Probabilistic theories stable under teleportation

Lionel J. Dmello, David Gross · 2026

Read Probabilistic theories stable under teleportation by Lionel J. Dmello, David Gross (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-21347.txt.

Introduction

Dmello and Gross classify probabilistic theories whose Bell inequality value stays stable under teleportation rounds. A long-standing question asks why nature does not reach the algebraic maximum of Bell violations. Iterated Bell tests, with entanglement swapping between rounds, make large violations harder to sustain. The authors earlier gave a theory sustaining the maximum value of four. Here they classify all general probabilistic theories with this stability. The problem reduces to a representation condition with exactly seven solutions.

Catalog record

CREATORLionel J. Dmello, David Gross
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE68521
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.21347

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Probabilistic theories stable under teleportation Lionel J. Dmello, David Gross Abstract A long-standing problem in the foundations of quantum mechanics is to identify a physical principle that explains why algebraically maximal violations of Bell inequalities can generally not be achieved in Nature. One recently proposed approach considers iterated Bell tests , where a Bell test is performed on a state that has undergone several rounds of entanglement swapping. Obtaining large violations in this scenario is more demanding, because it requires a theory to have both highly entangled states and highly entangled measurements. It has been conjectured that the maximal quantum mechanical Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH)-value of 2 ​ 2 2\sqrt{2} might be optimal for any probabilistic theory which, like quantum mechanics, maintains its CHSH-value after an arbitrary number of rounds of entanglement swapping. However, in a previous paper, we have exhibited a first example of a probabilistic theory that can sustain a CHSH value of 4 4 in this setting. In this work, further investigating this property, we give a classification of all general probabilistic theories (GPTs) whose CHSH value is stable in the above sense. The problem reduces to a representation-theoretic condition that allows for exactly seven solutions. The GPT from our previous work showed some counter-intuitive features, e.g. that the local state space had a higher dimension than seemed necessary to realize CHSH tests. The classification shows that this is necessarily so. Along the way, we generalize the concept of self-testing to GPTs. I Introduction The search for physical principles that single out quantum mechanics (QM) among descriptions of Nature is a long-standing problem in the foundations of QM. The seminal work of John S. Bell Bell 1964 , and the subsequent Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) experiment Clauser et al. 1969 , established contextuality as a principle that rules out classical descriptions of Nature in favour of QM. So far, realizations of the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) experiment Aspect et al. 1982 ; Weihs et al. 1998 ; Rowe et al. 2001 have shown that Nature is at least as contextual as predicted by QM, i.e., they achieve a CHSH value of 2\sqrt{2} , which is also the maximal value for any quantum strategy (Tsirelson’s bound Cirel’son 1980 ). What is still lacking is a physical principle that rules out theories (like boxworld Popescu and Rohrlich 1994 ) which predict a larger CHSH value than QM while still being consistent with the assumptions of the CHSH experiment. There is a rich body of research exploring this problem Pawłowski et al. 2009 ; Miklin and Pawłowski 2021 ; Fritz et al. 2013 ; Hardy 2001 ; D’Ariano et al. 2019 ; Wilce 2018 ; Brassard et al. 2006 ; Linden et al. 2007 ; Navascués and Wunderlich 2010 . Many such works are based on the following observation: Violations of Bell inequalities predicted by QM tend to be, in general, strictly smaller than the algebraically allowed maximum. Thus it is conceivable that understanding the origin of this discrepancy leads to a physical principle that explains it. Weilenmann and Colbeck have recently proposed the adaptive CHSH game Weilenmann and Colbeck 2020a ; Weilenmann and Colbeck 2020b as a task that may explain this discrepancy. They conjecture that the biggest CHSH value allowed in the adaptive CHSH game is 2\sqrt{2} , and that the same value is recovered in the usual CHSH experiment because it is a special case of the former. The adaptive CHSH game involves performing entanglement swapping before the CHSH test. Thus it probes the strength of correlations supported by both bipartite states and bipartite effects. The (convex) sets describing states and measurements are dual to each other. Thus, expanding one set, in order to reach stronger correlations, inevitably diminishes the other. In this regard, QM strikes a particular balance, which is why it appears reasonable to conjecture that QM would be optimal for the adaptive CHSH game. In fact, QM has a stronger property: There exist quantum strategies for which the CHSH value is preserved not only after one round of entanglement swapping, but also after an arbitrary number of rounds. This property is highly constraining, in the sense that many known examples of general probabilistic theories (GPTs) fail to exhibit it. However, in our previous work Dmello et al. 2024 we constructed a GPT called oblate stabilizer theory (OST), which not only has this feature, but can also achieve a CHSH value of 4 . Thus, in view of OST, it is unclear exactly what kind of constraints this property imposes on GPTs. In this work we deduce these constraints and as a result classify GPTs with this property. This classification also sheds light on various other aspects such as the resonablilty of the assumption of local tomography and the existence of redundant degrees of freedom in OST. In the process of obtaining the main result we also generalize the notion of self-testing to GPTs. I.1 General Probabilistic Theories General probabilistic theories (GPTs) Segal 1947 ; Ludwig 1967 ; Ludwig 1968 ; Dähn 1968 ; Stolz 1969 ; Stolz 1971 ; Davies and Lewis 1970 ; Barrett 2007 ; Plávala 2023 is a framework that allows us to describe correlations that are compatible with operationally motivated assumptions (e.g. no-signaling), but are not necessarily realized in QM. The goal of such a framework is to study the observations of QM in a broader setting in order to extract the underlying physical principles governing them. In this work we adopt the GPT formalism (with minor modifications) from our previous work (Ref. Dmello et al. 2024 ). Here we provide an overview of the formalism and the modifications. For a more detailed description, please refer to Sec. I and Sec. II of Dmello et al. 2024 . For a general overview of the GPT formalism we refer the reader to Plávala 2023 . We assume that a GPT is specified by • A finite-dimensional real vector space V . • A collection of closed, pointed convex cones 1 1 1 A convex cone is said to be closed if it contains all it’s limit points with respect to some topology. In the present case, since we work with finite dimensional real vector spaces, we take the standard topology. A convex cone P is said to be pointed if P\cap-P=\{0\} . , \displaystyle\forall n\in\mathbb{N},\mathcal{P}^{(n)}\subseteq V^{\otimes n}, where V^{\otimes n} is the standard n -fold tensor product of V . • A distinguished element \underline{1} in the relative interior 2 2 2 The relative interior of a convex cone is the interior of the cone with the ambient space taken to be the affine hull of the cone. of \mathcal{P}^{(1)} . We call \mathcal{P}^{(n)} the effect cones and \underline{1} the unit effect . The effects model measurement outcomes, in the sense that the effect e encodes the probability of obtaining the outcome labelled by e . The unit effect in particular, models the trivial measurement, which encodes the fact that in every experiment some outcome must occur. Therefore, a set of effects \{e_{i}\}_{i=1}^{m}\subseteq\mathcal{P}^{(n)} defines a measurement if, \displaystyle\sum_{i=1}^{m}e_{i}=\underline{1}^{\otimes n}. In this formalism, states are viewed as linear functionals on effects. To this end let (\mathcal{P}^{(n)})^{\prime}\subseteq(V^{\otimes n})^{*} be the polar dual 3 3 3 The polar dual P^{\prime}

Read the complete text