Revisiting the Excess of Bar-like Structures in TNG50 Early-type Galaxies: Consistency and Tension with Observations 2026 Revisiting the Excess of Bar-like Structures in TNG50 Early-type Galaxies: Consistency and Tension with Observations – References

Hangci Du, Yougang Wang, Junqiang Ge · 2026

Read Revisiting the Excess of Bar-like Structures in TNG50 Early-type Galaxies: Consistency and Tension with Observations 2026 Revisiting the Excess of Bar-like Structures in TNG50 Early-type Galaxies: Consistency and Tension with Observations – References by Hangci Du, Yougang Wang, Junqiang Ge (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-21279.txt.

Introduction

Du and co-authors revisit the excess of bar-like structures in TNG50 early-type galaxies. A morphology agnostic census finds these features in about three quarters of dispersion dominated galaxies. They are not prolate rotators. Instead, they are real non-axisymmetric instabilities with coherent but slow pattern speeds. The structures are longer and slower than bars in late-type galaxies. Their histories show they began as fast bars in gas rich discs at higher redshift. Quenching and friction slowed and stretched them into fossil bars.

Catalog record

CREATORHangci Du, Yougang Wang, Junqiang Ge
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE72132
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.21279

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Revisiting the Excess of Bar-like Structures in TNG50 Early-type Galaxies: Consistency and Tension with Observations 2026 Revisiting the Excess of Bar-like Structures in TNG50 Early-type Galaxies: Consistency and Tension with Observations – References Hangci Du, Yougang Wang, Junqiang Ge Abstract The IllustrisTNG simulation suite, particularly TNG50, was reported to have generated a notable population of elongated, bar-like structures within galaxies classified as Early-Type Galaxies (ETGs). In this work, we revisit the nature of these structures at z = 0 z=0 using a morphology-agnostic census. We find that these features are ubiquitous ( f bar ∼ 75 − 80 % f_{\rm bar}\sim 75-80\% ) in dispersion-dominated galaxies ( D / T < 0.2 D/T<0.2 ) in TNG50-1. They are not prolate rotators (rotating around their long axis), but genuine non-axisymmetric instabilities characterized by coherent, albeit slow, pattern speeds. Unlike the fast bars found in Late-Type Galaxies, these bar-like structures in ETGs are physically longer ( ≳ 3 \gtrsim 3 kpc), rotate significantly slower ( Ω p ≲ 20 \Omega_{p}\lesssim 20 km s -1 kpc -1 ), and reside in red, gas-poor, dispersion-dominated systems. By tracing the evolutionary history of these systems, we demonstrate that such structures originate as typical fast bars in gas-richer discs at higher redshifts ( z ≳ 0.2 z\gtrsim 0.2 ). They survive the galaxy quenching phase, undergoing secular deceleration and lengthening due to dynamical friction, ultimately appearing as slow, fossilized rotators in the z = 0 z=0 red sequence. We conclude that the specific excess of bar-like structures in TNG50 ETGs likely reflects a combination of the imperfect baryonic physics of the simulation (over-producing these bar-like structures or their host ETGs) and a potential observational blind spot regarding long-lived, secularly evolved bars in hot stellar systems. 1 Introduction Stellar bars represent one of the most ubiquitous non-axisymmetric structures in the Universe and serve as fundamental drivers of galactic secular evolution. By redistributing angular momentum and driving gas inflows ( 47 ) , bars enhance central star formation, fuel supermassive black holes, and may eventually facilitate galaxy quenching ( 61 ; 32 ; 36 ) . Consequently, they play a pivotal role in reshaping the structural and chemical abundance distributions of galaxies ( 33 ) . There remains an ongoing debate within the community regarding the preferential properties of bar-hosting galaxies. Specifically, it is contested whether bars are more frequently associated with red, rotation-supported systems or with blue, dispersion-dominated hosts. Historically, the presence of bars has been inextricably linked to rotationally supported disc galaxies. Theoretical frameworks typically describe bar formation as a global instability within dynamically “cold", rotation-dominated stellar discs ( 86 ) , a process potentially inhibited by a significant central spheroidal component ( 63 ) . Accordingly, observational censuses have almost exclusively relied on morphological pre-selection, restricting samples to disc galaxies (e.g. via Sérsic index cuts or axis ratio criteria) and implicitly treating dispersion-dominated systems as naturally bar-free ( 54 ; 1 ; 55 , e.g.) . Consistent with this view, early studies reported a higher bar fraction in low-mass, blue disc galaxies ( 11 ; 1 ) . However, subsequent observations have challenged this picture, indicating that bars are more prevalent in more massive, red, and dispersion-supported galaxies ( 45 ; 55 ; 82 ; 20 ) . Furthermore, bar presence shows a significant anti-correlation with specific star formation rate and atomic hydrogen (H i ) gas fraction ( 17 ; 55 ; 15 ) . Attempts to reconcile these conflicting trends suggest that the bar distribution may be bimodal ( 59 ; 26 ; 58 ) , with a notable deficit of bars in intermediate-type or “green valley” galaxies ( 21 ) . Cosmological hydrodynamic simulations provide an invaluable laboratory for addressing these observational discrepancies, tracing the coupled evolution of discs, bulges, gas accretion, mergers, and feedback within a self-consistent \Lambda CDM framework. Nevertheless, early cosmological simulations frequently failed to reproduce the observed population of stellar bars—a challenge termed the “bar problem" ( 2 ; 65 , e.g.) . This deficit was typically attributed to excessive gravitational softening scales ( 65 ) and overly strong AGN feedback ( 35 ) . IllustrisTNG suite features optimized resolution and feedback mechanisms, enabling the robust capture of non-axisymmetric structures within a full cosmological context ( 34 ; 66 ; 60 ; 72 ) . These simulations have achieved remarkable success in reproducing observed galactic morphologies ( 70 ; 67 , e.g.) . Across IllustrisTNG, bars preferentially form in galaxies with early ( z\sim 0.5 – 1.5 ) disc assembly and older stellar populations ( 72 ; 71 ; 50 ) . Gas reservoir depletion is a critical prerequisite, with a threshold of f_{\rm gas}\lesssim 0.4 consistently identified as necessary for triggering instability ( 97 ; 98 ) . Once formed, bars act as engines of secular evolution, facilitating nuclear quenching via gas inflow and AGN fuelling ( 72 ; 41 ) , while their pattern speeds decrease in accordance with angular momentum exchange theory ( 79 ) . However, tensions still remain. Bars in TNG50 are systematically shorter than those in surveys like ATLAS 3D or MaNGA ( 96 ; 31 ) , which is partly attributed to wavelength-dependence of bar measurements ( 37 ) . We cannot rule out the imperfect-feedback effect ( 30 ) and other unknown mechanisms neither. Another tension between IllustrisTNG and observations, which remains underappreciated, is the prevalence of elongated, bar-like structures ( 68 ; 98 ) in Early-Type Galaxies (ETGs). This population of ETGs in TNG50 is originally reported by 68 . After their ETG pre-selection using cuts in the color-mass diagram, this odd populations resides in a “forbidden" region of the \lambda_{R}-\varepsilon diagram ( 13 , to the right of the magenta line defined by) . These galaxies exhibit high ellipticity despite low rotational support, appear redder than the average population at fixed mass, and possess centrally elongated morphologies distinct from classical discs. This feature is not observed (as shown in 68 section 5.2) in previous hydrodynamical simulations such as EAGLE ( 92 ) , Magneticum ( 76 ) and Illustris. To reconcile the simulation with observations, 68 opted to excise these objects from their analysis by applying an axis ratio cut of b/a<0.6 . While this removes the tension, simply discarding a subset of the simulated population without a clear physical justification risks masking potential insights into the galaxy formation model. The physical nature of these objects remains debated. 68 hypothesized that they may represent physically realistic systems that are “failed discs"—galaxies that began to form a disc but whose evolution was disrupted by violent dynamics or intense feedback. Similarly, 98 identified a population of “bar-like galaxies" in TNG50 characterized by a rotating bar without an accompanying extended disc. They distinguished these from the classical “bars embedded in discs" studied in TNG by other authors ( 72 ; 97 ; 96 , e.g.) . Consequently, we adopt a morphology-agnostic strategy, diverging from notable prior studies of barred galaxies in TNG50 ( 72 ; 97 ; 96 ; 71 , e.g.) . Those studies typically applied pre-filters to mimic observational constraints, effectively assuming a priori that barred galaxies must be disc galaxies. Furthermore, unlike 68 and 98 , who limited

Read the complete text