highest and lowest usage quartiles ( \textit{p}=0.0002 ). Commercial vehicles (Porter/Bongo, n=52 ) exhibited the largest gap at 24.7% ( \textit{p}=0.0003 ). Even the narrowest-range platform, E-GMP 180S ( n=36 ), showed a 12.2% gap ( \textit{p}=0.014 ). The Modular Electric Drive (MEB) platform (Audi Q4 / VW ID.4, n=152 ) displayed a dQ coefficient of variation of 10.3%. Methodological validation We validated the dQ methodology through three independent approaches. Multi-window consistency (Fig. 2 a). For each vehicle pair, we computed the dQ ratio across four non-overlapping 0.1 V/cell voltage windows (W1: 3.50–3.60 V, W2: 3.60–3.70 V, W3: 3.70–3.80 V, W4: 3.80–3.90 V). If dQ reflects true capacity, the ratio between any two vehicles should remain constant regardless of the voltage window examined. The median pairwise ratio CV was 4.5% for E-GMP (57% of pairs below 5%), 4.3% for E-GMP 180S (59% below 5%), 4.8% for Commercial (52% below 5%), and 7.1% for Niro/Kona (31% below 5%), confirming that dQ differences represent genuine capacity differences rather than measurement artifacts (Fig. 2 a). The 5% threshold corresponds approximately to the intra-vehicle measurement CV (5–7%), below which pairwise ratio variation is attributable to measurement noise rather than methodological inconsistency. The MEB platform showed slightly higher variability (median CV = 5.8%, 43% below 5%), which we attribute to the wider measurement quantization of its pack voltage sensor

Read the complete text