Conspiracy Frame: a Semiotically-Driven Approach for Conspiracy Theories Detection

Heidi Campana Piva, Shaina Ashraf, Maziar Kianimoghadam Jouneghani, Arianna Longo, Rossana Damiano, Lucie Flek, Marco Antonio Stranisci · 2026

Read Conspiracy Frame: a Semiotically-Driven Approach for Conspiracy Theories Detection by Heidi Campana Piva, Shaina Ashraf, Maziar Kianimoghadam Jouneghani, Arianna Longo, Rossana Damiano, Lucie Flek, Marco Antonio Stranisci (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-21368.txt.

Introduction

Campana and co-authors introduce the Conspiracy Frame, a semantic frame for detecting conspiracy theories. Conspiracy narratives are anti-authoritarian and fuel social conflict. Their frame, drawn from frame semantics and semiotics, describes the parts of such narratives in fine detail. They built the Con.Fra. data set of Telegram messages with span level annotations. They test how well language models detect conspiracy content in and out of domain. Frame injection gives no clear gain, though mapped spans reveal abstract patterns that may guide better detection.

Catalog record

CREATORHeidi Campana Piva, Shaina Ashraf, Maziar Kianimoghadam Jouneghani, Arianna Longo, Rossana Damiano, Lucie Flek, Marco Antonio Stranisci
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54824
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.21368

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Conspiracy Frame: a Semiotically-Driven Approach for Conspiracy Theories Detection Heidi Campana Piva, Shaina Ashraf, Maziar Kianimoghadam Jouneghani, Arianna Longo, Rossana Damiano, Lucie Flek, Marco Antonio Stranisci Abstract Conspiracy theories are anti-authoritarian narratives that lead to social conflict, impacting how people perceive political information. To help in understanding this issue, we introduce the Conspiracy Frame: a fine-grained semantic representation of conspiratorial narratives derived from frame-semantics and semiotics, which spawned the Con spiracy Fra mes (Con.Fra.) dataset: a corpus of Telegram messages annotated at span-level. The Conspiracy Frame and Con.Fra. dataset contribute to the implementation of a more generalizable understanding and recognition of conspiracy theories. We observe the ability of LLMs to recognize this phenomenon in-domain and out-of-domain, investigating the role that frames may have in supporting this task. Results show that, while the injection of frames in an in-context approach does not lead to clear increase of performance, it has potential; the mapping of annotated spans with FrameNet shows abstract semantic patterns (e.g., ‘Kinship’, ‘Ingest_substance’) that potentially pave the way for a more semantically- and semiotically-aware detection of conspiratorial narratives. 1 Introduction Conspiracy theories (CTs) are narratives that embody an anti-authoritarian stance and skepticism towards official discourses, leading to social discord and a fractured sense of truth 3 ; 30 ; 48 ; 21 . CTs play a significant role in the propagation of Information Disorder ( 50 ) as they shape people’s interpretation of reality 3 and drive behaviors that have serious economic and political repercussions. Implementing effective strategies to mitigate CTs’ negative impact on society is becoming a priority of many societal actors who give impulse to educational ( 29 ) and research ( 12 ) initiatives to combat them. Research in Natural Language Processing (NLP) on CTs is crucial, since it enables automatic recognition and potential countering of this phenomenon through the development of datasets ( 43 ; 42 ) and novel approaches to detect and characterize CTs ( 11 ; 46 ) . However, two main challenges need to be addressed to implement effective technologies against this phenomenon: 1 st - From a computational perspective, CTs are hard to define and, thus, to annotate. Almost all existing corpora are annotated for binary and multi-label classification, which may not be useful to distinguish CTs from other information disorders like disinformation ( 13 ) and propaganda ( 26 ) , since they do not provide information on the structure of these narratives. 2 nd - From a thematic perspective, NLP resources for this task suffer a lack of generalizability, because most of them are confined to COVID-19, vaccines, or other health-related topics and restricted to particular contents. The aim of this work is to support a more general understanding of CTs to improve automatic recognition of this phenomenon . To this extent, we introduce the Conspiracy Frame: a fine-grained semantic representation of conspiratorial narratives whose design derives from frame-semantics and semiotics ( 18 ) . The Conspiracy Frame translates the definition of CTs from semiotics ( 3 ; 34 ) into a narrative structure that involves the presence of five frame elements: plan , secret , call-to-action , in-group , and out-group . This semantic representation drove the creation of the Con spiracy Fra mes (Con.Fra.) dataset, a corpus of Telegram messages annotated at span-level according to the Conspiracy Frame. The dataset is not only conceived for the detection of CTs, but to foster a more general understanding of CTs by seeking generalizability through the consideration of structural (formal) characteristics that are intrinsic to conspiratorial narratives. Recognizing the need to assess the generalizability of CTs, Con.Fra has been created through a three-step iterative annotation process: i. annotation : we annotated 2,077 Telegram messages for CTs identification and span detection; ii. augmentation : we performed a lexical mapping of annotated spans with frames included in FrameNet ( 2 ) to observe the presence of more abstract semantic patterns emerging from conspiratorial narratives; iii. out-of-domain evaluation : we evaluated the ability of LLMs to identify CTs and detect CT spans on messages from different Telegram channels. The Conspiracy Frame and Con.Fra. dataset contribute to the implementation of more explainable and generalizable CT understanding and recognition. We exploit this novel set of resources to observe the ability of LLMs to recognize this phenomenon in-domain and out-of-domain and to study the role that frames may have in supporting this task. Results show that, while the injection of frames in an in-context approach does not lead to clear increase of performance, it has a promising role in the development of more explainable approaches to CT recognition. The mapping of annotated spans with FrameNet shows abstract semantic patterns (e.g., ‘Kinship’, ‘Ingest_substance’) that potentially pave the way for a more semantically- and semiotically-aware detection of conspiratorial narratives. The paper is structured as follows: Section 2 presents existing work on CTs in NLP and Semiotics; Section 3 describes the design of the Conspiracy Frame and the creation of the Con.Fra corpus, followed by Section 4 which details our experimental setting. Finally, Section 5 is devoted to the analysis of LLM performances on CT recognition and span detection. 2 Related Work CTs have influenced public discourse since at least the 19th century 38 , but their reach and impact have been magnified by digital technology 33 . Content-wise, conspiracy themes range from government surveillance, to corporate manipulation of scientific knowledge, to media propaganda, and to supernatural knowledge being suppressed by epistemic gatekeepers 22 . The operation of CTs is thus more dependent on a specific rhetoric that symbolically reproduces segregation than on their particular contents 7 . Because of that, CTs operate as an ideological lens 27 , meaning-making template 34 , mode of interpretation 3 or belief system 41 , shaping reality comprehension. The CT phenomenon has triggered the emergence of large datasets. For instance, the basis LOCO corpus 39 provides 88 million words of conspiracy and mainstream documents, allowing lexical feature analysis. Moreover, WICO Text 43 and the Hoaxes and Hidden Agendas dataset 42 target specific topics, such as COVID-19, 5G, and climate change CTs, offering text annotated for stance and topic analyses. More recently, the XAI-DisInfodemics dataset 32 introduced a distinction between ’critical’ and ’conspiratorial’ narratives on Telegram, and the work by Hoseini et al. 24 investigated the globalization of the QAnon conspiracy theory on the same platform. Despite the importance of these resources and tools for training binary classifiers (e.g., 46 ; 10 ), they typically treat conspiracy theories as a classification label or a topic. However, recent studies on annotation reliability suggest that this binary approach is fraught with subjectivity. 20 argued the nuanced linguistic differences required to distinguish fake news from satire. 40 found that distinguishing conspiracy texts from mainstream ones is difficult without precise definitions of belief manifestation. Similarly, 23 demonstrated that even experts struggle to agree on binary labels, showing that the complexity of conspiratorial discourse requires a more nuanced, structural representation than simple labels can provide. For this reason, the use of semiotics as a methodological perspective for the study of CT is convenient. Past works have considered the semio-technological structures and codes of CTs 16 ; their logic of signification 37 ; CT as communicative phenomenon (re)constructing social

Read the complete text